文学伦理学视域下威尔斯科幻小说的伦理警示

分类  : 中文
作者  : 曹鹏越
来源  : 江西师范大学
卷   : 硕士
发表时间: 2018.   
发布人 : SFT

摘要:


正文:

分 类 号

:

HO

密 级

:

无

!

.??

学校代 码

:

1

0

4

1

4

学 号

:

2 0

1

5 0

1

0 3 48

°??

?

;

2

东 呷 紇

犬

学??

硕士 研 究 生 学 位 论 文??

S

t

u d

y

?

o

n

?

E

t

h

i

c

a

l

?

W

arn

i

n

g

s?

o

f

?

H

.

G

.

W

e

l

l

s

’

s?

S

c

i

e

n

c e??

F

i

c

t

i

o n

?

fr o

m

?t

h

e

?

P

er

s

p

ec

t

i

v

e

?

o

f

?

E

t

h

i

c

a

l?

L

i

t

er a r

y??

C

r

i

t

i

c

i

s

m??

文

学

伦

理

学

视

域

下

威

尔

斯科

幻 小 说的??

伦

理

警

示??

曹

鹏 越??

院 所

:

外

国 语 学 院 导

师

姓名

:

刘

茂 生??

学

位 类 别

:

学

术

型 硕 士

专

业领 域

:

英 美

文

学??

二 ?

一

八

年

六 月

??独 创 性 声 明

本人声明所呈交的学位论文是本人在导师指导下进行的研究

工作及取得的研究成果。据我所知,除了文中特别加以标注和致谢

的地方外,论文中不包含其他人已经发表或撰写过的研究成果,也

不包含为获得或其他教育机构的学位或证书而使用过的材料。与我

一同工作的同志对本研究所做的任何贡献均已在论文中作了明确

的说明并表示谢意。

学位论文作者签名: 签字日期: 年 月 日

学位论文版权使用授权书

本学位论文作者完全了解江西师范大学研究生院有关保留、使

用学位论文的规定,有权保留并向国家有关部门或机构送交论文的

复印件和磁盘,允许论文被查阅和借阅。本人授权江西师范大学研

究生院可以将学位论文的全部或部分内容编入有关数据库进行检

索,可以采用影印、缩印或扫描等复制手段保存、汇编学位论文。

(保密的学位论文在解密后适用本授权书)

学位论文作者签名: 导师签名:

签字日期: 年 月 日 签字日期: 年 月 日I

Abstract

Herbert George Wells (1866-1946) was one of the most talented English writers

in the world. He was a prolific writer in many other styles, whether it be

science-fiction or nonfiction. It is worth mentioning that his contribution to science

fiction is the most unforgettable. H. G. Wells was known as “The Shakespeare of

Science-Fiction”, and together with Jules Verne and Hugo Gernsback, Wells was

referred to as “The Father of Science Fiction”. One important reason that H. G. Wells

received such fame and reputation is that his ethical thought has deeply penetrated

his works. His individual science-fiction works have been analyzed from Ethical

Literary Criticism perspective, but lack of systematic research. This thesis aims to

explore the ethical issues caused by science and technology in his three early science

fictions, namely, The Time Machine (1895), The Island of Doctor Moreau (1896), and

The Invisible Man (1897), the three early science fictions are his science-fiction

masterpieces and the most representative ethical thoughts. With the hope of better

systematically interpreting H. G. Wells’s ethical thoughts through some basic terms

including ethical identity and social ethics from the perspective of Ethical Literary

Criticism. Furthermore, this thesis not only analyzes various ethical crises caused by

science and technology, but also explores Wells’s thoughts of evolutionary ethics, and

reveals the practical value of Wells’s science fiction works and his warnings to our

contemporary society.

This thesis is mainly composed of five parts:

Chapter one is an Introduction part, firstly, it briefly sketches out H. G. Wells’s

life and literary achievements, as well as a rough content of the early three science

fictions. Secondly, it summarizes the literary reviews abroad and at home related to H.

