MA Thesis
China Foreign Affairs University
外交学院 2016 届硕士学位论文
Translation Study on The Three-Body Problem from the
Perspective of Skopos Theory
目的论视角下的《三体》英译研究
MA Thesis
Submitted to the Department of English and International Studies
in partial fulfillment of the requirements
for the degree of Master of Arts in Translation Studies
Major
:
Foreign Linguistics and Applied Linguistics
专业:外国语言学与应用语言学
Focus
:
Translation Studies
方向:翻译研究
Supervisor
:
Prof. Wu Qingjun
导师:吴庆军教授
Writer
:
Zhang Xiang
研究生:张翔
Beijing
May, 2016
答辩日期:2016 年 5 月 27
独创性说明
本人声明所呈交的学位论文是本人在导师指导下进行的研究工
作及取得的研究成果。据我所知,除了文中特别加以标注和致谢的地
方外,论文中不包含其他人已经发表或撰写过的研究成果,也不包含
为获得外交学院
或其他教育机构的学位或证书而使用过的材料。与我
一同工作的同志对本研究所做的任何贡献均已在论文中作了明确的
说明并表示谢意。
学位论文作者签名:
签字日期:
年
月
日
ii
Acknowledgement
The completion of this paper marks an end to my three years of graduate studies
in China Foreign Affairs University. During the past three years, I have received much
help from many people.
My deepest appreciation goes first and foremost to my supervisor Prof. Wu
Qingjun. Prof. Wu is a knowledgeable and kind scholar. He has provided me with
valuable advice in choosing the thesis topic and organizing the content. His
meticulous academic attitude has left a deep impression on me.
I also want to thank other teachers who have taught and helped me during the
three years. I wouldn’t have achieved what I have got today without their guidance
and help. They have set a good example to me as to becoming a responsible and
reliable person.
My appreciation also goes to the authors of the books, journal articles and papers
I have referred to or got inspirations from. Their ideas help make this thesis a
well-rounded one.
Last but not least, I want to thank my family. My parents and sister have always
been there for me whenever I get frustrated. They would talk with me on the phone
for as long as one hour and I really appreciate and enjoy their understanding of and
support for me.
iii
Abstract
The Three-Body Problem
is a science fiction with distinct Chinese characteristics.
The translation study of
The Three-Body Problem
under Skopos theory is aimed at
finding out if the translation strategies adopted meet the requirements of Skopos
theory and how can the theory guide literary translation practice.
In the analysis of the translation, questions with respect to the skopos intended for
the TT, translation strategies and the relationship between the three rules of Skopo
theory are answered. And the answers constitute the main clue of this paper. Along the
main clue, much attention is paid to studying the contents characteristic of
The
Three-Body Problem
and these contents include:the background of the Cultural
Revolution, the use of technology terms, the description of science fiction scenes, the
borrowing of images of Chinese historical figures and the vivid depiction of
characters. To make the translation study of the abovementioned contents convincing,
examples are necessary. Through examples, the translation strategies and their relation
with Skopos theory can be analyzed. The conclusion of the study is that the
translation of
The Three-Body Problem
is consistent with Skopos theory and can
provide inspirations for other fiction translations.
