学校
代妈
1
0345
?研 究 类 璧?
基 础
研 究??
.
.
r
'
?
二
’
-
%
?
—
?
-
一??
^
)
嵌
> 砰
訖
大
f??
Z H
E
I
I
A N G?
N O
R
M
Studies on the Translation and Dissemination of Contemporary
Chinese Science Fiction from the Perspective of Communication
Studies
传播学视角下的中国当代科幻文学译介研究
A Thesis Presented to
The College of Foreign Languages
Zhejiang Normal University
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
For the Degree of Master of Arts
in
Foreign Language and Literature
By
Lin Fangyu
Under the Supervision of
Associate Professor
Chen Fangrong
Zhejiang Normal University
May 2019
I
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
First and foremost, my sincere appreciation goes to my supervisor Professor Chen
Fangrong, for her wholehearted tutoring and constant encouragement during my
writing of this thesis. She gave me enlightening advice and helped me probe deeply
research topic and finally conceptualize this thesis. And for each draft, she would
go through carefully and provide detailed comments. I am greatly indebted to my
supervisor, without her inspiration and instruction, it would be impossible for me to
complete this MA thesis.
Besides, I would express my thankfulness to all the respectful teachers in the
College of Foreign Languages in Zhejiang Normal University. Their intelligent
lectures enlightened me in understanding the translation studies, as well as the true
essence of doing research.
Last but not the least, I also owe great gratitude to my family and friends. My
family always grace me with love and understanding, they have been my solid support
while I was in frustration and worries. My friends were always ready to help and
encourage me, for which I really appreciated.
II
ABSTRACT
Contemporary Chinese science fiction (CCSF) is characteristic of its modern
spirit and universality, so the translation and dissemination of which would be
beneficial to the construction of China’s national image. Several works like
Three-Body
trilogy,
Folding Beijing
have won international awards, which could be
the symbols of CCSF’s going global success. The earliest English translation of
Chinese science fiction (CSF) was published in 1970. And the first English translation
of contemporary Chinese science fiction appeared in 1984. Since then more than 100
English editions of CSF have been published overseas, currently most of them are
contemporary works. Gradually more scholars began to attach academic attention to
contemporary Chinese science fiction (CCSF), but few of them have done a
systematic research on translation and dissemination on this topic.
Considering that there is an inherent connection between translation and
communication, communication studies can provide translation study a more dynamic
and comprehensive perspective. This thesis will apply Lasswell’s 5W communication
model to analyze the translation and dissemination of contemporary Chinese science
fiction from the aspects of the translators, the ion of content and translation
skills, the publishing channels, the audience and the reception effect, trying to explore
the features in CCSF’s going global. According to the analysis of this research, the
current quite successful situation of CCSF can be attributed to several reasons,
including the excellent translators with diversified background, the careful ion
of original works and translation skills, the combination of digital and physica
channels, as well as the comprehensive concern for readers. It’s also worth to be
mentioned that the great reception effect begins to give feedback to China’s own
science fiction development. Then this thesis also goes with a case study on
Invisible
Planets
, which would serve as a more explicit example to discuss about the
advantages and deficiencies. Therefore, the whole thesis summarized the translation
III
and dissemination of contemporary Chinese science fiction, aiming to enrich the
overall studies on Chinese literature translation, also with the good hope to provide
some valid references for the “going out” of Chinese culture.
