中图分类号:
I561.074
论文编号:
1028712 15-S003
学科分类号:
050201
硕士学位论文
威尔斯科幻小说的神话思维研究
研究生姓名
贺 俊
学科、专业
英语语言文学
研 究 方 向
英美文学
指 导 教 师
何 江 胜
教授
南京航空航天大学
研究生院 外国语学院
二О一五年三月
A Study of the Mythological Thinking in
Wells’ Science Fictions
by
He Jun
Under the Supervision of
Professor
He Jiangsheng
Submitted in Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts
College of Foreign Languages
Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics
March, 2015
承诺书
本人郑重声明:所呈交的学位论文,是本人在导师指导下,独立
进行研究工作所取得的成果。尽我所知,除文中已经注明引用的内容
外,本学位论文的研究成果不包含任何他人享有著作权的内容。对本
论文所涉及的研究工作做出贡献的其他个人和集体,均已在文中以明
确方式标明。
本人授权南京航空航天大学可以有权保留送交论文的复印件,允
许论文被查阅和借阅
,
可以将学位论文的全部或部分内容编入有关数
据库进行检索,可以采用影印、缩印或其他复制手段保存论文。
(保密的学位论文在解密后适用本承诺书。)
作者签名:
导师签名:
日 期:
i
Acknowledgements
Upon the completion of this thesis, I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude
to those who have helped me in the process of the thesis writing.
First of all, my gratitude goes to Professor He Jiangsheng. His profound
knowledge has enlarged my vision of academic studies, and his professional
instruction made my study in the college truly memorable.
My gratitude also should go to other professors in College of Foreign Languages
in Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, such as Professor Shi Yunlong,
Professor Wang Xiaoling, Professor Wu Dingmin, Professor Fan Xiangtao, Professor
Sun Ruichao and Professor Jiang Lifu. Their inspiring lectures have helped me a lot in
the study of English language and literature.
Last but not least, I would like to express my gratitude to my beloved parents for
their unflagging support and encouragement as well as my roommates Wu Qingtao
and Neng Yankun who have accompanied me at the most difficult time in the writing
of this thesis.
ii
Abstract
Herbert George Wells is a British novelist, world-renowned for his science fiction.
Of all his ideas about science fiction writing, his mythological thinking is particularly
noteworthy. The thesis studies how Wells uses the mythological thinking to write
about the relationships between man and nature, between man and gods and between
science and myths. The thesis deals with the most of Wells’ science fiction, such as
The Time Machine, The Island of Dr. Moreau, When the Sleeper Wakes, The Invisible
Man, The War of the Worlds, The Food of the Gods and The World Set Free.
The thesis commences with The Introduction which discusses the researches done
by foreign and Chinese scholars on Wells and his literary works, especially those on
Wells’ science fiction in the perspective of mythology, providing the background for
further discussion. Then with the discussion of the features of the mythological
thinking, the thesis proceeds to elaborate on how Wells on the basis of the integration
of the object and the subject, questions the authority and power of science and
criticizes the unconscious arrogance of human beings. In Conclusion, the thesis
discusses the meanings of Wells’ mythological narrative in his science fiction.
Although Wells embraces the scientific development and acknowledges the benefits
gained from science, he takes a skeptical view on the omniscience of science and
believes in the simplicity of life by early human beings. The thesis argues that Wells
attempts to uncover the essence of the seemingly perfect science through a
mythological way. Furthermore, Wells tries to remind readers of the respect shown to
gods, which, if not seriously addressed, will endanger human being\'s true existence.
