、??
指导教师:王寺fL?(签字)??On?化e?Pos化umanist?Views?in??
Angela?Carter’s?Science?Fiction?Writing??
by??
LinYi??
Under?the?Supervision?of??
Professor?Wang?Shouren??
Submittedhi?Partial?Fulfillment?of?化eRequirements??
For?t:he?Degree?of?Master?of?Arts??
English?Department??
School?of?Foreign?Studies??
Nanjing?University??
May?2014??I?hereby?declare?that?this?submission?is?my?own?work?and?that,?to?the?best?of?my??
knowledge?and?belief,?it?contains?no?material?previously?published?or?written?by??
another?person?or?material?which?has?to?a?substantial?extent?been?accepted?for?the??
award?of?any?other?degree?or?diplom过?at?any?university?or?other?institute?of?higher??
learning,?except?where?due?acknowledgment?has?been?made?in?the?text.??
Signature:??
Name?二?Lin??
Date:?May.?25,?2014??ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS??
While?mo巧?of?the?journey?of?writing?my?MA?thesis?is?打ecessary?泣?lonely?one,化??
can?never?be?completed?without?the?crucial?aid?and?support?from?my?supervisor,??
teachers,?friends?and?family.??
I?want?to?give?my?utmost?thanks?to?my?supervisor?Professor?Wang?Shouren,?who??
has?been?过?catalyst?in?so?many?ways?for?me.?I?benefited?enormously?from?his??
professional?mentorship,?encouragement,?patience?and?precious?time.??
A?special?note?of?gratitude?goes?化?Professor?He?Ning?and?Dr.?Dan?Hansong.??
Dialogues?and?化scussions?with?them?inspired?me?泣?lot?A?single?word?or?phrase?from??
them?would?kter?geoerstc?泣?par沒gr泣ph,过?section,eve打过?whole?ch泣pter.??
I?also?want?化?thank?my?classmates?and?friends?fbr?their?critical?comments?and??
helpful?suggestions.??
I?am?very?gratefiil?to?my?parents.?They?cheered?my?up?and?constantly?reminded??
me?化?listen?1:o?others,instructions?and?opinions?durin呂?my?writing?process.?Their??
wisdom?has?always?been?這?treasure?in?my?Kfe.??
L.?Y.??
ii??南京大学研究生毕业论文中文摘要首页用纸??
毕业论文题目:论安吉拉?卡特科幻小说创作中的后人文主义观念??
英语语言文学
?专业2012级硕壬生延違:?林懿??
指导教师(姓若、职称):
?
王守告教授??
摘要??
安吉拉?卡特(1940-1992)被誉为当代英国最有原创性作家之一。当前学术??
界对卡特作品的研究仍存在研究视角有限、研究过于偏重其激进女性主义立场与??
后现代创作手法的问题。卡特作品中体现出的后人文主义观念往往被评论家一笔??
带过或是完全忽略,而该观念又在她创作的科幻小说中体现得尤为突出。由此,??
本文选取卡特的H部科幻小说:《英雄与恶徒》(1969)、《霍夫曼博±地狱般的欲??
望机器》(1972)与《新夏娃的激情》(1977)为考察对象,意在分析作者在其中??
表现出的后人文主义思想。论文通过考察H部小说中卡持对人类狂会、人类主体??
与人类性别身份的思考,表明卡特对人性之理解根植于变异、生成与边界消弼这??
些理念,攝弃了传统的本质主义与(主体)孤立自治的观点。卡特的科幻作品拌??
击了经典人文主义一贯秉持的人之理念,其视角特点已经进入当今后人文主义的??
前沿范畴。??
对后人文主义而言,经典人文主义是作为人类化会的霸权性意识形态和对人??
的错误定义而存在的。后人文主义故而在两个主要层面颠覆人文主义话语:社会??
层面与人之主体性层面。此外,一些女性后人文主义学者将后人文思潮与性别问??
题研究结合起来,til巧除传统的性别本质主义与二元性别划分,这些思考形成后??
人文主义话语的第呈个层面。安吉拉?卡特的科幻小说可^说涵盖了1^>1上呈个关??
注层面;本文分析的H部小说每一部都突出体现了其中的一个层面。??