KEY WORDS
:
contemporary Chinese science fiction, communication studies,
5W communication model, translation and dissemination,
Invisible Planets
IV
摘
要
中国科幻文学所蕴含的普世性与时代性,对于中国文化形象构建具有正面意
义。近年来,《三体》《北京折叠》等优秀作品相继折桂“雨果奖”,更是这一
文学类型“走出去”的成功证明。然而目前在翻译研究领域,科幻翻译依旧存在
较大的研究空间,其中针对中国科幻作品外译的系统梳理性研究尤为匮乏。自
1970
年中国第一部科幻作品、
1984
年第一部中国当代科幻作品英译出版以来,
至今已有逾百余部中国作品得以译介海外。鉴于目前得到译介的中国科幻作品中
1949
年后创作的作品占多数,本研究将主要选取当代科幻文学的译介情况作为
研究对象。
翻译与传播存在着内在联系,传播学也可为翻译研究提供一个更为整体、动
态的视角。本研究拟在传播学理论的观照下,具体通过拉斯韦尔
5W
模式,结合
量化与质性研究对中国当代科幻文学自
1984
年在海外第一次出版后的外译情况
进行分析,即从译介主体、译介内容、译介途径、译介受众以及译介效果五个方
面入手,分析目前中国科幻文学对外译介具体情况。研究表明,多样化背景的优
秀译者、甄选的优秀原作与巧妙的翻译方法、线上线下结合的出版途径、针对读
者的全方位考虑都促成了中国当代科幻文学在英语世界的有效传播,同时良好的
海外传播效果正在对中国当代科幻的本土发展进行反哺,中国科幻正在经历又一
次发展高潮。本文通过对中国当代科幻文学在英语世界的译介经验进行分析总
结,试图充实中国文学外译研究,以期对整体的中国文学“走出去”提供一些有
效的借鉴。
关键词:
中国当代科幻文学;传播学;
5W
模式;译介;《看不见的星球》
V
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................ I
ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................. II
摘
要
.................................................................................................................. IV
CONTENTS .................................................................................................................. V
Chapter One Introduction .............................................................................................. 1
1.1 Research Background ....................................................................................... 1
1.2 Research Significance ....................................................................................... 4
1.3 Research Methodology ..................................................................................... 6
1.4 Thesis Structure ................................................................................................ 6
Chapter Two Literature Review ..................................................................................... 8
2.1 An Introduction to Chinese Science Fiction ..................................................... 8
2.2 Previous Studies on Chinese Science Fiction ................................................... 9
2.3 Previous Studies on the Translation and Dissemination of Contemporary
Chinese Science Fiction (CCSF) .......................................................................... 11
Chapter Three Theoretical Basis .................................................................................. 17
3.1 A Brief Introduction to Communication Studies ............................................ 17
3.2 The Connection Between Communication Studies and Translation Studies .. 18
3.3 Lasswell’s 5W Communication Model ........................................................... 20
Chapter Four Translation and Dissemination of Contemporary Chinese Science
Fiction ................................................................................................................... 22
4.1 Who--Three Types of Translators ................................................................... 22
4.1.1 Translators with SF Writing Experience ............................................... 22
4.1.2 Translators without Science Fiction Creation Experience .................... 24
4.1.3 Self-Translators ..................................................................................... 24
4.2 What--The Selection of Text and Translation Strategies ................................ 25
4.2.1 The Selection of Original Text .............................................................. 26
4.2.2 The Selection of Translation Strategies to Scientific Content .............. 28
4.3 In Which Channel--Printed and Digital .......................................................... 33
4.3.1 Printed Publication ................................................................................ 33
4.3.2 Digital Publication ................................................................................ 34
4.4 To Whom--Features and Efforts ...................................................................... 35
4.4.1 The Features of SF Readers .................................................................. 36
4.4.2 The Efforts Made for Readers ............................................................... 37
4.5 What Effect--Effects From Three Aspects ...................................................... 37
4.5.1 The Sales and Visitor Volume of Chinese Science Fiction ................... 38
4.5.2 The Awards............................................................................................ 38
4.5.3 The Feedback to Chinese Science Fiction Development ...................... 40
Chapter Five A Case Study of
Invisible Planets
.......................................................... 42
5.1 An Introduction to
Invisible Planets
............................................................... 42
5.2 An Analysis of the Translation and Dissemination of
Invisible Planets
Based
on 5W Model ........................................................................................................ 43
VI
5.3 The Highlight Features and the Deficiencies .................................................. 47
Chapter Six: Conclusion .............................................................................................. 49
References .................................................................................................................... 53
Appendix: The Publication of Contemporary Chinese Science Fiction (1984-2019)..59
攻读学位期间发表的学术论文
.................................................................................. 78
浙江师范大学学位论文诚信承诺书
.......................................................................... 79
浙江师范大学学位论文独创性声明
.......................................................................... 80
学位论文使用授权声明
.............................................................................................. 80
Chapter One Introduction
1
Chapter One Introduction
1.1 Research Background
Nowadays the competition between different countries has become even more
intense and complicated, which has involved many aspects. Among them, the
competition about culture infiltration has become more and more important and
urgent. Since culture can be considered to be the reflection of one country’s inner
spirit
and
has great meaning in constructing a positive international image, which
could also be necessary for China’s development. What’s more, the great
achievements that China has made in economy and the improvement of country’s
status are obvious to the world. However, the general impression towards China’s
culture is still backward, which can partly be attributed to the ineffective
communication. Thus there is absolutely an unbalance of development between them.