Key Words: Wells, science fiction, mythological thinking, human existence
iii
摘 要
赫伯特·乔治·威尔斯是英国著名小说家,尤以科幻小说闻名于世。统筹他
科幻小说创作的是神话思维。论文研究了威尔斯如何利用神话思维中的各种元素
来表达他对人与自然的关系、人神关系和科学与神话之间关系的看法。论文研究
囊括了大部分威尔斯的科幻小说,包括《时间机器》《莫罗博士岛》《昏睡百年》
《隐身人》《星球大战》《神食》《获得自由的世界》等。
论文以序言部分开始,介绍了中外学者对威尔斯作品的研究情况,尤其对威
尔斯科幻小说的神话学解读做了介绍,为论文的阐述提供背景支撑。接着论文论
证了威尔斯如何使用神话思维的特征来质疑科学的万能和至高无上,来批评人类
的盲目自大。在结论部分论文阐释了威尔斯利用神话叙事的真正意图。虽然威尔
斯对科学的发展抱着欢迎的态度并且承认科学带来的诸多好处,但是他也对科学
的无所不能抱以怀疑。威尔斯崇尚早期人类的纯朴生活,他以神话学的方法为读
者努力揭开看似万能的科学的真实面貌,并提醒读者保持对神的信仰。否则,人
类本身真实存在的意义就会荡然全无。
关键词:威尔斯,科幻小说,神话思维,人类存在
v
Contents
Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................... i
Abstract
..........................................................................................................................................
ii
摘 要
.............................................................................................................................................
iii
Introduction .................................................................................................................... 1
Chapter One The Integration of the Subject and the Object in Wells’ Works ............. 7
1.1 Human-God Relationship
.............................................................................................
7
1.2 Unity of Man and Nature
...........................................................................................
13
Chapter Two The Combination of Emotion and Reason in Wells’ Works ................ 18
2.1 Myth and Emotion
......................................................................................................
18
2.2 Myth and Reason
.........................................................................................................
22
Chapter Three Wells’ Mythological Symbols ........................................................... 28
3.1 Gyges’ Ring
..................................................................................................................
28
3.2 Forbidden Fruit
............................................................................................................
32
3.3 Circe’s Potion
...............................................................................................................
34
Chapter Four Wells’ Representation of Absurdity .................................................... 38
4.1 Lemur and Octopus
.....................................................................................................
38
4.2 Volatile God
..................................................................................................................
41
4.3 Defamiliarization of Time
.........................................................................................
44
4.4 Wells’ Mission
..............................................................................................................
46
Conclusion
...................................................................................................................................
50
Works Cited
.................................................................................................................................
52
Publication....................................................................................................................57
1
Introduction
Herbert George Wells (1866-1946) is a British novelist, world-renowned for his
science fiction. The publication of The Time Machine in 1895 established his fame
overnight. Wells enjoys high reputation in literature, reputed as “Shake Spear of
Science Fiction” and “British Jules Verne”. As a science fiction writer who criticized
social reality, Wells was visionary in observing numerous problems that scientific
development brings to the society, revealing such problems with his writing. Wells
with his strong sense of humanity kept seeking the most appropriate way for human
beings to live on earth, through his exploration of Utopia, which shows Wells’
concern for the destruction of the natural environments by the modern industrial
civilization and for the degeneration of humanity. To analyze the mythological
thinking adopted by Wells in his literary works presents his strong social
responsibility and his ultimate concern for human existence, significant in culture and
literature.
To analyze the myths used in Wells’ literary works, on the one hand provides a
new perspective to do the research on Wells and on the other deepens the study of the
relationship between myth and science. Wells combines the old with the new,
illuminating the way to human’s true belief.
Wells’ science fiction are very imaginative, interesting and philosophical. In 2002
and 2005 his science fiction The Time Machine and The War of the Worlds were made
films by Hollywood, huge box-office success. Coren thinks Wells is “a writer
touched by genius and capable of work that will forever delight those who read it.”
(Scheick 1994:361)
Western scholars have already made the research on Wells a rather systematic
discipline, with a large number of collections of Wells’ works, research monograph
and dissertations published. The research is wide in scope and profound in content.
2
The researches on Wells and his literary works are done from the perspectives of
psychology, ethics, logic, sex, religion, Utopia, etc.
