分
类号
密
级
UDC 编
号
硕士学位论文
何以为人-对四部机器人科幻小说的伦理分析
申
请
人
姓
名
李世昕
导师姓名及职称
张
欣
教
授
申请学位类别
文
学
学科专业名称
英
语语言文学
培
养
单
位
英
语语言文化学院
学位授予单位
广
东外语外贸大学
2017 年
4
月
1
6 日
分类号
_________
密级
___
公开
____
UDC
__ 编号
20140110005
广东外语外贸大学硕士学位论文
How to Define Human
—
An Ethical Analysis on Four Science Fictions of
Robots
何以为人-对四部机器人科幻小说的伦理分析
申
请
人
姓
名
李世昕
导师姓名及职称
张
欣
教
授
申请学位类别
文
学
学科专业名称
英语语言文学
论文提交日期
2017 年
4
月
1
6 日
论文答辩日期
2017 年
5
月
2
6 日
答
辩
委
员
会
刘
胡敏
教
授
(
主席)
管
建明
副
教授
焦
敏
副
教授
学位授予单位
广
东外语外贸大学
独创性声明
本人郑重声明:所呈交的学位论文是本人在导师指导下进行的研究工作及取
得的研究成果。据我所知,除了文中特别加以标注和致谢的地方外,论文中不包
含其他人已经发表或撰写过的研究成果,也不包含为获得 广东外语外贸大学
或其他教育机构的学位或证书而使用过的材料。与我一同工作的人对本研究所做
的任何贡献均已在论文中作了明确的说明并表示谢意。
作者签名:
签字日期: 年 月 日
学位论文版权使用授权书
本学位论文作者完全了解 广东外语外贸大学 有关保留、使用学位论文的规
定,有权保留并向国家有关部门或机构送交论文的复印件和磁盘,允许论文被查
阅和借阅。本人授权 广东外语外贸大学 可以将学位论文的全部或部分内容编入
有关数据库进行检索,可以采用影印、缩印或扫描等复制手段保存、汇编学位论
文。
作者签名:
导师签名:
签字日期:
年
月
日
签字日期:
年
月
日
i
How to Define Human
—
An Ethical Analysis on Four Science Fictions
of Robots
By Li Shixin
Supervised by Professor Zhang Xin
Submitted
in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for
the Degree of Master of Arts
in English Language and Literature
Guangdong University of Foreign Studies
Apr 2017
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My first thanks shall go to Anthony Daniels, the English actor who played the
robot character C-3PO in the Star Wars film series. It is his speech in the BBC
documentary film, “The Real History of Science Fiction”, about the experience of
being a robot that moves me and inspires this thesis in the first place.
Secondly I want to thank my mentor, Professor Zhang, who gives valuable
advice for me in developing the primitive idea a formed thesis.
From proposition to typing the final draft, composing this thesis takes nearly a
year. My friends and family give me support and encouragement during this whole
time, without which it would be a much harder experience.
Last but not least I want to thank my roommate and classmates as we spent the
last three years together
,
and offer support and encouragement for each other
whenever needed.
v
ABSTRACT
How to Define Human
—
An Ethical Analysis on Four Science Fictions of Robots
By Li Shixin
An M.A. Thesis in English Language and Literature
Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, 2017
The conception of artificial human has a long history and appears in both
Oriental and Occidental ancient myths. With the development of science and
technology, artificial intelligence also becomes a hot topic of science fiction. Just like
the double-
edged sword science and technology being, human’s attitude towards
artificial intelligence is also double sided. The status and position of artificial
intelligence is closely related to the definition of human, the change of which reflects
how human’s
value and ethic is influenced by the development of science and
technology. This thesis makes an ethical analysis on four science fictions which are
representative works of different periods of science fiction. By examining the
different ethical dilemma artificial intelligence faces in each text and the different
ethical choice made by human and artificial intelligence, this thesis discusses the
change of human
’
s attitude towards artificial intelligence, which reflects the influence
of science and technology development on human
’
s value and ethics.