Fortunately, the Chinese government has already recognized this problem and
has already made several efforts to improve matters, one of which should be the
translation and promotion of Chinese literature, or “the strategy of going out”. There
is no doubt that this project has already achieved much success, but there are still
many gaps between the reality and expectation. The amount of translation has been
increased in each year, while the promotion effect hasn’t been improved as expected.
Thus it’s urgent for scholars to attach importance to the issue how to promote the
effect of translation. Among all the literary works being translated, contemporary
literature has always been considered to be a hot issue. The reason might be that
contemporary literature comes from the time when we are. Since current readers are
familiar with materials from this time, it could be easier for them to make sense of
what the literature wants to express. The same situation happens to overseas readers,
contemporary literature would be more reader-friendly for them. Also, the
introduction and dissemination of excellent contemporary literature would be a god
way to show how China has innovated with the times. Besides, the literature finished
Chapter One Introduction
2
after 1949 can be classified contemporary literature. And the works after 1949
served as the majority of Chinese science fiction being translated. Thus this thesis
decides to choose contemporary Chinese science fiction as study sample.
Comparing to other genres of literature, science fiction can be considered to be
a new-born one. It has been just about one hundred years since it first appeared in
China. As a carrier of western culture and new ideological trend, science fiction was
introduced by Liang Qichao and other scholars China. Since science fiction
contains the power which could transcend the reality and tradition, it can be the
suitable way to convey the spirit, feeling of intellectuals and be the most innovative
literature genre, it would regain its place in mainstream soon.. (Wu, 2010:25) So it’s
of great necessity for scholars to focus on the significance of science fiction
translation and the studies of it. Moreover, the studies of contemporary Chinese
science fiction translation would be beneficial to the understanding of the relationship
between CCSF translation and the social progress,and to guide the practice of Chinese
science fiction translation and promote the science fiction culture communication
between China and overseas. (Wang, 2015:33)
Since the science fiction in China doesn’t have a long historical standing, it still
has a long way to go in general. For example, the number of its creation group isn’t
large comparing to other literary genres. However, with such limited number of
writers, the number of Chinese science fiction being translated has increased
continuously these years. According to the data collected, the first translated CSF is
The Cat City
(
《猫城记》
)written by Lao She in 1932, being published overseas in
1970. The reason why there was such a long span between the 1932 and 1970 lies in
the unsupported social background. Because of the war and social instability, the
creation of science fiction was in stasis at that time, let alone the translation. After
liberation the creation group gradually regained their strength, the second translation
and publication of Chinese science fiction appeared in 1984,
Conjugal Happiness in the
Arms of Morpheu
written by Wei Yahua in 1982, translated by Wu Dingbo and published on
Amazing Stories
. Since 1984, there were several works being translated during the next
few years. However, the creation and translation suspended again during 1990s
Chapter One Introduction
3
because of the Rectification Movement. Especially the translation, which didn’t
regain its vitality until 2003. Since then, the development of contemporary Chinese
science fiction has been on the right track
This thesis will choose the translation works of contemporary Chinese science
fiction after 1984 as research samples, which includes short stories, novelettes, long
novels as well as anthologies. Though the number of works being translated wasn’t
large during 1984--2003, but translations of this period are still worthy of academic
attention. According to the data collected from ISFDB
1
, abundant works have been
translated and published since 1984. And the edition of publication included first print
and reprint. Here is a point needs to be clarified that some publisher would published
several different formats of one simple work, for example the e-book, the trade
paperback and the hardcover. While in this thesis, various formats of one work would
only be counted as one publication. Since 2011 the numbers of translated works have
been staying above 10. Especially in 2016 the number has reached its peak, including
the republished one, there were 54 works being translated and published. Thus in
terms of the number, Chinese science fiction translation has already stayed in a rising
stage. (see Table 1)
Table 1 The Numbers of Translated CCSF Works from 1984 to 2018
What’s more, with the good news that
The Three-Body Problem
and
Folding
Beijing
had won the Hugo Awards in succession, people begin to pay much more
1
ISFDB: The Internet Speculative Fiction Database, a community effort to catalog
works of science fiction, fantasy, and horror.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
系列1
Chapter One Introduction
4
attention on the development on contemporary Chinese science fiction, which can
also prove that the translation effort made is kind of effective. Considering that the
heated discussion upon how to improve the effect of Chinese literature “going out”,
the example of contemporary Chinese science fiction actually could provide a new
reference for scholars. This thesis is going to carry out a macro-visual and systematic
research on the translation and dissemination of CCSF, ranging from 1984 to this day.
