硕士学位论文??福 承 * 彩 《 第 先 S 》 中 螓 反 种 族 裘 夂??钟天娇??专 业 名 称:英语语言 文学??研 究 方 向:文化研宄??论 文提 交 时 间:2 0 1 7年 4 月??论 文 答 辩 时 间:20 1 7年5 月??论 文 编 号!?2 0 1 7 1 69??学位论文独创性声明??本 人声 明 所 呈交 的 学位 论 文是 本人在 导 师指 导 下 进行的 研 宄工作 及取 得 的??研 宄成 果。据我 所 知,除 了 文 中 特别 加 以标 注和 致谢 的 地方 外,论 文 中 不 包含??其他人 己经 发表 或撰 写 过 的 研 宄成果,也不 包含 为 获得 四 川 外 国语 大学 或??其 他教育 机构 的 学 位 或证书而 使用 过 的 材料。与 我一同 工作 的 同志对 本研 究所??做的 任何贡 献均 己在 论文 中作 了 明 确 的说 明 并表示 谢意。??学位论文作 者签名 签字 日 期:年JT月4日??学位论文版权使用授权书??本学 位论文 作者 完全 了 解 四 川 外 国 语 大 学 有 关保留、使用 学位论文??的 规 定,有权保 留并 向 国 家 有关 部 门 或机构送交 论文 的 复印 件 和 电 子版,允许??论文被查 阅 和 借 阅.本 人授权 四 川 外 国 语 大 学 可 以将 学位论 文 的 全部 或部??分 内 容编 入有关数据 库进行检索,可 以 采用 影印、缩 印或 扫描 等复 制手 段保存、??汇编 学位 论文。??(保 密 的 学位 论文 在解密后适用 本授权书)??学位 论文 作者签 名;?人,?导 师签名^^?^?j??签 字 曰 期:; 年y 月々曰?签字 曰 期:災"年j:月 iy??曰?A??学 位论文 作者 毕业 后 去 向:??工作 单位:?电话:??通讯 地址:?邮 编:?? Sichuan International Studies University The Revelation of Anti-racism in District 9 By Zhong Tianjiao A thesis submitted to the Graduate School in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in English Language and Literature under the supervision of Professor Li Xiaoqing Chongqing, P. R. China April2017 iii 摘要 在 2009 年, 一部以纪录片形式拍摄的科幻片第九区惊喜上映了,吸引了众多观众的注意。没有科幻片里被广泛运用作为亮点的特效,该片以独特的纪录片拍摄形式和令人震惊的低至三千万美元的电影制作经费而著名。同近几年科幻片的流行趋势一般,该片也以备受科幻影迷追捧的外星人作为题材,讲述了 MNU 执行驱逐蜗居在居民区附近的不速之客,也就是外星人的任务,最终以主角的异化成外星人和外星人成功发动飞船离开地球告终。自从其上映以来,第九区成为了许多研究者的研究素材,一方面是因为其涉及主角异化成外星人的情节,另一方面是因其与历史上南非种族隔离事件的许多相似性。国内外的研究员和学者都对这部电影进行了深度的分析,试图解析电影中的人性本质以及分析其与南非种族隔离的关系。 本文试图从种族主义角度分析影片,并从三个主要方面来揭示影片的反种族主义主题。从电影的背景信息的选择来看,南非种族隔离与电影的相似之处说明这些安排并非偶然,通过作者的分析,这种特殊安排是为体现反种族主义而服务的。接着作者试图从外星人与人类之间的关系分析,指出带有优越身份的人类对外星人实施了许多不公平待遇并对其带有刻板成见,以此作为人类残害外星人并掠夺外星人先进武器技术的幌子。然而,外星人的成功逃脱对于有优越感的人类是一种讽刺,这种结果体现了电影的反种族主义主题。在文中最后,作者以电影主角 Wikus 为研究中心。通过基于一些身份认同理论对其变异过程的分析,作者认为他在变异前后表现出来的相悖的行为和想法,以及最终被外星人所救都指向电影中的反种族主义主题。 通过对该片的反种族主义主题的剖析,作者希望能借此为广大观众提供一个不同的思考角度,并希望这部电影能为当代世界存在的种族主义提供警示作用。 关键词:第九区;种族隔离;刻板成见;身份认同;反种族主义 iv Abstract In 2009, a science fiction film shot in a documentary form named District 9 was released, which has attracted much attention from the audiences from all circles since it came as a surprise for them. Without the special effects which are often applied in science fiction films as highlights, it is famous for its unique documentary style and makes people astonished at its inexpensive production budget about 30 million dollars. Like other popular current trends in science fiction films in recent years, it focuses on the alien creatures which are highly sought after by science fiction film fans and it depicts the process of implementing the mission signed by MNU( Multi-nation United) to evict aliens who accidentally appeared out of the district nearby the human residential areas and ends at the commander\'s (the main actor Wikus) transformation an alien and the success of aliens\' launch on the aircraft to leave the earth. Since its release, District 9 soon becomes the materials for many researchers due to its special plot of transformation of the main actor Wikus from a human an alien and its close connection with the Apartheid in South Africa concerning about many similarities between them. Many researchers and scholars from both home and abroad conduct serious analysis on this film, trying to dissect the human nature, identity issues, and the similarities between the Apartheid and this film. In this paper, the author tries to analyze the film from the perspective of racism and intends to reveal the theme of anti-racism in this film from three main aspects. From the perspective of the choice of the background information in the film, the similarities between the Apartheid and the film show that they are delicate arrangements and its intention through the analysis of the author is to express the theme of anti-racism. Then the authors tries to concerns about the relations between the aliens and human, pointing out that human with their superior status conduct unfair treatments and stereotypes on aliens so that they can find an excuse to treat the v aliens cruelly and to plunder the advanced weapon technology from the aliens. However, the success of the aliens\' escape from the earth is a satire for the superior human, leading to the presentation of the theme of anti-racism. Finally, the author focuses on the main actor Wikus. Through the analysis on the transformation experienced by him based on some identity theories, his opposite actions and thoughts before and after the transformation and the end of being saved by aliens all contribute to the anti-racism theme in this film. Through the analysis of the anti-racism theme in this film, the author hopes that it can provide a different perspective for people to ponder on this film and can serve as a reminder of the racism existing in modern world. Key words:District 9; Apartheid; stereotype; identity; anti-racism vi Acknowledgements First and foremost, I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude to my supervisor, Professor Li Xiaoqing, both for her intellectual guidance and for her warm and constant encouragement during the process of writing this thesis. With patience and prudence, she labored through drafts of this thesis and pointed out defects in my theorizing. Therefore, I owe all the merits in this thesis, if any, to her, though I am fully aware that the thesis might still contain some mistakes, for which I bear the whole responsibility. My cordial and sincere thanks go to Professor Zhao Chun, whose interesting and informative lectures on identity and stereotype analysis lead me to a challenging yet fascinating domain of academic research. The profit that I gained from his profound knowledge, remarkable expertise and intellectual ingenuity will be of everlasting significance to my future research. I am also deeply indebted to Professor Tao Xi, who kindly prepared me with the knowledge of media analysis and Professor Yan Qigang whose innovative perspectives greatly assisted me in conceptualizing the present thesis. I am also very grateful to Professor Duan Junhui, teaching the thesis writing format, whose careful and microscopic scrutiny of the manuscript resulted in the elimination of many inconsistencies. Last but not the least, big thanks go to my family who have shared with me my worries, frustrations, and hopefully my ultimate happiness in eventually finishing this thesis. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction .................................................................................................................. 1 Chapter OneThe Prototype of District 9 .................................................................... 4 1.1 The Similarities between District 9 and South Africa Apartheid ........................ 5 1.1.1 The Segregation Rule .............................................................................................. 5 1.1.2 The Racial Discrimination ....................................................................................... 7 1.1.3 Eviction Activity .................................................................................................... 10 1.2 The Implications of Similarities ............................................................................... 13 Chapter Two The Conflict between Humans and Aliens ............................................. 17 2.1 The Superior Humans ................................................................................................. 