G. Wells. Most research mostly centers on his view on novels creation, the

Eco-criticism perspective or moral and ethical exploration of his individual

science-fiction works. And based on the material collected, the last part of the chapter

highlights the significance by applying Ethical Literary Criticism in a systematic way

to better appreciate H. G. Wells’s science-fiction works.

Chapter Two illustrates the main characters’ loss of ethical identity and

confusion after accepting the change of science and technology. In The Time Machine,

degradation of the body, the weakening of language and thinking, and the loss ofII

human feelings in the Eloi and the Morlocks, which make them tend to be animals,

lose human ethical identity. In The Island of Dr. Moreau, the alternation of human

factor and animal factor in beast folks, even though they have the appearance of

human beings, and they are clumsy to learn human language, imitate human behavior,

the suppressed animal factor will be shown from time to time. In The Invisible Man,

invisibility medicine makes Griffin’s identity ambiguous. After being invisible,

Griffin is equivalent to giving up human identity. So the invisible man is no longer

human after he abandons the nature of man. H. G. Wells reveals the ethical tragedies

from the destruction of ethical identity caused by science and technology.

Chapter Three focuses on collapsed social ethics in the three science fictions.

Disharmony and hostility of social relationship between Elio and Morlocks in The

Time Machine, the Elio is nothing but a group of fat cattle, stocked by the Morlocks

living underground, being fattened for slaughter. Besides, Elio is indifferent and

ruthless to each other even refused to help someone who was dying. In The Island of

Dr. Moreau, Dr. Moreau set up a “utopia human world” for his beast folks, it looks

like a civilized world, but it is chaotic in reality. The barbarity and the fear of pain

drove the beast folks against Moreau’s totalitarian rule and killed him. Eventually, the

beast folks’ human nature was gradually degraded, and fallen a terrible mutual

hunting and chaos. Besides, Dr. Moreau intended to transform animals rational

humans and to become their master, he did not treat these beast folks as equal as

human beings, completely lost humanity. There is a social community segregation in

The Invisible Man. Although Griffin is a rare genius scientist in the world, the

academic world is full of artificial forces, wantonly to steal the fruits of his labor. The

invisible man was not accepted by others, so he frantically pursued power, to build a

horror dynasty for dominating all human beings, it is obviously that he lost sense of

social responsibility. The collapse of social ethics is also one of the important reasons

leading to the ethical tragedy of these protagonists.

Chapter Four analyzes the evolutionary ethics thought contained in Wells’s

science fiction. Although there are many ideas affecting Wells’s life, in many of the

ideas, the greatest impact on Wells is Darwin’s theory of evolution. In the process of

Wells’s all creation and ideological development, the theory of evolution is all

through, and it is the ideological basis of Wells’s ethical and moral concepts. This

chapter focuses on the embodiments of the theory of evolution in the early three

works of Wells and its influence on Wells’s ethical and moral thoughts.

Chapter Five concludes that ethical literary criticism offers a new approach to theIII

interpretation of H. G. Wells’s science-fiction works. Through the exploration of the

ethical issues: ethical identity and social ethics, and analysis of his evolution ethics

thoughts in his three early science fictions, H. G. Wells not only shows the changes

brought about by the development of science and technology, but also explores the

tragedy brought by the malignant high-tech, which aims to send a warning to the

world. Just as his epitaph: God will destroy human beings, I warned you!