论文第一章研究卡特在《英雄与恶徒》中体现的后人文主义人类狂会观。人??
文主义在其狂会话语层面W目的论为主宰,这一哲学思路在后人文主义观念中则??
被不确定性和变异性所取代。小说里人类历史与人类租会不再线性连贯,而是与??过去断裂,并于裂痕中析出多种发展可能,与后人文主义所倡导吻合。第二章探??
索卡特在《霍夫曼博±的欲望机器》中体现的后人文主义人类主体观。在后人文??
主义看来,人类主体既不是固定而独立自治的,也不再受制于纯粹理性,而是被??
理解为可变且复杂的实体。小说人物的主体性处于不断变动、并与外界力量互动??
的过程中。视觉科技的发展则进一步促进了对人类主体认识的改变。第H章分析??
卡特在《新夏娃的激情》中体现的后人文主义性别身份观。后人文主义摄弃在人??
文主义的二元对立与本质主义逻輯下形成的规范性性别身份。小说主要角色跨越??
了非男则女的性别划分边界,暗示在新的科技情境下,多元的性别表达已成为可??
能。这响应了后人文主义的性别身份主张。??
卡特的作品从未完全舍弃人文主义话语,或对后人文主义宣称的人文主义定??
义之下"人"之终结一味称颂。H部小说通过对人文主义思想进斤批判性的严肃??
反思,在新旧两种关于人类状况的理解见架起对话的桥梁,并W此为契机展望当??
下不断临近的后人文情境。??
关键词:安吉拉?卡恃;后人文主义;人文主义;科幻小说??南京大学研究生毕业论文英文摘要首页用纸??
THESIS:?On?the?Posthumanist?Views?in?Angela?Carter’s??
Science?Fiction?Writing??
SPECIALIZATION:?Englkh?Language?and?Literature??
POSTGRADUATE:?Lin?巧??
MENTOR:?Profe化or?Wang?Shouren??
ABSTRACT??
Angela?Carter?(1940-1992)?is?one?of?the?most?original?contemporary?British??
writers.?Studies?of?her?writing?are?stiU?limited?in?perspective?and?quite?imbalanced,??
pivoting?on?her?radical?feminism?and?postmodern?writing?style.?The?posthxunanist??
views?expressed?in?Carter,s?writing,mo巧?palpably?in?her?science?fiction?writing,have??
been?largely?neglected?if?ever?inched?upon.?This?paper?attempts?化?analyze?Carter,s??
posthumanist?views?in?her?science?巧ctions:巧如0的?a灼朽//加打文(1969),77於?巧廣m幻/??
Desire?Machines?of?Doctor?Hoffinan?(1972),md?The?Passion?of?New?Eve?(1977).?By??
exploring?Carter,s?reflecdons?on?human?social?state,human?subjectivity?and?human??
gender?identity?in?these?three?novels,?this?paper?argues?that?Angela?Carter?gives?a??
radical?critique?of?classical?humanism,s?concepts?on?humanity?in?her?science?fiction??
writing.?Her?views?of?humanity?as?rooted?in?mutation,?transgressions?of?boundaries??
and?becoming?rather?than?e巧entialism?or?isolation,have?entered?the?realm?of??
posthumanism.??
Posthumanism?regards?classical?humanism?as?a?hegemonic?ideology?in?human??
society?and?a?flawed?concept?of?man.化?aims?at?subverting?humanist?discourse?from??
two?main?layers:?the?social?layer?and?the?layer?of?human?subjectivity.?Moreover,?some??
female?posthumani巧?scholars?combine?posthumanist?thoughts?in?the?study?of?gender??
issues,so?as?to?debunk?traditio打al?gender?essentialism?and?duali巧?gender?categories,??this?idea?forms?a?third?layer?of?posthumanism.?Angela?Carter,s?science?石ction?writing??
embodies?all?three?aspects?of?posthiimanism;?the?three?works?analyzed?here?each??
highlights?one?of?these?aspects?as?the?most?outstanding.??
Chapter?One?studies?Carter,s?posthumanist?view?on?human?society?in
?幻说^??