Keywords: Liu Cixin,
The Three-Body Problem
, Skopos theory, translation strategies
iv
摘要
《三体》是一部有中国特色的科幻小说。以目的论为指导进行《三体》英译
研究旨在分析译者翻译策略是否符合目的论及其在文学翻译中的实践意义。
《三体》英译的目的为何,译者的翻译策略是否符合目的论,译者在翻译过
程中如何处理目的论三原则,即目的原则、连贯原则,忠实原则之间关系,以上
问题构成翻译研究的主线。在具体研究过程中,具有《三体》特色的内容是重要
的分析对象。《三体》特色内容包含:小说的文革背景,小说对科技术语的运用,
对科幻场景的描写,对中国历史人物重新塑造,对人物形象的鲜明刻画。以翻译
目的论为指导研究上述内容的英译需要大量翻译实例,需要研究译者的翻译策
略,并且分析这些策略如何运用和体现目的论。《三体》的英译符合翻译目的论,
可以为其他文学翻译实践提供借鉴。
关键词:刘慈欣;《三体》;目的论;翻译策略
v
Contents
Acknowledgement ......................................................................................................... ii
Abstract ........................................................................................................................ iii
摘要
............................................................................................................................... iv
Chapter 1 Introduction ................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Research Background ....................................................................................... 1
1.1.1 About the Translator ................................................................................... 1
1.2 Significance of the Research ............................................................................. 2
1.3 Research Methodology and Structure of the Thesis ......................................... 3
Chapter 2 Literature Review .......................................................................................... 5
2.1 Studies on
The Three-Body Problem
................................................................. 5
2.2 Studies on the Translation of
The Three-Body Problem
................................... 6
2.3 Studies on Skopos Theory ................................................................................. 7
2.4 Limitations of Current Studies .......................................................................... 9
Chapter 3 Skopos Theory as a Theoretical Framework ............................................... 10
3.1 The History of Functionalist Skopos Theory .................................................. 10
3.2 Development of Functionalist Skopos Theory ............................................... 11
3.2.1 Text Typology ........................................................................................... 11
3.2.2 Hans Vermeer’s Skopos Theory ............................................................... 11
3.2.3 Translational Action ................................................................................. 12
3.2.4 Function plus Loyalty ............................................................................... 13
3.3 The Three Basic Rules of Skopos Theory ....................................................... 14
3.3.1 Skopos Rule .............................................................................................. 14
3.3.2 Coherence Rule and Fidelity Rule............................................................ 14
3.3.3 The Relationship between the Three Rules .............................................. 15
Chapter 4 Skopos, Strategies and Contents in the English Translation of
The
Three-Body Problem
.................................................................................................... 17
4.1 Skopos Designed for the Translation of
The Three-Body Problem
................ 17
4.2 An Overview of Translation Strategies under Skopos Theory ........................ 19
4.2.1 Translation Strategies Abiding by the Skopos Rule ................................. 19
4.2.2 Translation Strategies Abiding by the Coherence Rule ............................ 21 vi
4.2.3 Translation Strategies Abiding by the Fidelity Rule ................................ 23
4.3 Translation Study on Contents Characteristic of
The Three-Body Problem
... 25
4.3.1 Translation of Science Related Information ............................................. 25
4.3.2 Translation of Historical Facts ................................................................. 30
4.3.3 Translation of the Cultural Revolution Scenes ......................................... 36
4.3.4 Translation of Descriptions of Characters ................................................ 41
Chapter 5 Conclusion ................................................................................................... 45
Bibliography ................................................................................................................ 48
1
Chapter 1 Introduction
1.1 Research Background
The Three-Body Problem
is a masterpiece by Liu Cixin. It received the Chinese
Science Fiction Galaxy Award in 2006. In 2014, the English translation by Ken Liu
was published by Tor Books and won the 2015 Hugo Award for Best Novel, the first
for Asian science fiction writers. The news sent a strong shockwave to the science
fiction community in China. Although Liu had been considered one of the best
science fiction writers in China, it’s still surprising he could win the award. The
reasons are two-fold. First, generally speaking, science fiction has been peripheral in
China for long. In spite of the popularity it enjoys among young readers, it hasn’t
been accepted as mainstream literature; hence it lags far behind the West. Therefore,
it’s a rare thing that a Chinese science fiction can win the highest award. Second,
The
Three-Body Problem
was not originally written in English. It was translated
English. This fact adds to the difficulty for
The Three-Body Problem
to get popular on
foreign markets. Yet, for all this, Liu Cixin’s masterpiece has won applause among
foreign readers, with 61% of readers giving five star customer reviews on
Amazon.com.
China now is embarking on a cause to make its culture go global. It has to be
admitted that some efforts haven’t met the intended purpose, because foreign
countries especially western countries are instinctively averse to any Chinese
government efforts in this regard and consider them as ideology export. The success
of
The Three-Body Problem
may provide useful experience to help Chinese culture go
global.