17 2.2 The Stereotyped Aliens ............................................................................................... 21 2.2.1 Racism and Stereotype .......................................................................................... 22 2.2.2 The Image ofOthers ............................................................................................... 23 2.2.3 The Stereotypes of Aliens ...................................................................................... 27 2.3 A Satire: The Failure of Human ................................................................................ 32 Chapter Three The Transformation of Wikus An Alien ...................................... 35 3.1 Being self: Human Superiority ................................................................................. 37 3.2 Being Self and Other: Identity Struggle .................................................................. 44 3.2.1 Identity: Body and Mind ........................................................................................ 45 3.2.2 The Reaction of the IdentityShift: Human\'s Greed and Cruelty ............................ 47 3.2.3 The Inner Struggle of Being Human ...................................................................... 51 3.3 Being other: the Shift of Identity .............................................................................. 54 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 57 Works Cited ............................................................................................................................... 59 1 Introduction Since the release of District 9, a science film of documentary style directed by Neill Blomkamp, it has arisen a heated debate and attracted much attention from all circles. It depicts a story of a MNU (Multi-national United) director who is deployed to evict these aliens living in District 9 who were from outer space 20 years ago and presents the experience of transformation of this director from a human to a prawn (the name given by human to these aliens). This science film was nominated as the best movie in Oscar Award in 2010, which also presented a remarkable record for its global box office of 2000 billion dollars since the cost of the whole movies was just 30 million dollars. The media also gavea high praise for this film. For example, it scored 8.3 in the IMDB (Internet Movie Database), Rotten Tomatoes (the most popular website for movie review) gave the freshness of this film of 89%, even the Chicago Tribune, one of the most important newspaper in United States, praised District 9 with this sentence “Some movies pack such a terrific central idea, even their flaws can\'t stop the train. \'District 9\' is one of them.” (Phillips) All of these illustrate that this movie has successfully become one of the most heated science films, which undoubtedly arises the interest of many scholars both from China and abroad to deeply analyze it. In China, many scholars have conducted serious analysis on this movie. All of these researches in domestic circle mainly focus on two aspects. One of them centers on the analysis of the human nature presented in this movie, including the exploration of the comparison between the human nature and alien nature, such as this article named An Analysis of the Criticism on Human Nature in District 9 (48-9)by Gong Mingyang which exposes the nature of human: being selfish, greedy and cruel to Wikus who transforms a prawn from a human due to the value of his body for human to initiate aliens\' advanced weapon technology and compares the nature of human and aliens through the transformation of Wikus. The second aspect 2 of domestic researches focuses on the analysis of the identity issue presented in this movie, exploring the meaning of identity shift of the main actor Wikus during the transformation from a human a prawn. The most prominent one for this aspect is the article called The Eternal Identity Dilemma---Comments on District Nine(150-153) written by Huang Qiongyao. This article mainly explores the nature of group identity and personal identity, promoting that the dilemma of these identity comes from racial segregation. Basically all these researches center on the analysis of the characters themselves and the comparison between the human and aliens in District 9. Besides that, many researches from abroad have also been conducted on this movie. And most of them try to make a comparative analysis with other science films such as Avatar and Huger Game, or the foreign researchers just cite District 9 as a small example to illustrate the main statement in papers, such as the article named The passing films and The illusion of racial inequality(Karen 21-43) which tries to illustrate that the passing narratives in films made an empty gesture toward racial equality since they encourage those at the bottom stay in their place. Of course there are other articles about the District 9, such as The Hysterics in District 9(Kapstein 155-175) which mainly discusses the relationship between the apartheid in South Africa and the visions presented in this film, and there is another important article called the District 9, race and neo-liberalism in Post-Apartheid Johannesburg (Wagner 43-59)which states that there is a close connection between the plots and the post-apartheid period in South Africa. Throughout the general review on the researches on District 9 from both home and abroad, there are mainly three categories. The first one is trying to explore the human nature and the difference between human and aliens, mostly from the domestic researches. The second category centers on the comparison study among District 9 and other prominent science films. The third category lies in the pure study of this single film from the perspective of studying the relationship between District 3 9 and the apartheid in South Africa. Based on the data collected, there is no single article trying to analyze this film from the perspective of racism. Thus, this article will try to analyze and explore the racism presented in this film and draws the conclusion the District 9 is explicitly embedded with the ideology of anti-racism. This paper will be divided three chapters. In the first chapter, the author tires to reveal the connection between the film and the Apartheid in history. Through analyzing the similarities, such as the same segregation rule and the eviction activity, the author draws the conclusion that Apartheid is the prototype for District 9. Based on this finding, the author then tries to uncover the director\'s intention of the ion of the similarities: the expression of the theme of anti-racism. In the second chapter, the author mainly focuses on the conflict between the human and the aliens. The main conflict relies on the superior human and the stereotyped aliens. According to some racism and stereotypes theories, it can be easily drawn that human purport themselves as superior and try to maintain their status by conducting many activities on other inferior species, such as the economic deprivation in the film. Besides that, the author tries to analyze the stereotypes human hold on these aliens and also illustrates the reason for it. By analyzing the conflict between human and the aliens, the authors tries to reveal that human are superior. However, the ending in the film for the human\'s failure to evict these aliens is a satire for the human\'s racism, which contributes to the