The thesis starts with an introduction which offers information about research
background, put forward the research question and makes a literature review. The
main body of this thesis is composed by four chapters to analysis the four texts,
vi
namely Frankenstein by Mary Shelly, Issac
Asimov’s robot stories particularly the
collection I, Robot
and “The Bicentennial Man”,
Do Androids Dreams of Electric
Sheep?
by Philip K. Dick, and William Gibson’s
Neuromancer. By examining the
different ethical dilemmas artificial intelligence faces in these texts and the response
of both human and artificial intelligence, this thesis suggests that with development of
science and technology, human
’
s attitude is becoming more and more open and
artificial intelligence is gradually accepted. The definition of human is becoming
more open, proving the progress of human
’
s ethic.
Keywords: ethical criticism, ethical dilemma, ethical choice, artificial intelligence,
science fiction
vii
摘
要
何以为人
-
对四部机器人科幻小说的伦理分析
李世昕
广东外语外贸大学英语语言文学专业
硕士学位论文
2017
人造人这一概念由来已久,东西方神话传说中都有它的身影。随着科学技术
的兴起,人工智能也变成了科幻文学中长盛不衰的主题之一。正如科学技术是一
把双刃剑一样,人类对人工智能的态度也一直具有两面性。人工智能的地位和处
境与“人”的定义密切相关,其变化折射出了人类的伦理价值观念受科学技术发
展的影响而随之改变的过程。本文选取了在科幻小说发展各个阶段具有代表性的
四部科幻小说,探讨了其中的人工智能形象所面对的不同伦理困境,和人工智能
与人类面对困境做出的不同伦理选择,进而分析了人类对人工智能态度的逐渐转
变,以及这些转变所反映出的不同时代科学技术发展对人类伦理和道德带来的影
响。
本文首先在引言部分简单介绍了研究背景,提出了研究问题,并对过往的相
关文献进行了综述。主体部分共分四章,分别探讨了玛丽·雪莱的《弗兰肯斯坦》,
阿西莫夫的《我,机器人》和《两百岁的人》,菲利普·K·迪克的《仿生人能梦
见电子羊吗?》和威廉·吉布森的《神经浪游者》中,不同类型的人工智能所面
临的不同伦理困境,以及面对伦理困境人工智能和人类所采取的不同措施。从这
些不同中可以看出,随着科学技术的发展,人类态度越来越开放,人工智能逐渐
为人类所接受。“人”的定义变得更加广阔,反映出人类伦理道德的进步。
关键词:
伦
理批评,伦理困境,伦理选择,人工智能,科幻小说
ix
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.............................................................................................iii
ABSTRACT.................................................................................................................v
摘要
..............................................................................................................................vii
CONTENTS..................................................................................................................ix
CHAPTER
ONE INTRODUCTION..........................................................................1
1.1 Background and Significance of Research.....................................................1
1.2 Review of Relevant Literature.......................................................................3
1.2.1 Research Abroad.................................................................................3
1.2.2 Domestic Research................................................................................6
1.3 Aim and Analysis Procedure..........................................................................8
1.3.1 Research Aim and Questions.................................................................8
1.3.2 Analysis Procedures..............................................................................9
CHAPTER
TWO
COMPLETE REJECTION OF FRAN
KENSTEIN’S
MONSTER...................................................................................................................11
2.1
Human’s Rejection and Identity Confusion
..............................................11
2.1.1 Human
’
s Rejection and Prejudice.........................................................11
2.1.2 Identity Confusion of the Monster......................................................12
2.2
Monster’s Fighting and Frankenstein’s
Shirking ..........................................13
2.2.1 Monster
’
s Choice
–
Battle between Human and Animal Factor............13
2.2.2 Frankenstein
’
s Choice
–
How to Use Science....................................15
2.3 Contemplation on Definition of Human with Historical Background ........16
2.3.1 Definition of Human and Frankenstein Complex..............................16
2.3.2 Influence and Limitation of Science Development on Ethics......17
CHAPTER
THREE
CONDESCENDING
ACCEPTANCE
OF
ROBOT..................19
x
3.1 Three Laws of Robotics and the Ethical Conflicts behind...........................19
3.1.1 Three Laws of Robotics
–
An Attempt..........................................20
3.1.2 Unsolved Ethical Dilemma.............................................................21
3.2