This thesis focuses its attention on the translation of
The Three-Body Problem
,
because the translation of the book plays a crucial role in the market success of the
book. How the translation was so well done and what inspirations we can draw to
better translate other Chinese books? The answers to the above two questions may
contribute to the cause of Chinese culture going global.
1.1.1 About the Translator
Ken Liu is a Chinese American science-fiction writer, poet, lawyer, and computer 2
programmer. Like Liu Cixin, he is also a part-time but productive science fiction
writer. His short story \"The Paper Menagerie\", which told a story of how a
second-generation Chinese American came to appreciate his mother’s love, swept the
Nebula, Hugo, and World Fantasy Award in 2012. His short story, \"Mono no aware\"
which told a story of a 25 years old Japanese survivor after the destruction of the earth
moved to another planet, won the 2013 Hugo.
Ken Liu was born in 1976 in Lanzhou, China and immigrated to the United
States when he was 8 years old. At the age of 8, he composed his first science fiction,
which might be the start of his love for science fiction.
Liu has translated many Chinese short stories English, but
The Three-Body
Problem
is the first time Ken Liu translating novel. It’s a different experience and he
was confronted with several challenges. He had to firstly get a thorough
understanding of all the topics in the book, for example the jargons of science and
technology as well as some historical events, like the Cultural Revolution. The second
challenge is to strike a proper balance between preserving the flavor of the source text
(hereinafter ST) and making the TT appealing to readers.
Below are some excerpts from the translator’s postscript which well reflects Ken
Liu’s thought on translation.
Translating another writer’s work is a heavy responsibility. It’s almost like
being asked to care of someone’s child
In translating, my goal is to act as a faithful interpreter, preserving as much of
the original’s nuances of meaning as possible without embellishment or omission.
(Ken Liu 2014:397-399)
1.2 Significance of the Research
The study on the translation of
The Three-Body Problem
is designed to make due
contributions in the following three aspects.
First, this study will add to the completeness and richness of relevant studies on
the translation of
The Three-Body Problem
. As the translation coming out only
recently in 2014, only a few researches and studies on the translation can be found.
Since
The Three-Body Problem
is a very successful case of Chinese book being
accepted by foreigners, there must be something notable in its English translation.
Second, this study will provide some experience for the successful translation of 3
other Chinese works, thereby contributing to Chinese culture going global. There are
many English translations of Chinese books failing to attract foreign readers.
Sometimes, it is not that the translation quality is flawed or the translators are
unqualified. There is some room for improvement in their translation strategies. One
reason to explain the success of the translation of
The Three-Body Problem
is that the
translator has always met the skopos of the translation, knowing that in order to get
popular on foreign market, the translation should read appealing to foreign readers.
Bearing this in mind, the translator can adopt effective and targeted translation
strategies. And the efforts paid off. To make other translated Chinese works accepted
on foreign markets, there is something we can learn from the case of
The Three-Body
Problem.
Third, the research will verify the applicability of Skopos theory in translation
activities. Skopos theory was put forward in the 1970s and has undergone four
development stages. The theory provides a new perspective to look at translation and
a new approach to do translation. Yet, the applicability of the theory has been under
attack. This thesis, by using Skopos theory as theoretical framework, is verification to
the applicability of the theory. In this thesis, we will look at how the three rule of
Skopos theory (skopos rule, coherence rule and fidelity rule) are applied in the
analysis of the translation of
The Three-Body Problem
. It’s hoped that this thesis can
inject a little impetus to the development of Skopos theory.
1.3 Research Methodology and Structure of the Thesis
As the title indicates, the thesis will use Skopos theory as the guiding theory to
examine the translation of
The Three-Body Problem
. Apart from this, the thesis will
mainly use three methods to conduct the analysis.
First, this thesis is a textual study on the translation of
The Three-Body Problem
.