construction of the theme of anti-racism. In the third chapter, the author tries to center on the main actor Wikus and to reflect the director\'s theme of anti-racism by analyzing the transformation of Wikus. By comparing the different status of Wikus in different transformation stages: before, between and after it, the author tries to focus on the identity shift and explains why and the reactions both from the human and himself based on some identity theories. By making contrast, the previously superior human Wikus is saved by aliens, which serves as a satire for him who hold stereotypes on these aliens, contributing to the presentation of anti-racism in the film 4 Chapter One The Prototype of District 9 District 9, with its magnificent scenes and documentary style, has undoubtedly captured the world attention since its release. Besides that, the plot of the eviction of the aliens and the background setting on the Johannesburg in South Africa about the slums also arise a large amount of debating, making people associate it with the Apartheid happened in South Africa from 1948 to 1994 for there is a close connection between them in many factors. Apartheid,was a racial segregation rule enforced in South Africa through making it a law by the National Party (NP), which was the governing party from 1948 to 1994. The Legislation classified inhabitants four racial groups – \"black\", \"white\", \"coloured\", and \"Indian\", and the last two of them were divided several sub-classifications (Baldwin-Ragaven, Lesley, and Jeanelle18)– and the residential areas were segregated. Under this legislation, the majority of black inhabitants and other ethnic groups were limited in the rights, associations, and movements, and white minority rule was maintained as the African National Congress (ANC) stated in 1987 that Apartheid was nothing other than \"white minority domination through exclusive concentration of political power on the side of the white minority.\"(Wrobel 68) Apartheid not only meant the segregated labor, the segregated residential areas, but also some repulsive features such as separate park benches, the ban on multi-racial sports and theatrical performances, which resulted to the inferior status of other ethnic groups. In this film, District 9, it depicts the task of evicting the aliens who came to the earth from outer space by accident from the slums near the city Johannesburg in South Africa. There are many factors that are similar between the Apartheid and District 9, such as the tackling with the different species, the ideology underline this eviction task and so on. So, the conclusion can be drawn as this : the setting and the plot in District 9 is based on the Apartheid happened in South African history, in 5 other words, Apartheid in South Africa is the prototype for this film. Thus, in this chapter, the author tries to analyze the connection between the Apartheid and District 9 from two aspects. First, the author will analyze the similarities between them, such as the rule implemented on the different species, the racial discrimination presented, and the creation of the environment. Secondly, the author tries to uncover the intention for choosing these similarities presented in this film. By analyzing it, the conclusion that the director tries to express his anti-racism theme through the ion of the similar plot and settings can be drawn. 1.1 The Similarities between District 9 and South Africa Apartheid The conclusion that the Apartheid happened during 1948 to 1994 is the prototype of the film District 9 is based on the similarities or the connections between them. After analyzing the film and going through the history of the Apartheid, we can conclude many major similarities such as the same segregation rule implemented on the different species, the same racial discrimination these special groups are facing and the same poor living conditions they are in. 1.1.1 The Segregation Rule Since 1948 when Apartheid was enforced, the difference between the apartheid system and other systems such as the legal system was that it was not constructed with a unique set of ideas and practices that were strongly propagandized by the heads of Afrikaner nationalists who made every effort to maintainthe minor whites superiority over other groups. Instead, \"it was built upon the segregation order which had developed along with the accelerated industrialization of South Africa following the discovery of diamonds and gold.\"(Giliomee and Schlemmer 1).The form of modern segregation in South Africa first appeared by the end of the nineteenth century during which the South Africa\'s industrialization process, particularly in the sectors of mining and farming, was accelerated to meet the demands of the capitalist 6 system. The serious labor shortage associated with the thriving of mining and farming sectors and the fear that white supremacy would be fatally undermined by rapid industrial transformation and urbanizationresulted to the attempts to regulate labor effectively and strengthen the white domination. It was in Kimberley which owned many mines that the segregation was elaborated a more substantial system for the first time in purpose of preventing diamond smuggling and ensuring a constant supply of migrant labor by establishing separate compounds for single African men. Besides that, the control of black labor is one aspect. The attempts to enforce the segregation came from the white people\'s desire to construct towns and cities which were pictured as orderly white island in Africa, uncorrupted by the “Lower”civilization and “Unhygienic” standards of blacks. (Giliomee and Schlemmer 10).The desire to separate Africans in compounds or locations became the real driving force for many activities of the authorities. As the Prime Minister of Cape Colony, W.P. Schreniner described: \"What we wanted was to get them practically in the position of being compounded ...... Keep the natives out of harm’s way, let them do their work, receive their wages, and at the end of their term of service let them go back to the place whence they came--- to the native territories, where they should really make their home.\" (Swanson400) By 1948, the colored people had become marginalized and poorly integrated the political system. Despite the fact that they had the vote, the United Party wouldn’t allow the colored people any special role within the party, which led to the disappearance of the voice for the colored people.Even though the United Party refused the idea to forcibly segregate the colored community in society, they preferred the idea of residential segregation which,from their opinion, could be achieved through voluntary segregation that will not causeanyantipathy or a sense of 7 grievance from the colored people. Since then the colored population lived in depressed conditions: in the white areas, colored people had access to few facilities, such as they were not served in restaurants or Cafes. With the implementation of many important acts, Africans or colored people were placed a fundamentally inferior position to an important extent. So, in a word, in order to maintain the white supremacy, which is also called the maintenance of a pure white race, and erase the threat posed by the colored people in politics and economy, white people implemented the segregation rule to place colored people areas separated from the white residential areas and provide limited access to white facilities for colored people, as D.F.Malan proposed in his final statement:The NP guaranteed the character of each racial group and that all groups would obtain the opportunity “to develop in their own areas self-sufficient ethnic units.” (Giliomee and Schlemmer 35). In this film, there is also a clear division between human and the aliens who came to the earth by accident. At the beginning of the film, it depicts a giant space ship which hung over the city of Johannesburg without no reason just as the dialogue in this film illustrates \"(00:01:41,643 --> 00:01:45,549The doors didn\'t open for 3 months. It just hovered there. Nobody could get in.