Comparative studies on Wells’ works are done by western scholars. Researchers
place Wells in the context of British literature and world literature, taking comparative
means to elaborate on Wells’ unique creation mode. They compared Wells with other
distinguished literary figures, such as Edgar Allan Poe, George Bernard Shaw and
William Butler Yeats, deepening the understanding of Wells’ creation mode and
literary theme. David Cody in his Faulkner, Wells, and the “End of Man” considered
the same literary theme expressed by Faulkner and Wells. He pointed out that Wells
like Faulkner contemplated “the ultimate fate of mankind in a nuclear age and
considers the role that the writer might play in helping to determine that fate.” (Cody
1993:466) Alex MacDonald in his “Passionate Intensity” in Wells’ The Island of
Doctor Moreau and Yeats’s “The Second Coming”: Constructing an Echo declared
his own views on Wells citing Yeats’s poems that Wells did so in order to express his
literary theme on biblical myth.
The study of Utopia novels is also the perspective often adopted by western
scholars. John Partington in The Death of the Static: H.G.Wells and the Kinetic Utopia
elaborately analyzed the Utopia theme of Wells’ novels, making his own conclusion
and comment to the development of Wells’ thought of Utopia. He thinks Wells shifts
his notions of Utopia, from a static one to a kinetic one because of “T.H.Huxley’s
teachings of the evolutionary process”. (Partington 2000:96) Robert Crossley in The
First Wellsians: A Modern Utopia and Its Early Disciples takes consideration the
influence of Wells’ kinetic Utopia. He thinks Wells’ notion of kinetic Utopia greatly
interests the young people and he concludes the development of the word “wellsian”.
Crossley gives an exact definition of wellsian, referring to those who take Wells as
their idol, and he thinks “the first wellsians came being shortly after A Modern
Utopia was published in 1905.” (Crossley 2011:444) In his opinion the first wellsians
were “fervent young readers who wanted to imitate and indeed become the Samurai
3
of H.G.Wells’ imagination.” (ibid)
In China The Time Machine and The War of the Worlds were translated
Chinese and introduced in 1915 by Shanghai Progress Book Store, which laid the
foundation for the research of Wells. In 1956 Xu Keming issued his book review
Wells’ The Invisible Man, pointing out that in his science fiction “Wells combines his
marvelous imagination of human future with the bitter critique on the ugly and
distorting nature of capitalism in his country.” (Xu 1956:431) It is obvious that the
Chinese scholars at that time focused their attention on the ideological status in Wells’
fiction when they did the literary research on his works. After 1980s the research of
Wells done by Chinese scholars began to pick up its momentum. In 1984 Lin Ning
in Interviews of Wells and His Memoirs Edited by Hammond advocated that readers
should often read Wells’ science fiction for “it not only brings literary beauty but also
delivers serious consideration of the future.” (Lin 1984:149) In 1985, Hou Weirui,
famous English and American literature expert in Shanghai International Studies
University proposed his own views on Wells’ realistic creation. All in all, before 2000
the research of Wells and his literary works was still in its preliminary stage.
After 2000 with the popularity of the films The Time Machine and The War of the
Worlds progress of the research on Wells has been made continuously by Chinese
scholars. What’s more, the scholars have diversified the research methods and the
perspectives. They mainly focused on the perspectives of Utopia, ethics and
psychology.
As to the perspective of Utopia Chinese scholars mainly follow the old track left
by western scholars, but still made some progresses. Xi Qian in A Study of Wells’
Utopia Novels discusses the outline of Wells’ Utopia novels, artistic pattern, artistic
function and ideological basis. She made a careful analysis of Wells’ Utopia novels,
stating the difference between Wells’ Utopia and other Utopias in literature. The
difference lies in “the introduction of the science power which fills the process of the
construction of the Utopia and the strengthened standard of alienating Utopia.” (Xi
4
2009:abstract) It is indicated in the passage that Wells’ science fiction function as a
critique on reality and an imagination of future. The ideological basis of Wells’ Utopia
novels lies in Wells’ own views on science, humanity and politics. In 2010 Dr. Wang
Yiping went further ahead from the characteristics and nature of Wells’ Utopia to the
value and disadvantages of his Utopia. It is demonstrated in the passage that the value
of Wells’ Utopia is originated from the breaking of the shackle by previous writers
who think Utopia is perfect and static. Also Wells was much more visionary for he
proposed the idea of a world-wide Utopia. Doctor Wang thinks Wells “set up a new
era of Utopian imagination.” (Wang 2011:91) What’s more, the passage indicates
Wells not only designed Utopia from a macro aspect but also laid down detailed rules
to realize his own Utopia while at the same time there are still some disadvantages.