Key words: H. G. Wells; Ethical Literary Criticism; Ethical Identity; Social Ethics;

Evolution EthicsIV

摘 要

赫伯特·乔治·威尔斯(1866-1946)是世界上最富有才华的英国作家之一。

他是拥有各种风格的多产作家,无论是科幻小说还是非小说类作品。其中他对科

幻领域的贡献最令人难以忘记。威尔斯被誉为“科幻小说界的莎士比亚”,并与

儒勒·凡尔纳和雨果·根斯巴克一起被称为“科幻小说之父”。威尔斯获得如此

声誉的一个重要原因是他的伦理思想深刻地渗透到他的作品中。有很多学者从伦

理文学批评的角度分析他的单部科幻作品,但缺乏系统性的研究。本论文旨在探

讨威尔斯早期三部科幻小说中因科学技术引发的伦理问题,即《时间机器》(1895

年),《莫罗博士的岛》(1896 年),《隐形人》(1897 年),这三部早期科

幻小说是他科幻作品的代表作,蕴含的伦理思想也是最具代表性的。本文主要运

用文学伦理学的批评方法,以期通过分析三部代表作中伦理身份和社会伦理来更

好地系统性地诠释威尔斯的伦理思想。此外,本文不仅分析了威尔斯三部早期科

幻小说中科技引发的各种伦理危机,还探索了威尔斯的进化伦理思想,揭示了威

尔斯科幻作品的实践价值及其对当代社会的警示意义。

论文共分为五个章节。

第一章是介绍部分,主要囊括了赫伯特·乔治·威尔斯的生平、文学成就以

及简要概括了他早期三部科幻小说的大致内容,并且对国内外研究威尔斯的方向

做了文献综述。笔者发现大部分研究都集中于分析威尔斯小说的创作观、从生态

批评视角和道德伦理探究他单部科幻小说作品。基于笔者收集到的资料,笔者指

出了运用文学伦理学的批评方法,系统性地分析威尔斯科幻小说的重要意义。

第二章阐述了接受科技变革后主要人物的伦理身份的迷失与困惑。在《时间

机器》中,爱洛伊人和莫洛克人身体的退化,语言和思维的弱化,以及人类情感

的丧失,使他们近乎成为动物,丧失了人的伦理身份;在《莫罗博士的岛》中兽

人人性因子与兽性因子的交替。尽管它们具有人类的外表,笨拙地学习人类的语

言和模仿人类的行为,但被压制的兽性因子会不时释放出来;《隐形人》中,隐

形药水使格里芬的伦理身份变得模糊。隐身后的格里芬,相当于放弃了人类身份。

可以说隐身人抛弃了人的本质属性后就不再是人。威尔斯揭示了科技对伦理身份

的破坏带来的伦理悲剧。

第三章主要探讨三部科幻小说中社会伦理的崩塌。《时间机器》中爱洛伊人

和莫洛克人之间不和谐和敌对的社会关系,爱洛伊人只不过是由生活在地下的莫

洛克人饲养的食物;而且爱洛伊人彼此之间漠不关心,冷酷无情,甚至不顾他人

死活;在《莫罗博士的岛》中,莫罗博士为他的兽人族建立了一个“乌托邦式的V

人类世界”,它看起来像一个文明的世界,但实际上却混乱不堪。兽性和对痛苦

的恐惧驱使兽人起身反抗莫罗的极权主义并杀死了他。最后兽族人性逐渐退化,

社会陷入了可怕的相互狩猎和混乱之中。此外,莫罗博士他意图将动物转换成有

理性的人并且成为他们的主人,并没有把这些兽人当作人一样平等对待,毫无人

情。《隐形人》中群体间的社会隔离。虽然格里芬是世界上难得的天才科学家,

但学术界充满了虚伪假善,肆意窃取他的劳动成果;他的隐身身份不被大众理解

和接受,于是他疯狂地追逐权力,欲建立一个恐怖王朝,统治所有的人类。自我

丧失了社会责任感。社会伦理的崩塌也是导致主人公伦理悲剧的重要原因之一。

第四章分析了威尔斯科幻小说作品中蕴含的进化伦理思想。尽管威尔斯一生

所受的影响是多方面的,但是在众多的思想中,对威尔斯影响最大的是达尔文的

进化论学说。在威尔斯的全部创作和思想发展过程中,进化论学说都贯穿始终,

是威尔斯的伦理道德观念的思想基础。本章重点阐述了进化论在威尔斯早期三部

作品中的体现及其对威尔斯伦理道德思想的影响。

第五章是对这篇论文的总结。这部分再次重申了文学伦理学批评为解读威尔

斯科幻小说提供了新的视角。通过阐明威尔斯早期三部科幻作品中伦理身份和社

会伦理,以及分析其中蕴含的进化伦理思想,威尔斯不仅展现了科技发展带来的

改变,而且探索了恶性高科技造成的伦理悲剧,旨在向人类发出警告。正如他的

墓志铭所言:上帝将要毁灭人类——我警告过你们!

关键词:赫伯特·乔治·威尔斯;文学伦理学批评;伦理身份;社会伦理;进化

伦理VI

Contents

Abstract..........................................................................................................................I

摘 要

......................................................................................................................... IV

Contents...................................................................................................................... VI

Chapter 1 Introduction................................................................................................1

1.1 H. G. Wells and His Three Early Science Fictions...........................................1

1.1.1 An Introduction of H. G. Wells............................................................. 1

1.1.2 An Introduction of Three Early Science Fictions..................................3

1.2 Previous Research on H. G. Wells at Home and Abroad................................. 4

1.2.1 Previous Research on Wells Abroad......................................................4

1.2.2 Previous Research on Wells at Home....................................................6

1.3 Ethical Literary Criticism and Significance of the Study.................................9

1.3.1 An Introduction of Ethical Literary Criticism.......................................9

1.3.2 The Significance of the Study............................................................. 11

Chapter 2 Lost in Situating Ethical Identity............................................................13

2.1 Identity Polarization in The Time Machine.................................................... 13

2.1.1 Pure and Flabby Eloi...........................................................................14