\") In the purpose of knowing what is hidden inside the ship, human break it forcibly. To their surprise, there are millions of creatures that are different from human in appearance and language. Due to some reason, they just isolate these aliens just for self-protection and the interest of human. In a word, the similarity between the segregation rule happened in South Africa and the isolation in this film illustrates there is a connection between them. 1.1.2 The Racial Discrimination Apartheid, which happened in South Africa, is a great representation of racial discrimination. As the author mentioned before, Apartheid was implemented under the circumstances of protecting the white supremacy and maintaining the inferior status of colored people, leading to the appearance of segregation rule, just as 8 Frederick Johnston stated categorically that “true rationale of Apartheid is to maximize economic development both for the sake of white prosperity and for the material protection of white supremacy” (Frederick 358). In South African History, Apartheid and white material privilege coincided with which can be called the “white nationalism” in which apartheid endowed each of these racial groups with a sense of nationhood separately and made it a task to maintain this identity in separate groups or homelands from the perspective of politics (Giliomee and SchlemmerIntroduction V)leading to the suppression of other colored people living in South Africa and the establishment of a system of divide-and-rule which cultivated and strengthened white domination. The racial discrimination happened in many aspects, not only the segregated labor order, all-white Parliament but also the most obvious and repulsive features of Apartheid--- such as separate park benches and the ban on multi-racial sport and theatrical performances. In South African history, white supremacy or racial discrimination has long existed from the late-eighteenth century during which the black labor force was under white control and the majority of workers for strategic positions were white people whose number also ran high in political, economic and administrative systems of the country and so on. By the 1870s, whites people had long been used to conducting dominance and privilege over colored people to excluding the blacks from the state or church and some residential areas, as whites wanted blacks apart in order to keep them \"under and inferior.\" (Giliomee and Schlemmer4)Since the enforcement of Apartheid, concerning about political rights, by 1948, the colored people had no place in political system. With the rare opportunity of attending the election, colored people were too weak to speak for themselves and become independent, which served as a veracious circle. As a result, by the time of the 1948, the total colored vote had dropped, which was less than the figure in 1946. Not only that, colored people also suffered from residential segregation, which resulted to the depressed living conditions for the colored people, the prejudiced education and civil 9 service. In the civil service, colored people were often hired as unskillful laborers at a lower wage levels compared with the white workers. Besides, due to the educational discrimination that colored people could not receive appropriate education since the standard was set so high that colored people with secondary education couldn\'t meet, the number of skilled colored people were decreasing dramatically. So, all these illustrate that apartheid reasserted the racial division and racial discrimination. In this film District 9, there are also many racial discrimination presented. First, these aliens discovered by human in that giant ship hovering over the city of Johannesburg through brutal force are placed in the slam area existing in a special area which is under poor sanitation and safety conditions. They live in the small flat houses, which are surrounded by garages and wastes from which these aliens findtheir food. The picture below shows the place where aliens are situated. . ( The District 9 where aliens are placed in this film) Secondly, these aliens are brutally treated with the rule of population control just as what human did to different races. Human are quite enjoying the process of devastating the aliens’ little eggs who are under the condition of getting nutrition from the pipes built by aliens. (00:16:17,964 -->00:16:36,025Very little of it left, of course,because all these pipes; supply the nutrition to the little prawn eggs.There we go. Okay,no more nutrition to the guy. Then finally we take air back. The little guy is gone to a nice little sleep now.)Human are quite obsessed in this eliminating mission as is shown is the picture, the man are quite happy about the killing in front of the camera. 10 ( Reporting the burning of aliens\' eggs in front of the camera and showing his excited mood)) Thirdly, in order to obtain the control of the advanced technology brought by aliens, human decided to do experiment with these aliens in purpose of researching weapons technology so that human can take control of these advanced machines. These aliens are forcibly brought the lab where human scientists study the separate parts of aliens, and use the aliens as the target for testing these weapons made in accordance with the aliens weapons. All these demonstrates the racial discrimination displayed by human to the unexpected aliens. There are also other forms of racial discrimination, the author will explore that deeply in the later chapters. 1.1.3 Eviction Activity During the Apartheid period, colored people were evicted to the certain areas where there was insufficient supply of education, community facilities and so on compared with the areas where white people in South Africa resided in. Actually, there are two similarities concerning about the eviction activity. The first one is the forced removals itself that happened both in Apartheid in South Africa and also the film District 9. The second one is the similarity between the living environment for the colored people in the separate areas during the Apartheid and the condition under which aliens are living in.Under the segregation rule, white people succeeded in building many towns and cities as orderly white islands in Africa, which were free from the lower civilization and unhygienic standards of blacks. First, the eviction activity in District 9 to remove these aliens in Johannesburg to a so called much safer and comfortable place for the aliens to live in surprisingly resembles what happened during the Apartheid in South Africa. (00:06:18,387 -->00:06:32,448from their present home in District 9to a safer and better location, 11 200 kilometers outside ofJohannesburg City.We built