W//幻如反虹?its?social?discourse,?humanism?is?characterized?by?the?philosophy?of??
teleology,which?is?substituted?by?posthumanism?for?a?sense?of?uncertainty?and??
mutation.?In?the?novel?human?history?and?society?are?described?in?an?abyssal?rapture??
from?tile?past,?and?exude?multiple?possibilities,?which?concur?with?what??
posthumanism?advocates.?Chapter?Two?explores?Carter,s?posthumani巧?view?on??
human?subjectivity?in?The?Infernal?Desire?Machines?of?Doctor?Hoffinan.?Human??
subjectivity?in?pos化umani巧?view?is?no?lo曰ger?autonomous?or?fixed,11?彷r?ruled?by?pure??
reason,?but?is?changeable?and?complex.?Accordingly,?the?characters^?subject?in?the??
novel?is?mobile?and?interactive?1:o?outside?forces;?visual?technology?transforms?the??
understanding?of?human?subject?even?further.?Chapter?Three?analyzes?Carter,s??
posthxunanist?view?on?gender?identity?in?The?Passion?of?New?Eve,?Posthumanism??
rejects?化e?regulative?gender?identity?under?humani巧?logics?of?essentialism?and?binary??
opposition.?The?main?characters?of?the?novel?transgress?the?boundary?of?mde/female??
division,?implying?the?possibility?of?multiple?gender?expressions?imder?new??
technological?situation,which?coincides?wi化?posthumanisUdeas.??
Carter,s?works?never?leave?humani巧?discourse?behind?and?gleefully?celebrate?the??
end?of?Man?(under?humanism?definition).?Rather,?by?reflecting?on?liberal??
humanism,s?ideas?in?泣?critical?way,?these?three?novels?open?up?a?dialogue?between?old??
and?new?understandings?about?human?states,?and?envisage?the?coming?of??
contemporary?posthuman?condition.??
Key?words;?Angela?Carter;?posthumanism;?humanism;?science?fiction??ABBREVIATIONS??
DM?The?Infernal?Desire?Machines?of?Doctor?Hoffinan??
HV?Heroes?and?Villains??
PNE?The?Passion?of?New?Eve??
in??Table?of?CoMents??
Acknowledgements
??
?ii??
Abbreviations
?iii??
Introduction?1??
Chapter?One??
From?Teleology?to?Uncerteinty:?Posthumanist?View?on?Human?Society?in??
Heroes?and?Villains
?11??
I.?Linear?History?Interrupted:?Incoherence?and?Contingency
?13??
II.?Despotic?Social?Order?Problematised:?Crises?of?Rationalism
?17??
III.?Singular?"Man"?Imperiled:?Diversity?against?Totality
?20??
Chapter?Two??
From?Hubris?to?Humility:?Posthumanist?View?on?Human?Subjec枯vity?in??
Desire?Machines
?25??
I.?"I?Desire?Therefore?I?Am":?the?Enigmatic?Subject?of?the?Unconscious27??
II.?"Who?is?Desiring?Me?":?Subjects?化at?Debunk?Absolute?Autonomy.....?31??
III.?"The?Machine?化at?Therefo巧?I?Am":?Human?Subjectivity?in?High-tech?£巧??
??
?34??
Ch£ipter??巧?e??
From?Dualism?to?Pluralism:?Pos化umanist?View?on?Gender?Identity?in?77}e??
Passion?of?New?Eve
??
?39??
I.?Beauty?in?Performance:?Challenge?虹?Gender?Essentialism
?41??
II.?Performer-in-process:?Deconstruction?of?Gendered?Substances?
?45??
III.?Cyborgian?Body:?Th巧at?and?Chance?for?Mu阳pie?Gender?Identity?49??
Conclusion?54??
Works?Cited
?57??
iv??INTRODUCTION??
In?"The?Noveli巧?at?the?Crossroads,,,David?Lodge?sugge船?that?since?the?1960s,??
literary?realism^s?central?position?has?been?rigoromly?questioned?among?western??
writers.?Britidi?writer?Angel过?Carter?(1940-1992)?clearly?belongs?1;o?化e?radical??
non-realistic?camp,化gether?with?other?literary?innovators?such?as?Salman?民ushdie,??
Peter?Ackroyd?and?J.?Q?Ballard.?As?泣?staunch?supporter?and?practitioner?of?what??