Textual study is an effective way in translation studies, because with detailed and
thorough analysis they focus on one certain subject. This thesis will some
aspects characteristic of
The Three-Body Problem
, such as the science and fantasy part,
as the objects of analysis and make a thorough and detailed investigation how the
rules of Skopos theory are observed. Second, this thesis adopts a descriptive approach
to look at the translation. Descriptive method is common when it comes to discussions 4
under the Skopos theory framework. It combines the translation theory well with the
practice. Third, the thesis also uses a quantitative approach to examine some of the
translation strategies adopted by the translator. For example, the thesis makes a table
to show how many times certain translation strategies are used in the TT.
This thesis is comprised of five chapters: Chapter 1, Introduction; Chapter 2,
Literature Review; Chapter 3,Theoretical Framework; Chapter 4, Skopos, Strategies
and Contents in English Translation of
The Three-Body Problem
; Chapter 5,
Conclusion.
The first chapter gives an introduction to the research background, research
significance, methodology and the thesis structure. Chapter II is a literature review,
in which current studies on
The Three Body-Problem
and its translation and Skopos
theory are explored. Chapter III establishes the theoretical framework of the thesis.
This chapter gives an analysis of Skopos theory and elaborates on the relationship
between the rules of skops, coherence and fidelity. Chapter IV is a specific
translation analysis of Ken Liu’s translation of
The Three-Body Problem
based on
Skopos theory. This chapter contains three main sections: the first section defines the
skopos of the translation intended by the initiator; the second section investigates the
translation strategies the translator adopts with Skopos theory and the third section is
a detailed analysis of the translation from several salient aspects, still with Skopos
theory as an evaluation tool. Chapter V makes a conclusion of this thesis. In this
chapter, a summary of the contributions and limitation of this thesis will be made.
5
Chapter 2 Literature Review
2.1 Studies on
The Three-Body Problem
Science fiction has been considered as children’s literature and hasn’t been
accepted as mainstream literature. As a result, not so many studies have been done on
science fiction. But the high fame and quality of
The Three-Body Problem
make it an
exception. There are many papers on cnki.net studying the fiction.
Current studies on The Three-Body Problem mainly focus on two aspects. The
first is to elaborate on science fiction with
The Three-Body Problem
as an example.
The second is a detailed analysis of the themes and connotations behind
The Three
Body-Problem.
For the first aspect, many researches have been done to explore the situation of
science fiction in China, and the future trend of science fiction. Han Jun(2013) stated
that the success of
The Three-Body Problem
is an individual case, and that the overall
situation of China’s science fiction still faces challenges. The prospect of China’s
science fiction is not a bright one. The reasons according to Han Jun include: the
failure to become mainstream literature, the impact from audiovisual media and the
hindering from literature utilitarianism. Han Jun’s view on the overall situation is
echoed by Wu Yan. Wu Yan proposed several suggestions on the development of
science fiction. He (2016) said science fiction writers should be given opportunities to
learn and improve their skills and also he encouraged people with mixed disciplines to
write science fictions. Jiang Xiaoyuan (2015) used
The Three-Body Problem
as an
example to demonstrate the future trend of science fiction. He (2015) said that the
development of science fiction has undergone two stages and now is entering a new
stage. In the beginning, science fiction was a strong advocate of science and
technology, but after Jules Verne, most science fictions were written to show the
damage of science and technology. Yet, the third stage, to which
The Three-Body
Problem
belongs, focuses on the reflection of science and technology.
For the second aspect, Gu Ye (2014) believed that the universal wandering
consciousness is an important theme of Liu’s writings. And Liu Cixin’s depiction of
characters and his narrative methods are both affected by this consciousness. In Gu’s
mind, the universal wandering consciousness refers to the ultimate goal of Liu’s 6
science fiction, which is survival and pursuit. Gu (2014) attributed this writing
thought to Liu’s growing-up experience, the influence of Russian literature and the
试阅到此结束,如需查看全部内容请购买正版文献。如因学习需要阅览全文,请联系站长。