a nice new facilitywhere the prawn can go, he can be comfortable,he can stay there...)According to the statistics, during the 1960s, 1970s and early 1980s, through the enforcement of a resettlement policy from the governmentwhich intended to force people to move to their previously designated group areas, theyconducted forcedremovals to make millions of people to relocate. Many people relocated through the forced removals under the guidance of slum clearance programs, such as labor tenants on farms owned by whites, the inhabitants of the so-called \"black spots\"referring to black-owned land which was surrounded by white farms), the families of workers who lived in townships close to the homelands, and \"surplus people\" from urban areas which included thousands of people from the Western Cape (which was declared a \"ColouredLabour Preference Area\") who were moved to the Transkei and Ciskei homelands (Western711-16). What resembles the eviction activity most in District 9 was themost popular forced removals of the 1950s occurring inJohannesburg, a place where the eviction activity happened coincidentally in District 9, when 60,000 people were moved to the new township Soweto which was abbreviated for South Western Townships. (South Africa History Online) Despite the protest from the African Native Commission, the government still enforced the removal of Sophiatown on 9 February 1955 under the guidance of Western Areas Removal Scheme. These people were forced to leave their house by the heavily armed police with the government loading their belongings trucks. Just as planned, the government evicted them to a remote place from the city center, which was known asMeadowlands. This sort of forced removals continued to happen in the next few years and spread to other colored people too. Besides that, areas like Cato Manor (Mkhumbane) in Durban were also implemented with forced removals, leading tothousands of colored, Indian and Chinese people leaving their homeland to the Cape Flats forcibly. About 40,000 whites were also forced to move at the time when the \"white South Africa\" land was transferred the black homelands. (Pirie 12 172-81)Apart from the similarity in conducting the eviction activity between the Apartheid and District 9, the reason for the eviction is surprisingly similar. In District 9, residents living in Johannesburg cannot tolerate aliens living in their township,as the play script shows:(00:04:29,801 -->00:04:52Residents in Tembisariotedfor the third consecutive night, in an attempt to removeall the aliens from their township.A virus, a ive virus.Release it near the aliens. They must just go.I don\'t know where, just go). (Parade to require the removal of aliens) They believe that these aliens are violent and unhygienic, threatening their safety and sanitation levels by attacking humans and releasing virus. Similarly, this is also what happened in history in Apartheid. In Johannesburg, after hours of discovering that bubonic plague existed in African slums, these placeswere burned down, resulting to Africans move to a separate location at Klipspruit. (Giliomee and Schlemmer 10)So, judging from the eviction activity itself and the reason for intriguing this, the removal happened in Johannesburg in District 9 resembles the historical event occurring during the Apartheid in South Africa, Secondly, there is also a similarity between the living environment for those who were going to be evicted both in District 9 and also in the history of Apartheid. In District9, aliens are placed in the slums area near Johannesburg, with the lower-sanitation level and insufficient of food, resulting to the fact that these aliens can only feed themselves with the leftovers they search in the garages, which is why they are called prawns. (00:05:02,505 --> 00:05:09,936 The derogatory term Prawn is usedfor the alien, and obviously it implies. Something that is a bottom feeder,that scavenges the leftovers.) They don’t have enough food to eat, which forces them to 13 steal and take from the human beings. Besides that, the whole environment is under poor-condition: things and wastes are scattered around, without enough water supply and so on. All they can do is to search for what can be eaten. The colored people living in the separate places from the white people confronted the same situation during the Apartheid in South Africa. Until 1995, with the growth of industry in Johannesburg, Sophiatown, which had been one of the few urban areas in which blacks were allowed to own land, was slowly developing multiracial slums. Due to its convenience and closeness to the town,it became the home of black workforce which expanded rapidly. But the facility and resources were scarce. In the “white” areas, colored people had access to few facilities, for example, the only swimming pool for black children existed in Johannesburg in these areas. (Meredith95)Colored people were placed in the slums. They were not served in restaurants or cafes(except with take-away) and the only places welcoming the colored people were crowded, segregated canteens of the hotels. There was little contact between the colored people and the white peer group. Thus, in a word, the eviction activity and the environment where aliens are living in the film District 9 actually resemble the removal event occurring in Johannesburg and the living situation where colored people confronted during the Apartheid in South Africa. In this sense, the conclusion that there is a close connection between District 9 and the Apartheid can be drawn. 1.2 The Implications of Similarities Just as the Apartheid in history which receives a lot of criticism, in this film District 9, there is also always a different sound about the eviction mission and also the treatment for the main actor Wikus. Judging from many factors in the film, such as the beginning background music which is a typical African song, the location where these aliens live and so on, we can easily draw the conclusion that this film is 14 basically a reflection of the Apartheid happening in history. So, these similarities between the Apartheid and this film don\'t happen in coincidence, instead, it has its own purposes to serve for the presentation of the theme of the anti-racism of the director by presenting the similar scenes happened in history. All these similarities will make people to consider about the film from a historical perspective and based on that, the director reaches the purpose of spreading the theme of anti-racism in District 9 through many aspects. As we all know, even though people\'s mind and ideas are controlled by ideologies which are presented through discourse and power relations(which will be clearly explained in the later chapter), there is always somebody who presents different ideas, such as the criticism provoked by many critics in the Apartheid period in which they condemned the inhuman treatment as implementing separation rules to those Africans who are labeled with some inferior meanings just because their body difference. However, even though there is a fair and unbiased opinion on this Apartheid, it is too weak to overturn the mainstream ideology held by the majority of people. The same thing happens in the District 9. There is always a different opinion about the eviction activity implemented by human on these aliens and also on the treatment on the main actor Wikus when he presents the signs