Lodge?calls?wfabulatory"?writi打g?(^Novelist?Today,,),Carter?always?^suspendfs]??
realistic?illusion?…in?the?intere巧?of?a?freedom?in?plotting,,(Lodge,"Crossroads,,).??
Whether?infusing?the?Gothic?with?the?grotesque,?incorporating?the?picaresque?into??
science?fiction,or?conflating?the?fairy?tale?wi化?the?pornographic,Carter,s?writing??
artfiilly?employs?a?pastiche?of?literary?forms?and?fti化?them?into?new?ones.?Working??
magic?on?language,?Carter?is?also?much?lauded?for?her?outlandish?tone?and?baroque??
syntax.?(T^owhere?else?…have?English?sentences?been?so?meandering?and?convoluted,??
nowhere?else?have?they?undergone?such?syntactic?folding?and?unfurling/^?(Ocana?73)??
However,?as?one?of?Britain's?most?original?and?provocative?contemporary?writers.??
Carter?is?not?!:〇?be?mixed?with?the?kind?of?"fabulists"?who?are?all?for?stylistic??
experiments?as?they?cut?writing?from?worldliness?and?indulge?in?textual?play.?For?her,??
"
all?art,of?any?kind,is?part?of?politics?—?it?either?expresses?or?criticises?an?ideology,,??
(Bedford?53).?At?the?heart?of?Carter,s?oeuvre?is?汪?Ksistance?again巧?the?social?""truth"??
that?is?often?consolidated?in?traditional?realism.?Wilh?an?annoyance?at?Charles?Dickens??
(who?she?化inks?as?a?strip-cartoonist)?and?Jane?Auste打(whose?mannered?charm?she??
finds?deadly),Carter?produces?fictio打?that?"can?scarcely?pretend?化?be?an?imitatio打?of??
nature,so?it?cannot?di化eminate?false?knowledge?of?the?world"?(Carter,"Gothic??
Mode"?133).?She?writes?both?to?re-vision?and?to?envision,?giving?tre打chant?critiques?of??
old?assumptio打s?as?well?as?casting?打ew?light?on?peopIe,s?outlook?of?化e?world.?Edward??
J.?Aheam?suggests?that?Carter,s?writing?is?in?fact?"rooted?in?visionary?traditions"?(453),??
which?coul过巧nd?their?way?back?化?William?目lake.?According?to?Abeam,visionary??
writing?"explodes?the?stabilities?of?world?and?person,time?and?space,?conscious打ess??
1??and?sexual?identity,?and?with?them?religious?and?ideological?certainties?concerning??
society?and?history,,?口bid).?The?description?fits?Carter,s?works.??
Carter?was?a?prolific?writer.?In?her?fifty-two?years,lifetime?she?produced?nine??
novels,several?volumes?of?short?stories,along?with?some?radio?plays,journalism?and??
literary?criticism.?Yet?she?is?best-known?as?a?noveli巧?and?short?巧ory?writer.?Carter,s??
fiction?writing?can?be?generally?divided?into?three?phases,?starting?from?the?somewhat??
mimetic,?to?the?speculative?(especially?in?the?science?fiction?genre),?to?the?fairy?tale??
mode.?Her?early?打ovels?57約成w?Ztomre。966),iSevera/?iVc巧化my。968)?and?Zove??
(1971),mentioned?together?as?'他e?Bristol?Trilogy,,,bear?化e?imprints?of?traditional??
literary?realism,?although?they?are?already?''saturated?with?domesticated?Gothic?and??
psychological?fantasy?elements"?(0,Day?43).?With?the?publication?of?成roey?幻??
Villaim?(1969),、抗?llowed?by?The?Infernal?Desire?Machines?of?Doctor?Hoffincm?(1972)??
and?The?Passion?of?New?Eve?(1977),?Carter?demonstrates?a?stronger?willingness?in??
giving?speculative?insights?化?society?and?human?consciousness,?and?过?mind?more??
resolute?in?resisting?realism?with?stylistic?innovation.?From?the?late?seventies?on.??
Carter?once?again?shifts?artistic?gears.?TTze?公/〇〇却?C7z面6獻幻m/?0成er?汉on.ey。979)??
explores?gender?stereotypes?by?retelling?fairy?tales?witii?surprising?turns?of?plot?Her??
last?two?novels?also?bear?traits?of?tail-tale?narratives.??