The theoretical basis would be communication studies, or more specifically the
Lasswell’s 5W communication model. The specific factors that functioned in the
process of CCSF’s translation and dissemination would be studied, including the
translators, the choice of original text and translation strategies, the publishing
channels, the readers and the reception effects, trying to find out the features of them
and think about their applicable value to the improvement of overall Chinese literature
“going out”.
1.2 Research Significance
As this thesis mentioned above, the development of science fiction in China has
been in a positive situation and the future of which is also quite promising. With the
numerous efforts made by the science fiction group, the number of books published
domestically every year has increased, which will make sure a continuous vitality of
contemporary Chinese science fiction. In this way, with abundant creation enthusiasm,
excellent works can stand out and be translated. Actually, the scale of science fiction
creation group is not such great. However, comparing to such a compressed number
of writers, the number of works being translated is relatively great. And the question
is how has CCSF made such an improvement with limited resources? Scholars have
always dedicated to the question that how we could improve the situation of Chinese
culture going out, while CCSF’s recent achievement can be a really good example for
reference.
Moreover, at present there are already a few scholars have realized the academic
value of contemporary Chinese science fiction, but comparing that serious literature
Chapter One Introduction
5
translation has always been considered as the one that contains the most academic
value, the number of scholars dedicated to science fiction studies is not large.
However, it’s true that serious literature translation is really in its dilemma. Because
usually only scholars or someone who are superbly interested in Chinese culture
would read it and it’s too hard for normal foreign readers to understand. Many
scholars have also found out this situation, thus they have conducted several studies
on the translation of other literary genres, including children’s literature, genre
literature and even network literature. All these kinds of literature have their unique
features and have made success overseas. So exploring the experiences of more
literary kinds and sum up the advantages and deficiencies might be beneficial to the
promotion of overall Chinese culture going out.
This thesis will both focus on the translation and dissemination process, which
means that the whole process should be taken consideration. The theory of
communication studies has provided translation study a new perspective, more
specifically with Lasswell’s 5W communication model. This thesis is going to carry
out the study from “Who” -- the translators, “How” -- the channels, ‘What” -- the
ion of original text and the specific translation strategies applied to scientific
content, “To Whom” -- the audience and “With What Effect” -- the reception effect.
What should be mentioned is that the last part about the effect is of great importance.
Even among all the studies on Chinese literature translation, there is always a lack of
attention paid to the reception part. Actually the reception effect has long been
overlooked but could be a key element to evaluate whether a translation is successful
or not. So this thesis will go much deeper and investigate the reception situation as
well as its feedback to domestic CCSF development. This study aims to find out the
characteristics of each step, and think about their applicability to the culture going out
project. Also through the case study, a more explicit analysis of the existing problems
should be focused. In this way, this thesis hopes to provide more reference for
Chinese literature translation studies and be an enlightenment for successive studies.
Chapter One Introduction
6
1.3 Research Methodology
The research questions in this thesis including three aspects as follows:
(1) From the Lasswell’s 5W communication model, how has Chinese Science
Fiction been translated and disseminated English world?
(2) Comparing with other types of Chinese literature, what are the features of
each factor functioned in translation and dissemination of CCSF?
(3) What are the implications of this research for the overall Chinese culture
going out?
As for the method applied, the whole research mainly conducted
empirical-descriptive method. Quantitative method and qualitative method will both
be used. Qualitative method includes literature method, which would be applied to
figure out the development of science fiction in China and to clarify the relevant
domestic and overseas studies of science fiction in China. And the theoretical method
would be used to explain why communication studies, more specifically the 5W
communication model, should be applied as the theoretical basis. The textual-analysis
method will mainly be applied in analysis of “What”, aiming to find out the
translation strategies used for scientific content. As for the quantitative method,
data-analysis will focus on different kinds of data, including the rankings, the
quantities of sales and visitor volume of different kinds of publications etc. All these
data will be carefully classified, then this thesis is going to find out what have they
represented.
1.4 Thesis Structure
The thesis is composed of six parts as follows
:
The first chapter takes the responsibility to illustrate the research sample and
research background, as well as to emphasize the research significance, and introduce
the research questions and specific research methods.
Chapter One Introduction
7
The second chapter is about literature review. First, this thesis would describe the
development of science fiction in China, and would focus on the current research
situation of contemporary Chinese science fiction. Then this chapter would study the
previous studies on translation of Chinese science fiction and makes a summary of
their findings as well as deficiencies.
The third chapter should be the theoretical basis. This chapter is going to
introduce the communication studies, mainly about Lasswell’s 5W communication
model, and discuss about the relevance between 5W model and translation studies.