2.1.2 Cruel and Aggressive Morlocks.......................................................... 16

2.2 Identity Ambiguity in The Island of Dr. Moreau............................................18

2.2.1 Human Factor in Beast Folks..............................................................18

2.2.2 Animal Factor in Beast Folks..............................................................20

2.3 Identity Antagonism in The Invisible Man.....................................................22

2.3.1 The Visible Man Griffin...................................................................... 23

2.3.2 The Invisible Man Griffin................................................................... 25

Chapter 3 Collapse in Social Ethics..........................................................................28

3.1 Disharmony of Social Relationship in The Time Machine.............................29

3.1.1 Indifference between the Eloi..............................................................29

3.1.2 Hostility between the Eloi and the Morlocks......................................31

3.2 Unstable “The Truman Show” in The Island of Dr. Moreau..........................32

3.2.1 Inequality between Dr. Moreau and the Beast Folks...........................33

3.2.2 The Conflict between the Beast Folks.................................................35

3.3 Segregation of Social Community in The Invisible Man............................... 36

3.3.1 Self Loss of Social Responsibility.......................................................36

3.3.2 Ostracized by General Publics............................................................ 38

Chapter 4 H. G. Wells’s Evolutionary Ethics Thoughts......................................... 40

4.1 Weakening of Ethical Thoughts Caused by Social Evolution in The Time

Machine................................................................................................................41VII

4.2 Disunity of Biological Evolution and Ethical Thoughts in The Island of Dr.

Moreau................................................................................................................. 44

4.3 Alienation of Ethical Thoughts from Biological Evolution in The Invisible

Man.......................................................................................................................45

Chapter 5 Conclusion.................................................................................................48

Bibliography............................................................................................................... 51

Acknowledgements.....................................................................................................55

在读期间公开发表论文(著)及科研情况

..............................................................56Study on Ethical Warnings of H. G. Wells’s Science Fiction from the Perspective of Ethical Literary Criticism

1

Chapter 1 Introduction

1.1 H. G. Wells and His Three Early Science Fictions

1.1.1 An Introduction of H. G. Wells

H. G. Wells, in full Herbert George Wells, English novelist, sociologist,

journalist, and historian best known for such science fiction novels as The Time

Machine (1895) and The War of the Worlds (1898) and such comic novels as

Tono-Bungay (1909) and The History of Mr. Polly (1910). Along with Jules Verne,

Wells has been referred to as “The Father of Science Fiction”, and he was nominated

for the Nobel Prize in Literature four times.