for transformation to the alien\'s body. First, the different opinion presented when the MNU decides to launch the eviction mission appears just as the dialogue in the film (00:08:01,590 -->00:08:07, I\'m not saying what he did was right, but.... he took the choices that were given to him.)which happens when the Wikus is assigned as the leader of the eviction activity and decides to deal with it successfully while the majority people (showing his different opinions about the mission of evicting the aliens) 15 are eager to put these aliens out of Johannesburg. So, this illustrates that people have the different opinion and indicates that this eviction may cause some bad results. (00:08:16,065 -->00:08:22,438 I just want everyone watching this right now to learn from what has happened. -You would think...) However, the opinion of some common people shows that they just want to escape from the responsibility claiming that this mission will not be assigned to him and have a careless attitude toward it. (00:08:22,726 --> 00:08:26,217 things like this would happen to somebody else, not to me.)This shows that even though some people have different opinion, they are not daring to declare it in public and choose to remain silent about what they don\'t agree, which is the measure that most opponents would take. And it is this keeping silent that makes this tragedy happen and it also presents the weakness of the sound of the opponents, which is also presents the director\'s satire. The second different opinion happens when Wikus is misrepresented on the media as the extremely dangerous man and is treated like an alien. Some people consider that they can help him but they just don\'t know how. (00:51:22,454 -->00:51:52,692If we knew where he was, we would try and help him, and that is the most difficult part, not knowing where he is. He was an honest man, and he didn\'t deserve any of what happened to him.)All these presents that people have the intention to help him but they are just powerless which resembles the reaction when people were faced with the Apartheid activity in history. In a word, the phenomenon that different opinions presented when aliens are tortured and the main actor is mistreated also happened in the Apartheid history, which can be regarded as a reflection of the history. However, even though there is a different sound, people are too weak and too intimidate to speak it out and put it practice. All these are regarded as a satire for the director. Besides that, there is also a satire in the ending scene when the aircraft finally launches. With the help of Wikus, the elite aliens finally get the fluid and start the craft. The whole city is stunned as is shown in the script.(00:50:10,653 -->00:50:16,509 and people are tremendously excited. The city had come to an 16 absolute standstill.)It seems that it is an acclamation for the final dispensation of the interruption of the aliens in their life. However, it may be regarded as an applause for the final freedom that these inferior and stereotyped aliens have finally achieved freedom and gain autonomy for the director. Judging from this, the anti-racism theme can be partly shown. 17 Chapter Two The Conflict between Humans and Aliens In this film District 9 which depicts the eviction process of aliens living on earth from the outer space, the main reason that triggers this mission is actually the conflict between the human and the aliens. For human, there is always a sense of superiority over the aliens, which urges human to eliminate the inferior one and want to steal what the aliens have such as the advanced weapon technology. In the racism theory, racism, in most instances, according to Atkin, it refers to “the assumption of racism with relations of superiority and inferiority existing between them, such that the presumed superior group is able to dominate and exercise power over the dominated group to the detriment and disadvantage of members of that members of group.”(116) That is to say, there is always a race claiming they are superior, and depreciating other races as inferior, under which there are two major reasons, the first one is the economic depravity and the second one is the maintenance of the superior social status. In this film, the human are always depicted as the superior one who possesses the power to evict the other race, claiming they are for the benefit of the human. In fact, what is covered under this is the desire to demolish the one that is different from what they are, and the desire to keep their existing status. So, in this chapter, the author will analyze the conflict between the human and the aliens: the purported superior human and the depreciated aliens, based on some racism theories and further draw the conclusion that the theme of District 9 is anti-racism. 2.1 The Superior Humans In the theory of racism, racism is the exercising of power and dominance by one 18 racial group over another racial group, frequently and consistently leadingto the disadvantages of the dominated group and in favor of the dominating group. “Racism is generated primarily at the social and economic levels.” (Anthony4)And the sense of superiority entitles the superior people to conduct economic depravity and to maintain the existing social status as Wellman argues that “both economic and status interests can be defended through racism.” (Wellman 221)These two aspects are both represented in the film District 9. In history, when many sociological and political opinions concern about racism, they tended to study the development of the false beliefs held about different races by making use of historical materials, in the purpose of claiming the purported rational interests through making connection with their invention, the sources they have found and their own opinion over individuals and communities. In a broader sense of such an account, \"racism becomes little more than a convenient excuse for the pursuit of economic gain\". (Wellman 24-5)Thus, in a sense, the human’s superiority is presented in the economic depravity. In this film, there is an economic depravity existing in District 9, except being forced to live in the slams outside Johannesburg with poor conditions, such as the shabby house, dirty environment scattered by flying domestic rubbish and abandoned industrial waste. . (An alien searching for food from the rubbish) Just as shown in the picture, the aliens have to search food for surviving from the piled rubbish with their dirty hands. Although these aliens are depicted as aimless 19 and no initiative, (20800:14:24, 927 --> 00:14:30,013 They will take commands,they have no initiative.They\'ve lost all theapt of leadership) human still conducted the economic depravity on the aliens, snatching the alien weapon technology as their own and squeeze whatever they have under the mercy of just scrambling along in this world. One of the economic depravity resides on stealing the advanced weapon machinery and conduct experiments of the effectiveness of these weapons with living aliens. (A researcher is adjusting the weapon to shoot on living prawn as an experiment) In fact,the organization MNU which is entitled with the mission to evict the aliens out of Johannesburg accept this mission for another reason: the desire to master the latest technology of the weapon as it is the second biggest company for the production of weapons in the world. Just as the script