Robot’s Growing Humanity and Human’s Changing Attitude
........................22
3.2.1 Long Journey of Becoming Human
–
Growing Humanity................22
3.2.2 Changing Attitude towards Robots........................................................24
3.3 Changing Definition of Humanity ..............................................................25
3.3.1 How to Define a Human-Humanity and Independent Thought........25
3.3.2 Influence and Limitation of Science Development on Ethics.............26
CHAPTER
FOUR
INVOLUNTARY
SYMPATHY
FOR
ANDROID
......................29
4.1 Blurring Boundary between Human and Androids ...................................29
4.1.1 Empathy Test
–
Wrong Standard to Judge Machine...........................29
4.1.2 Mood Organ and Specials
–
Machine-like Human.............................30
4.2
Androids’
Emotion and Human’s Coldness
................................................32
4.2.1 Androids - Animal Factor and Ethical Choice....................................32
4.2.2 Human
’
s Attitudes toward Androids...................................................33
4.3 Confusing and Worrying about Humanity ..................................................34
4.3.1 Warning of Human-like Machine and Machine-like Human..............34
4.3.2 Influence and Limitation of Science Development on Ethics.............35
CHAPTER
FIVE
CYBORG’S BOUNDARY BREAKDOWN
................................37
5.1 Challenging for the Definition of Human................................................... 37
5.1.1 Cyborg and Cyberspace
–
Challenging Human Nature......................38
5.1.2 Artificial Intelligence and Lives
–
Artificial yet More Real...............39
5.2
Human’s Losing and A.I.’s Gaining Humanity
..........................................40
5.2.1 Human
–
Losing Humanity and Addicted to Technology..................40
5.2.2 Machine
–
Fighting for Freedom with All Costs................................42
5.3 Exploration for the Post-modern Humanity ...............................................43
5.3.1 Post-Modern Humanity......................................................................43
5.3.2 Influence and Limitation of Science Development on Ethics.............44
CHAPTER
SIX
CONCLUSION................................................................................47
xi
WORKS
CITED...........................................................................................................51
1
CHAPTER
ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background and Significance of Research
From the Chinese legendary tale
“
Yan Shi Zao Ren
”
to the ancient myths of
Prometheus and Pygmalion, artificial human is a concept long embedded in human
’
s
history. With the development of science and technology, in 19th century real robot is
created and gradually applied in society. As artificial intelligent beings, robot brings a
series of ethical problems, and the attitude towards robot is closely related to how
human view themselves. Science fiction writers begin to explore this question
hundred years before the scientists and engineers, and their viewpoints have deeply
influenced the society.
Literature is closely related with ethics as it depicts society and life. The ethical
approach to literary works is one of the most traditional critical methods, and
numerous researches have been made on the ethical dimension of literary works.
Science fiction is defined by the Oxford English Dictionary as
“
fiction in which the
setting and story feature hypothetical scientific or technological advances, the
existence of alien life, space or time travel, etc., especially such fiction set in the
future, or an imagined alternative universe
”
. It has a natural bond with ethics, as it
considers the future ethical questions human may encounter, especially fiction on
robot. Roberts Adams concludes that all robot stories are ethical fictions
“
at root
”
(199). The robot ethics in science fiction is closely related to the development of
human values, reflecting human
’
s attitude towards science and technology. This thesis
chooses four science fictions of robot in different times which describe four different
attitudes toward robot, to explore the ethical dilemmas faced by robot and human, and
influence of science and technology development.