Wells’ wish to maintain the Utopia by rules is contradictory to the nature of Utopia
itself.
The research perspectives of ethics and psychology are also very popular in
Chinese scholars who study Wells. Liu Xiao in Ethical Shock Led by Science in Wells’
Science Fiction claims that the development of science helps resolve many social
problems while it may lead to the change of values, moral standards, dreams and
pursuits, even worse to the loss of social responsibility. Liu Changyun in The
psychological Transmutation of Kipps in H.G.Wells’ Kipps, with the key word
“psychology”, combined with the background of Edward’s Britain and the social
context, discusses Kipps’s psychological transmutations in each phase of development.
Ma Jiaoyan in Wells’ Self Shaping in Tono-Bungay answers “how Wells shapes
himself through the pursuit of his identity and challenging the mainstream
consciousness.” (Ma 2012:1)
Except those mainstream researches mentioned above, Chinese scholars also turn
to study feminism, myth and archetypal criticism and other literary techniques. Chen
Yinwen adopted the perspective of feminism to analyze the female images in Wells’
novels, finding out the rich characters and subtle activities of mentality in those
5
female figures. She pointed out that Wells pays attention to women in a subordinate
position and their existence dilemma, affirmative in women’s brave pursuit of
happiness. Jia Zhigang in A Study of Wells’ Creation Mode and Artistry analyzes
Wells’ literary works from the respect of creation mode and artistry, suggesting that
Wells is good at applying mythological images to strengthen his literary theme. He
said “mythological elements may appear under Wells’ pen, such as Frazer’s Golden
Bough, Greek myth, Jung’s archetypes and primitive religious symbols.” (Jia 2008:29)
As a result in Wells’ novels and short stories mythological images such as water, fire,
dream, drowning, garden and cave appear very often. Therefore Wells bridges science
and myth through the application of mythological images, deepening the
understanding of the relationship between science and myth.
Generally speaking, the research on Wells by western scholars has been deployed
with different perspectives, multiple levels and full scope. There are not only
individual researches on Wells’ single piece of work such as The Time Machine, The
War of the Worlds, A Modern Utopia and The Island of Dr Moreau but also general
researches. There are not only comparative literature researchers who put Wells along
in the line of other writers, such as Allan Poe, Faulkner, Yeats, but also those who use
literary theory to explain Wells’ literary works from the perspectives of feminism and
Reader-Response Theory, etc. The research on Wells in China is still in its preliminary
stage, scope of perspectives limited and profundity less. The author come across
numerous mythological elements while reading Wells’ science fiction. On the basis of
the previous study in mythology the author concludes the mythological thinking
adopted by Wells from those elements. Through a detailed analysis of the text together
with the enlightenment from the study of the theories in myth and archetypal criticism
the thesis believes that the adoption of the perspective of myth and archetypal
criticism to do the research on Wells’ science fiction, studying the infiltration of
mythological thinking in his science fiction, is a new approach. The previous
researches from the same perspective are only a few in number and stay in the
6
picking-up process of mythological images. The previous scholars adopted myth and
archetypal criticism only to enrich their study of Wells’ literary techniques, without
the ambition to find the mythological thinking embodied in his fiction and to uncover
Wells’ true meaning of the construction of a mythological context. Based on the
previous researches from the perspective of myth, the thesis serves as a complement.
试阅到此结束,如需查看全部内容请购买正版文献。如因学习需要阅览全文,请联系站长。