shows (00:17:46,369 -->00:17:59, 117 MNU is trying to move the aliensfor humanitarian reasons.But the real focus,just as it has been, right from the beginning,is weapons. MNU is the second largestweapons manufacturer in the world.) These troops sent by the MNU are given the task of collecting the weapons in District 9 which are originally held by the aliens from the ship. Besides that, in order to analyze the weapon in a more well-organized way and claim the ownership of it, human even categorize the weapon and give them the different name based on human language. (25900:17:29,266 -->00:17:35, 445You see this? Trent, look at this!There\'s weapons all over here. CK 5, 7572...) Apart from that, in order to get human master the advanced weapon technology and use them with human hands, scientists in MNU conduct some brutal experiments on aliens, using aliens as the target for testing the 20 effectiveness of them.Just as one of the officials claimed in the dialogue of the film. (26700:17:59,213 -->00:18:04,915We assumed that we\'d be ableto pick up the alien laser gun and just be able to shoot,but it didn\'t work like that.)Even though the result is not satisfying. Another economic depravity occurred in the squeeze of the only money that the aliens have by selling them the cat foods which are the one that these aliens are obsessed with compared with the leftovers they search in the piled rubbish, thus leading to the appearance of a powerful scam in the District 9, just as the dialogue in this film shows (00:14:52, 796 --> 00:14:57,626 The nigerians had various scams going.One of them was the cat food scam.) This scam is run by a nigerian man who takes a great use of the desire of the aliens for the cat food. This exclusive selling point in District 9 leads to the increase of the price of the cat food, and these people in the scam are forcing these aliens to pay while buying the cat food. Just as the dialogue shows (21400:14:57,915 -->00:15:05,69Where they sold cat food tothe aliens for exorbitant prices. You put the money here first.You don\'t get anything until you pay.) In a word, the economic depravity occurs due to the desire of gaining economic interests and the sense of being superior than other group members. This economic depravity concerns about two aspects in this film: the first is the depravity of the advanced weapon technology owned by the aliens and the second is the squeeze the last bit of the aliens by selling high-priced cat food which is the favorite for these outer space aliens. The superiority of human is not only reflected in the economic depravity, but also in the desire of keeping the higher or the current social status, in other words, the status interests mean an interest in social prestige in preserving or enhancing the sense of self and group esteem. Just as David T. Wellman pointed out in his writing: \"racial consciousness is still most fruitfully analyzed in relation to the organization 21 of advantage rather than the structure if personality. Thus, racism continues to be a defense of racial privilege, not a psychological abnormality or the product of psychological manipulation.” (24-5) In this film, the defense for the status interests is reflected in many ways. In order to maintain their current status, human try to evict them to the so-called comfortable zone. (00:27:20,899 -->00:27:26, 889You\'re going to another place. A nicenew city built especially for prawns. A special place! -And we are noteven going to charge you, okay?)But the real desire hidden behind it is the thought to eliminate the different groups so that the current status can be kept and maintained. In this current world before the accidental arrival of these aliens, human conceive themselves as the most powerful species who has control over everything existing in the world, including the nature. Human fosters a sense of superiority over other forms of life, making human consider them in a quite prestigious status. However, the arrival of aliens from outer space about which human has little knowledge makes human wary of their current status interests. They have a sense of being threatened. Thus, in order to maintain the prestigious status, the conducted many activities on these aliens in the purpose of presenting their current status which is different from the aliens. They can do what they want to do: to place these aliens in a shattered place full of rubbish, to leave these aliens being squeezed by the local scam, even to evict them out of where people live and do brutal experiments on them. 2.2 The Stereotyped Aliens Contrasted with the portrayal of superior human, the descriptions of aliens are stereotyped, which actually form a set of structural and fixed meaning on the aliens, attributing to the negative traits to the aliens who are different from human.Stereotype, a term in racial theories, was first drawn by Lippmann from the 22 printing press. For him, stereotype is an image, or text in a rigid form which is different from the real one due to its\' characteristics of lack of depth and details of the figure. But this image or the text can produce the likeness which is enough to capture the essence of it for an easy reproduction. So, stereotypes can be understood as vivid but simple representations, endowing persons with a set of exaggerated, usually negative characteristics. Thus, in order to explain why the aliens are stereotyped by human, this part the author will try to analyze how this stereotype is formed, what are these stereotypes over aliens and what is the motivation for it comes to mind. 2.2.1 Racism and Stereotype According to the racial theory, stereotype is often connected with racism, which can produce a superior status and inferior status between two different groups. Racism, in racial theory, is considered as a form of ideology which is directly implicated in the ongoing communication of self and other. As a form of continuous social production,ideology can make subjects to involve in and re-constitute themselves as subjects at the same time in relations of self and other. Just as Robert Miles wrote in his book Racismdefining ideologies as: \"the accumulated, taken for granted, and often contradictory set of assumptions and beliefs that are employed by people to impose an ideological structure upon the social world, within which they can then act.