Scholarly?attention?出dn,t?favor?Carter?during?her?lifetime?as?much?as??
posthumously,?and?mo巧?of?which?focused?on?her?first?and?last?stage?of?writing.?Her??
early?novels,?written?somewhat?under?the?realist?tradition,were?well?received,?and??
established?her?as?a?promising?writer.?However,?with?Ihe?coming?out?of?her?''fiction??
of?speculation,,,reviewers?became?increasingly?alarmed?that?"Carter,s?literary??
fireworks?were?getti打g?a?bit?化o?explosive,,(Katsavos,Car论?*?2).?This?second?phase??
marked,?as?Carter?commented,化e?beginni打呂?of?her?obscurity.?From?then?on,she??
"
went?from?being?a?very?promising?young?writer?to?being?ignored"?(qtd.?in?Ali?Smith??
12),?It?was?not?until?the?publication?of?The?Bloody?Chamber?that?Cartercritical??
1?The?division?of?Carter’s?writing?phase?is?a?general?0打e.?Some?overlapping?is?allowed?for.?The?more?reali巧沁王ove??
was?i打?fact?written?two?years?after?方era仍口wc/?胤/幻,>2五,a?speculative?novel.??
2?Carter’s?first?novel,r&e?M?各fc
?was?awarded?化e?1967?John?Llewellyn?Rhys?prize;?her?third?novel:??
Several?Perceptions,?was?honored?with?the?1968?Somerset?Maugham?Award.??
2??acclaim?returned.?This?book?brought?Carter?to?化e?public?gaze?in?泣?way?that?her?缸St??
seven?novels?had?not.?The?critical?succe巧?extended?化?her?following?打ovels.??
Carter^s?reputation?and?influence?have?risen?substantially?since?her?untimely??
death?in?1992.?Around?her?writing?style?has?clustered?a?wide?range?of?topics?化?date,??
such?as?the?influence?of?magic?realism?(Bayley?9-11)?and?surrealism?(Suleiman??
115-122;?Roe?78-99),Carter,s?postmodern?writing?strategy?(Gonzalez?507-515),her??
web?of?intertextual?references?(Bonca?56-62),?and?her?adoption?of?Bakhtinian??
camivalesque?spirit?(Boehm?84-89).?Thematically,?Carter?is?frequently?labeled?as??
"feminist,,,which?is?化stifled?by?prominent?critics?and?writers?like?Elaine?Showalter,??
Laura?Mulv巧?and?M壯garet?Atwood.?3?Yet?still,Carter,s?three?main?speculative??
novels.?Heroes?and?Villains,?The?Infernal?Desire?Machines?of?Doctor?Hoffman??
(hereafter?Des/re?M口cAmes)?and?巧26?户幻s如0。o/iVew?風冶,are?largely?neglected.??
iStarting?from?only?沒?dec江dc?过g〇3?the?study?of?Angela?Carter?i打?Ghina?is?long??
overdue?and?is?more?imbalanced.?An?overwhelming?proportion?of?important?essays?on??
Carter?is?about?her?short?stories?from?7%e?公C足幻while?the?rest?stick?1:o??
her?mo巧?f猶ous?novel?M挪友26?C7ra从虹?comparison,7%e?化獻沁巧?置ve??
emerges?only?sporadically?in?a?few?e泌ays?and?化ssertations.?M公从沁es?is??
barely?出?scussed?except?in?one?doctoral?dissertation?and?a?treatise?on?Carter?(Zeng??
Xuemei,?Mu?Yang).?The?analysis?of?Heroes?and?Villains^?an?important?novel?by??
Carter,s?own?admission?(Katsavos,"Interview"?12),is?nowhere?to?be?found?in?China.??
In?fact,as?some?western?scholars?have?come?化?realize?in?recent?years,?these?three??
novels?feature?more?prominently?Carter,s?"visionary?writing"化an?any?other?of?her??
works?does.?Ocafia?巧gards
?。巧</?巧化ri打s?as?"Carter,s?mo巧?glamorous?[novel]"??
for?its?audacious?investigation?into?social?political?power?(0〇她过?69).?Ali?Smith??
maintains?that?Z)es7>e
?is?"Carter,s?lost?classic,,,because?it?foresees?the?age??
of?simulacrum:?"you?can?see?how?visionary?a?work?it?is,?now,reading?化?in?the?virtual??
age,,(11).?r&?戶幻獻把打?o/TVew?£Ve,?claime过?by?Carter?as?her?favourite?novels?(qtd.?in??