2
The English science fiction is generally considered as has been went through
four stages, namely the early and primitive time, the Golden Age, the New Wave
period and the post New Wave period, and each stage has its distinctive focus and
understanding about science and technology
’
s influence. This thesis chooses four
texts as representative work for each stage, namely Frankenstein by Mary Shelly,
Issac Asimov
’
s robot stories, particularly
“
The Bicentennial Man
”
, Do Androids
Dreams of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick, and William Gibson
’
s Neuromancer,
all of which are famous and influential works about artificial intelligence. An analysis
on the four of them shall shed light upon human
’
s ongoing reflection on ethics and
attitudes towards artificial intelligence, as they describe four different kinds of robot
and human-robot relationship facing different ethical dilemma. The being
Frankenstein creates is an abhorrent monster made with dead human bodies.
Asimov
’
s robot looks like machine with metal body. Android in Philip K. Dick
’
s
novel is designed to look and act just like human, and cannot be distinguished without
professional test, which is a huge problem for the protagonist and raises ethical
concerns. The cyborg in Neuromancer is human being whose body has been replaced
in whole or in part by electromechanical devices, to repair the ineffective parts or to
enhance normal functioning. The combination of human and machine in cyborg
causes identity issue.
Abundant criticisms have been made on the chosen texts from various
perspectives. The fear of technology, the issue of identity and the ethics needed in
human-robot interaction have all been mentioned, and ethical issue in Frankenstein
has been noticed. However, no connection of them from the view of ethical criticism
has been made yet. This thesis will examine the change of human
’
s attitude towards
artificial intelligence with the technology development, and hopefully will be helpful
for the future research on science fiction.
3
1.2 Review of Relevant Literature
1.2.1 Research Abroad
Ever since the first science fiction Frankenstein, robot was a hot topic in western
science fiction. Humans
’
complicated feelings and attitudes towards the intelligent
being created by themselves were depicted by many writers, and criticized by many
scholars. In their book The Artificial Human: A Tragical History, Horst Albert Glaser
and Sabine Rossbach traced the humanoid constructs down to the ancient myths of
Prometheus and Pygmalion, and followed the track of artificial human through
various countries and across more than two thousand years of history. They reflected
on the ideas of Descartes, Leibniz and La Mettrie which generated artificial human,
and the social, technological and medical developments that accompanied and to a
great extent explained them. Robert M. Geraci found a similarity between human
beings simultaneously feeling fear and allure in the presence of intelligent machines
and the numinous experience as described by Rudolph Otto, and argued that the
human reaction to intelligent machines shows that human beings in many respects
have elevated those machine to divine status, and this machine apotheosis may
threaten traditional Christian theologies.
Frankenstein was always a favorite in academic field, and the debate on the
relationship between science and ethics in the novel never rested since its publication.
In
“Science, Frankenstein, and Myth”
, Theodore Ziolkowski argued that Frankenstein
is not just a fantasy about the
“
intrusion of the irrational the rational world
”
(39),
and it expresses society
’
s concern on, as it believed to be, the blind pursuit of
knowledge with no thought for its social implications. Stuart Curran exemplified the
novel
’
s scientific grounding, and pointed out that what Mary Shelly wanted to explore
is how the scientific laws and moral principles can be compatible.
As one of the most famous science fiction writers in history, Asimov
’
s Three
Laws of Robotics greatly influenced other writers and thinkers in this subject. Not
only the literature field, in the scientific field the three laws were widely accepted as
4
well. Naturally, there were voluminous discussions about Asimov and his three laws.
Robin R. Murphy and David D. Woods pointed out that Asimov
’
s three laws have
been so successfully
“
inculcated
”
(2) the public consciousness through
entertainment that they now appear to shape society
’
s expectations about how robots
should act around humans. They questioned whether the Laws are actually viable as a
framework for human-robot interaction when taken outside of cultural expectations.
Riek and Howard saw Asimov
’
s works as
“
robo-dystopia
”
(1) while the more
mundane and therefore more important ethical challenges lies in the ongoing and
试阅到此结束,如需查看全部内容请购买正版文献。如因学习需要阅览全文,请联系站长。