On Sept. 21, 1866, H. G. Wells was born in Bromley, Kent, from a lower middle

class. His father was domestic servants turned small shopkeepers and

semiprofessional cricket player. His mother was an intemittent housekeeper. At the

age of 7, Wells entered Morley’s School in Bromley. Because his family was very

difficult to support themselves, Wells was forced to drop out of school and engaged in

various part-time jobs. At the age of 14, he became a draper’s apprentice, but his

employer soon dismissed him; and he became assistant to a chemist, then to another

draper, and ultimately, in 1883, an usher at Midhurst Grammar School. In 1884, he

won a scholarship to the Normal School of Science at South Kensington, where he

studied under the biologist T. H. Huxley. Huxley has great influence on Wells. Wells

had a keen interest in his teacher’s research and began to study evolution. He founded

and edited a science school magazine during his college years. In the second year,

Wells was disappointed with the teaching of the school and left in 1887 without

earning a degree. Then he taught at a private school for three years. He received a

degree in science from the University of London in 1890. After his marriage to his

cousin Isabel (his first wife), he began teaching at a correspondence college in

London in 1891. The marriage was not a success, he left Isabel in 1894 and married

again in 1895 to his student Amy Catherine Robbins. They had two sons, George

Philip and Frank Richard. On August 13th, 1946, Wells died at his home at Regent’s

Park, London, aged 79.

In the early 1890s, Wells devoted himself entirely to writing. His early works,

often called “scientific romances”, were influential and inventive science-fiction andA Thesis for the Degree of Master of Arts

2

fantasy novels. This period saw the production of almost all his SF masterpieces. With

his first novel, The Time Machine (1895), which made him rise to fame overnight, he

began a series of science fiction novels that revealed him as a writer of marked

originality and an immense fertility of ideas: The Island of Dr. Moreau (1896), The

Invisible Man (1897), The War of the Worlds (1898), When the Sleeper Awakes (1898),

The First Men in the Moon (1901), Anticipations (1901), The Food of the Gods and

How it Came to Earth (1904), A Modern Utopia (1905) formed a list of whose titles

proves to be a checklist of SF masterpieces of all time.

In the novels of his middle period Wells turned from the fantastic to the realistic

and drew on memories of his lower-middle-class early life. These books are

considered his best achievement, including Kipps (1905), Tono-Bungay (1909), and

The History of Mr. Polly (1910).

Wells’s later books were primarily novels of ideas. The speculative content grew

increasingly rare. The World Set Free (1914) raises questions about the role of science

in developing ever more destructive weapons. The Dream (1924) is a retrospective

look at contemporary mores from the viewpoint of the distant future. The Autocracy

of Mr. Parham (1930) is a marginal future political satire.

In his final works, Wells set forth his view of the plans and concessions that

individuals must make in order to survive. His works became increasingly pessimistic

as he aged, including The Shape of Things to Come (1933), World Brain (1938), The

Holy Terror (1939) and Mind at the End of Its Tether (1945).

Unlike Verne, who was primarily interested in telling a good story and who used

technological wonders such as submarines and advanced aircraft as part of the setting

for his adventures, Wells usually addressed technological change as an element in the

plot, and in terms of its social implications. Indeed, all of Wells’s science fiction was

intensely engaged with the social and political issues of his day, demonstrating early

on the potential of SF as a mode of commentary on such issues. His science fiction

novel was almost pessimistic about humanity and the future.