3?S说?Elaine?洗owalter^?Zi化ra/wre?0/772ez>?Own?巧23-331),Laura?Mulv巧"Cinema?Magic?細d?the?Old?Monsters:??
Ange化?Carter's?Cinema’',?and?Margar幻?Atwood?‘书Ainnkig?with?the?Tigers".??
^?For?example?essays?written?by?Li?Weiping?and?Cheng?Huijuan?(2010),?Wang?Labao?and?Huangjie?(2009),?and??
Zheng?Baiqing?(2011).??
3??Jordan?224),?touches?upon?frontier?topics?such?as?kchnology,(trans)gender??
phenomena?and?cyborgian?bodies,?which?in?Sarah?Gamblers?opinion?have?entered?''the??
futuristic?realm?of?the?posthuman,,(53).?With?their?"apocalyptic?visio打s"?(Patricia?J.??
Smith?391)?of?hximan?society?and?culture,?these?three?speculative?novels?—?more??
specifically?science?fiction?novels?—?can?be?see打?as?Carter,s?most?effective?vehicles?of??
subversion.??
Produced?in?the?second?phase?of?Carter?writing?career,?the?three?novels?bear?a??
lot?of?resemblance.?They?are?''the?three?novels?in?which?Carter?most?clearly?uses?the??
trope?of?SF?[science?fiction]?and?genre?fantasy,,(Kaveney?185)-?And?1;ogether?tihey??
show?Carter,s?thematic?undertaking?is?not?confined?within?femini巧?concerns,but??
extends?to?different?aspects?of?humanity,?from?sociohistorical?issues?to?human??
subjectivity?and?ge打der?identity.?As?Elai打e?Jordan?suggests,these?three?works?could??
be?read?as?a?sequence?(208).?They?most?obviously?exhibit?how?Carter^s?writing??
"
encourage[s]?people?化?i*eflect?on?the?pure?and?simple?fact?of?being?human,,??
(Cavallaro?6)?until?it?turns?out?to?be?"neither?pure?打or?simple,and?hardly?to?qualify??
for?definition?as?泣"fact",卿id).?By?contemplating?human?existence?under?new??
techno-scientific?situations,化ese?three?打ovels?give?泣如specting?second?thought?on?a??
wide?range?of?old?assumptions?backed?up?by?the?domineering?humani巧?ideas.?They?all,??
化?follow?Sar地?Gamble,s?brief?mentioning,have?entered?the?realm?of?posthumanism.??
While?"posthumanism"?is?still?an?unsettled?neologism?used?in?various?ways,巧?is??
ge打erally?accepted?as?过打umber?of?critical?mutatio打s?that?refuse?化?take?humanist??
claims?for?granted?and?aspire?化?challenging?化e?hegemony?of?humanism.?Therefore,??
化?pinpoint?化e?tenets?of?pos化umanism?entails?clarifying?humanism?—化e?object?it??
emphatically?repudiates.??
Humanism?emerged?during?the?16化?ce打tury?Re打aissance,when?the?("theoce打trie巧??
worldview?of?medieval?Christianity?was?rejected?in?favor?of?a?"homocentric??
paradigm"化at?shifted?the?focus?from?God?to?Man?(Best?and?Kellner?180).?It?化en??
came?化?its?prime?during?化e?Enlightenment?and?the?modem?time.虹?its?goal?化??
remove?human?bei打gs?from?化eir?obeisant?tutelage?of?God,humanism?promotes??
human?出gnity,secular?values,化chnological?mastery?and?scienti巧c?rationality.??