The fourth chapter is the stress of this thesis. In this chapter, the whole process of
CCSF’s translation and dissemination would be studied under the 5W communication
model, namely the translators, the translation skills applied and the original text
choice, the channels of publication, the efforts made for audience, the reception effect
and the feedback.
The fifth chapter will focus on a case study of
Invisible Planets,
which would
serve as a more explicit explanation of the translation and dissemination of CCSF
.
In
this part, the whole analysis would also be conducted under 5W model. And the
advantages and deficiencies existed would be discussed.
The last chapter would be a conclusion of this research, including the major
findings and the limitation. Meanwhile, this part also would talk about the
implications of this research to the follow-on studies.
Chapter Two Literature Review
8
Chapter Two Literature Review
2.1 An Introduction to Chinese Science Fiction
Before discussing about the translation and dissemination of Chinese science
fiction, it is also of great importance to illustrate the development history of science
fiction in China. Because science fiction still can be considered to be a new born
literature genre which is still in its upswing. Figuring out its history would be
beneficial to later research of this thesis.
Since the first science fiction was imported China, it has already been more
than one hundred years. And it should be the only literature genre that hasn’t been
appeared in Chinese literature history before. The whole development generally can
be divided five periods, respectively are late Qing dynasty and early Republic
period, early stage of PR, from the late 1970s to the early of 1980s, the 1990s and the
new 21
st
century. “Science fiction” was firstly put forward by American Hugo
Gernsback, who tried to emphasize the science value of this new literature genre.
When it was introduced China, its first Chinese name was“
科学小说
”. This name
can transfer the original expectation of those who brought it in. (Huang, 2003:43) The
first traceable translated foreign science fiction was
Eight Days Around the World
(
《八十日环游记》
) in 1900
,
not long after that, the first originally created Chinese
science fiction appeared in 1904,
《月球殖民地小说》
written by Xu Nianci. And
during 1950s, a great scale of science fictions has been translated from the Soviet
Union China. At that time, according to meaning of its Russian, this genre was
called “science fantasy”. After being translated Chinese, its translation was “
科幻
小说
”
,
and this name has been widely accepted up to now.
Chapter Two Literature Review
9
2.2 Previous Studies on Chinese Science Fiction
As for the development of science fiction in China, it has experienced several
ups and downs and now has already entered its golden age and flourished.
Although the history of Chinese science fiction might not be that magnificent, but
there have been always some scholars focused on its development. In 1991, the first
science fiction university course in China was set up in Beijing Normal
University(BNU). Then in 2003 the Master of Science Fiction and in 2014 the Doctor
of Science Fiction were also set up in there. And BNU also has a Research Centre for
Science Fiction and Creative Education of Beijing Normal University.
With the wholesome growing trend of CSF, much more academic attention has
been paid to Chinese science fiction study. More than 900 results could be searched in
CNKI with the key word “Chinese Science Fiction”. Most of them focuses on
contemporary Chinese science fiction’s literature value and development prospect,
also there are several studies focuses on the works of Qing dynasty. Moreover, some
awarded works like
The Three Body
Problem
could be the hot topic for research.
Among all of them, the studies on domestic development history of Chinese science
fiction are the most cited one. Here are some examples:
Qiu Jianghui (1982:82-86) has been the first one to realize that it’s of importance
to clarify the development of science fiction in China, though science fiction hadn’t
undergone a long history but actually grew rapidly from 1977 to 1981, so he paid his
attention on the development of this time. He specifically focused on three periods,
1900-1949,1949-1976,1977-1981, and he clarified the innovations that happened on
new era Chinese science fiction writing.
Ye Yonglie (1983:63-69) discussed about his idea towards science fiction
thrillers as a response to another scholar’s query. He illustrated the history, the writing
characteristics and confirmed the value of this genre. He emphasized the enlightening
meaning of science fiction to the development of science and our society should not
be overlooked.
Chapter Two Literature Review
10
Yan Yi (2001:41-43) explored the publications of Chinese science fiction at
2000s, and also discussed about its future. This paper analyzes several factors that
have influenced the Chinese science fiction writing and also lists the particular
advantages for science fiction to develop in China and estimated the problems it might
confront. Tang Zhesheng (2003:63-67) realizes that science fiction has flourished in
Europe and America, however in China, the current situation hasn’t been that
satisfying. The author thinks that the root cause lied in the ambiguity of Chinese
试阅到此结束,如需查看全部内容请购买正版文献。如因学习需要阅览全文,请联系站长。