The influence of Wells and his works in the SF genre and in western culture is

immeasurable. Many of his works have become the founding texts of SF subgenres.

For example, his masterpiece The War of the Worlds has become the prototype of the

cyborgs and the hyper-brain future humans and extraterrestrials of later science fiction.

Many writers, such as Brain W. Aldiss, Karl Alexander, Christopher Priest, are

indebted to Wells. Almost all of Wells’s novels have been filmed or have provided

inspiration for others with similar concepts.Study on Ethical Warnings of H. G. Wells’s Science Fiction from the Perspective of Ethical Literary Criticism

3

1.1.2 An Introduction of Three Early Science Fictions

In 1895, H. G. Wells published a science fiction novella The Time Machine and

written as a frame narrative. Wells is the first writer who makes his protagonist travel

through time. The novel has generally been regarded as one of the founding text of the

time-travel SF and a forerunner of dystopian subgenre. The book is the first

well-executed, imaginatively coherent picture of a future worse than the present, a

picture at the same time generally anti-utopian in its tendencies. The protagonist is an

unnamed and gentleman scientist from Victorian England, who invented a time

machine and then used it to take a journey to the distant future and encounters the

world of AD 802,701, in which humanity has degenerated the subhuman Eloi and

Morlocks. The Eloi are tiny, peaceful, vulnerable and cattlelike humans, who live

above ground, do not work, feed on fruit. They seem to have lost all capacity for

action or creativity. By contrast, the Morlocks are brutal, aggressive, ape-like

creatures who having developed an lerance to light, live in underground. They

haven’t lost all the technological ability and are more energetic than the Eloi.

However, their degeneration to animality is revealed when the Time Traveller realizes

that they actually feed on the Eloi at night. Later, the traveller travels even further

the future, where he observes the human race continuing to decline and eventually

becoming extinct. Finally, he returns home, relating his adventures to his disbelieving

visitors and then embarks on a second voyage the future, from which he never

returns.

In 1896, Wells finished a frightening masterpiece The Island of Dr. Moreau about

the characteristics of beasts blurring as the animals turn men. The narrator of the

novel is Edward Prendick, who suffered from a shipwrecked, he was then rescued by

a passing ship and brought him to a deserted island. The owner of this island is Dr.

Moreau, a mad scientist who turned kinds of animals humans through vivisection.

Using his scientific knowledge and technological prowess, Dr. Moreau has created

new animal species by using a series of startling and unheard-of experiments, such as

organ transplantation and metamorphosis. These created orcs have the habit of human

beings, and have developed social habits with certain pre-human functions and

abilities, such as moving goods and building houses. Crazy Doctor even did vocal

cord surgery for them and taught them to speak. Moreau used all means to make

himself the god whom these orcs worship, ruled this unknown island. Prendick was

unable to face what he had witnessed, and eventually escaped from this unnamed

island, but it was hard to escape his psychological impact from this world.A Thesis for the Degree of Master of Arts

4

In the next year, Wells published another work The Invisible Man. This novel

tells a story about a maniac scientist called Griffin who has discovered the secret of

invisibility and has taken the drug responsible for the incredible feat. Griffin begins to

use his invisibility for nefarious purposes, including murder. To escape the hunting

and terror in London, Griffin arrives at Iping, an English country village. Many local

townspeople are suspicious of Griffin who brings hundreds of strange glass bottles

his luggage. At the same time, a mysterious burglary took place in the village. His

landlady questioned strangers about the theft of pastor’s home, the irritated stranger

torn down everything on his head, and people suddenly realized that he was an

invisible person. After escaping from the fight with crowd, he threatens a tramp called

Mr. Marvel to be his assistant and help him steal books left behind in the hotel.

Whereas Marvel was unwilling to be served by him, wanted to sue him at the police

station, but also hid his three notebooks that contain records of his experiments. The


试阅到此结束,如需查看全部内容请购买正版文献。如因学习需要阅览全文,请联系站长。