4??However,?in?posthumanist?views,much?as?we?have?benefited?from?these?humanist??
advocations^?they?also?tend?to?go?awry?and?become?oppressive?narratives.?In?its??
promotion?of?humanity,?humanism?insists?on?a?sovereign?human?subject?and?a?basic??
human?essence,which?"we巧?humans?share?and?the?"other"?non-human?don,t.?This??
assumption?leads?to?化e?enforcement?of?normality?and?totality,as?weU?as?a?binary??
system?for?human?identity.?Humanism?is?thus?used?as?an?insidious?weapon?against??
equality?(both?among?human?and?between?human?and?inhuman),for?the?"we,,in??
humanism?is?never?inclusive,?otiierwise?it?retains?a?hierarchy?based?on?the?values?and??
opinions?conjectured?by?a?small?privileged?minority.?Moreover,?humanisminsistence??
on?same打ess?i打evitably?leads?to?a?predestined?human?society,which?anticipates?化e??
facile?prediction?of?"progre巧巧?and?the?justification?of?the?shackles?of?regulative?social??
powers.?The?outrageous?weight?of?reason?assumed?in?humanist?discourse?also?brings??
trouble.?As?Kate?Soper?pointed?out,?''humanism?is?itself?presented?as?a?kind?of?religion??
?the?progre泌ive?cult?for?today,s?broadminded?rationalist"?(qtd.?in?Badmington,??
"Introduction"?2).?The?abusive?appeal?to?rationality?alienates?reasoning?from??
individual?thinkers;?it?has?become?"instrumental?reason,,一?reason?that?has?been??
tempted?by?the?lure?of?immediate,?hence?despotic,?translation?into?an?effective?polity.??
For?the?posthumanist?trend?in?general,?humanism?is?viewed?not?as?progressive?but??
as?reactionary,because?humanism?s^appeals?(positively)化?the?notion?of?a?core??
humanity?or?common?e巧ential?feature,in?terms?of?which?human?beings?can?be??
defined?and?understood,,(Badmington,"Introduction,,2).?In?posthumanism,?the??
sovereign?subje巧?of?reason?is?submerged?by?systems?of?desire?and?outside?forces;??
"
progress"?is?transformed?into?the?inclusive?and?^together?more?disquieting?structure??
of?mutation;?impermeable?boundaries?between?selC^ottier,?human/inhiiman,??
male/female,?natural/artificial?etc.?are?transgressed?or?even?melt?away.??
A?second?layer?of?posthumanism?is?characterized?by?its?keen?concerns?about??
contemporary?hi-tech?culture?and?how?化e?ever-accelerating?impact?of?1:echnology??
transforms?human?states?both?physically?and?ontologically.?As?Badmington?maintains,??
posthumanisjn?should?be?construed?as?"pos也uman-ism,,as?well?as?"post-humanism,,??
115).?A?large?group?of?frontier?posthumanists?locate?their?study?技elds?in??
5??techno-scientific?philosophy?化?analyze?the?states?of?化day,s?"posthumans,,一?human??
forms?that?are?no?longer?pure,?but?transformed?or?infected?by?technology.?N.?Katherine??
Hayles,most?打otably,explores?how?the?mind/body?dualism?is?出ssolved?by?virtual??
bodies?and?virtual?identities?on?化e?cyberspace?i打?//ow?脈及ec幻歷户0及娩謂aw;?and??
Robert?Pepperell,s?The?Posthuman?Condition?discusses?the?possibility?of??
understanding?human?CO打scious打ess?as?a?neural?circuit,much?like?an?electrical?one.??
Technological?change?has?become?"a?core?component?of?contemporary?imaginations??
about?posthumanity,,(Miah?2).虹?this?sense,posthumanism?is?also?defined?as?过??
marker?of?''the?shifting?condition?of?humanity?from?changes?in?scientific?and??
technological?developmenf^?(Reilly?4).?However,?ultimately?the?digging?into??
1:echno-scientific?issues?still?serves?to?overturn?humanist?discourse.?As?is?indicated?in??
Hayles,book,?high?化chnology?practically?deconstructs?humanist?boundaries?between??
mind?and?body,?male?and?female?etc.?And?in?Peppereirs?opinion,?high-tech?culture??
gives?a?deadly?attack?on?humanist?sovereign?subject?by?regarding?humanity?as??
indistinguishable?from?machines:?"Humanists?saw?themselves?as?出stinct?beings,in?泪1??
antagonistic?relation?with?their?surroundings.?Posthximanists,?on?the?other?hand,?regard??
their?own?being?in?an?extended?technological?world,,(Pepperell?187).??
On?a?third?layer,?posthumanism?should?be?understood?in?the?context?of??
postmodernism.?Between?the?two?trends?is?synchronicity?as?well?as?a?convergence?of??
basic?ideas.?Many?posthumanists?agree?that?the?emergence?of?posthumanist?thoughts??
should?date?back?1:0?1945?—化e?end?of?WW?n?(Best?and?Kellner?196-97).?At?that?time??
it?became?clear?that?irrationality?can?prevail?over?rationality?on?a?massive?scale,?and??
that?the?human?species?could?destroy?itself,?since?might?not?be?in?control?of?our??
own?technoprogency,,(化id.?197).?This?period?coincides?with?the?gennination?of??
postmodernism.?The?1960s?were?regarded?as?the?watershed?for?posthumanism,?with?a??
group?of?anti-humanist?scholars?challenging?the?humanist?idea?of?Man.?Those?scholars??
are?mostly?prominent?postmodern?thinkers/?Later,?Ihab?Hassan?in?1977?claimed?that??
5?For?example:?Foucault?in?TTze?〇沁/*?(^77?-巧拼。966)?proclaimed?^at?"man,,was?a?historical?construction?whose??
era?was?about?化?end:?Levi-Strauss,in?77ie?况V幻复e?Mr?陆sf。962).?revealed?化at?也e?supposedly?sovereign?human??
subjectivity?was?but?細?invention?of?the?Enlightenment.?Jacques?Derrida's?巧?say?"The?Ends?of?M?組’’(196^?points??
at?hum现ism,s?precarious?siiimtion?caused?by?its?own?tenets.??
6??''five?hundred?years?of?humanism?may?be?coming?to?an?end?as?hmnanism?transforms??
itself?into?something?that?we?must?helplessly?call?post-humanism"?(212),which?is??
widely?cited?as?the?beginning?for?posthumanism?to?gai打?wide?currency*?This?period??
(the?1970s)?was?also?the?heyday?of?postmodernism.??
Many?ideas?of?posthtimanism?concur?with?the?general?postmodern?proclamations,??
Linda?Hutcheon?states?that?posmodemism?aims?at?problematizing?the?notion?of?the??
''
centered?self^?(40),?contesting?the?entire?notion?of?continuity?in?history,?and??
overturning?a?human-centred?world?(62).?All?those?issues?are?of?posthumani巧??
ccmcems?犯?well.?Lyotard,s?famous?dictum:?"Let?us?wage?a?war?on?totality,,(82)?also??
holds?true?in?posthumanism.?Lying?at?the?core?of?posthumanism?is?the?intention?to??
shatter?humanism,s?master?narratives?化at?enforce?a?totality?on?humanity,and?to??
replace?化em?with?化6?ideas?of?出versity?and?mobility.?No?wonder?Andy?Miah?suggests??
that?posthumanism?actually?exhibits?"moments?of?concern…which?might?be?more??
broadly?conceived?as?a?postaiodem?anxiety"?口3).?We?mi班t?as?well?i^egard??
posthumanism?as?红"postmodern?humanism"?1:o?some?degree.?And?"posthuman??
framework??"?is?part?and?parcel?of?the?postmodern?condition"?(Best?and?Kellner?195),??
with?the?former?maintaining?a?special?concern?about?the?matrix?of?contemporary??
technology.??
The?afore-mentioned?three?layers?join?化?give?a?comprehensive?definition?of??
posthumanism.?Posthumanism?is?first?of?all?"post-humanism,,,泣?critique?of?classical??
humani巧?concepts.?Secondly,?it?is?"posthuman-ism,,,for?it?gives?foil?attention?to??
contemporary?high-tech?culture?and?its?transforming?power?on?human?states.?Thirdly??
it?echoes?a?"postmodern?idea?of?humanity,,,which?emerges?from?化e?postmodern??
cidture?in?general?and?overlaps?with?postmodernist?discourse?on?knowledge,?history??
and?hximan?subject.??
WHtten?during?the?formative?period?of?posthumanism?(the?late?1960s?化?the??
试阅到此结束,如需查看全部内容请购买正版文献。如因学习需要阅览全文,请联系站长。