\"(70) So, stereotype is just one of them, leading to the fact that the meaning of being stereotyped is constructed through a form of ideology, which concerns not only the self but also the other who is different from the self. Just as Hall pointed out in his work, he argued that stereotypes concern about the abnormal things that were excluded from the normal order which can simultaneously distinguish from self and other, thus, stereotyping reduces, essentializes, naturalizes and fixes difference. (258)And the ideology of being stereotyped is achieved by representation. Representation is one of the principle concepts to understand ideology, which 23 refers to the concepts, images and associations that cohere some sort of symbolic framework which influences subjects’ relations with the world and the world of others. Representation, as one of the major terms in cultural studies, provides a way for how to evaluate or judge the world since human, cultural and social sciences are concerned with the production and consumption of meanings. It is a process that we apply science and codes to construct meanings, in other words, it is a signifying practice which produces meaning and makes things meaningful. People construct a symbolic structure to build a meaning in association with the images, concepts and so on. Just as Robert Miles mentioned in his book: \"the representational process by which meanings are attributed to particular objects, features and processes, in such a way that the latter are given special significance, and carry or are embodied with a set of additional, second-order features....It is the process of depicting the social world and social process, of creating a sense of how things ‘really are’”(70). So, in this sense, the representational process involves production, invention, ion and domination, which also, inevitably, becomes a site of contestation and domination, where a certain images and meanings come to the minds of subjects. In the process of stereotyping,stereotyping also points to the exercise of power and it also plays a role in excluding others from the social, symbolic and moral order. So, in this sense, we can see that stereotyping is the discourse of others who is in control and power over other inferior groups. 2.2.2 The Image of Others Based on the theory that stereotyping constitutes of the representations of certain things,the most implicit stereotype in this film is the analysis of the image of these aliens who are constructed as the creature prawn on earth. In this film, species different from human are constructed as a totally different 24 image which people are quite familiar with in which they are portrayed as similar as prawns living on earth. Just as the script shows(00:05:02,505 -->00:05:09,936The derogatory term Prawn is usedfor the alien, and obviously it impliessomething that is a bottom feeder,that scavenges the leftovers.) First, the name human give to these aliens is prawn which is a discriminated nickname. They call these aliens prawns not just because their appearances are familiar, but also because human wants to label an inferior tag on these aliens. Through representation, human can make a sense of these aliens. In this way, the way people call these aliens is actually a discourse made by the designated forms of representation, conventions and habits of language produces located meanings in the specific fields of history and culture. (Brooker78)According to the racial theory, racism involves the exercise of power over other groups. Michel Foucault, a famous French philosopher, believes that it is not the repression, inhibition or mere domination that power is associated with, instead, he believes it is connected with the institutionalized and accustomed discourse that restrict the forms of action, knowledge and being. In this way, the exercise of power constitutes as it simultaneously controls individual subjects. Since it is being institutionalized, institutionalized discourse has authority and legitimacy by definition. Andthe language of a specific discourse within a given system and society will therefore play an important role in constituting subjective and social identities. So, that is to say, by making certain discourse which is the means of implementing power over other inferior groups, human can make senses of other things. In this film, it is this discourse of calling these aliens prawns that makes human exercise power over them and make them in an inferior status. The second thing concerns about the depiction of the appearance of these aliens. Instead of portraying these aliens as some creatures that people have never seen before, the director tries to create these aliens as something similar to one creature living on earth called prawns. 25 (The depiction of the appearance of aliens) As is shown in this picture, there are many similarities between the prawns and these foreign aliens. First, the antenna is the same, stretching out to feel something. When these aliens talk with human, the antenna just shaking like prawns are feeding on something. The second thing is that these aliens have many shells on their hands and legs, which resembles the shell in prawn. And another similarity happens in the shape of their hands and legs since real spawns are anthropoids. Last but not least, real pawns and aliens are both feeding on the scavenges and wastes. The real prawns usually live in a highly-contaminated environment, feeding on the soils and other dead small insects and drink the dirty water. All of these happen to these aliens living in District 9. Due to lack of good shelter and great infrastructure facilities, these aliens have to live in the harsh environment where there is no food and clean water. The only thing that these aliens can do is to search food in the wastes produced by human activity and live in shabby houses. So, these resemblances between these two creatures make human easily associate them together and therefore give the nickname of prawn to these aliens. Actually, it is not only the similarities between their appearances, but also the implications of the given name prawns that create the sense of discrimination. Prawn in real life is a kind of social animal which will immigrate together in a certain period. Besides that, they are considered as low intellectuals by human with no special ability presented and they are often aimless, just searching for something to eat and without any leader who arranges the whole work of hunting unlike the bees 26 which has different divisions of labor, making the whole hunting effective. They just live in this dirty environment and have no ability to change the situation, neither do they have the intellectual. They just eat for live until they die. Therefore,for human, prawns can\'t be comparable to human since it doesn’t possess the special abilities human have, such as leadership, arrangement, purposeful and so on. Humans rank the prawns the inferior status and actually exert discrimination on them. So, in this sense, people make some connotations by calling these aliens prawns,not only because they resemble the appearances of that of real prawns, but also because they have the same characteristics which make people discriminate them. Just as the film script shows: (00:14:18,715 -->00:14:32, 989 What we have stranded on Earth in this colony, is basically the workers that are unable to think for themselves. They will take commands, they have no initiative. They\'ve lost all the apt of leadership through whatever cause. We presume illness.) The name which is given to these aliens makes people associate these aliens with the set of characteristics of the real prawns. This name is actually an representation. Representation is a process that we apply science and codes to construct meanings, in other words, it is a signifying practice which produces meaning and makes things meaningful. For example, we call a mountain as GeLemountain because we want people to have a pleasant mood which can makes people associate with the music and dance when they climb the mountain. As a matter of fact, the mountain without a name doesn’t have any meaning for human, the action that we give a name to something is the process that we construct the meaning for this staff, which makes it easier for people to put the world their system of knowledge. The meaning is a human concept since human endow some certain kind of staff with some kinds of certain meaning. No human beings, no meanings. Just as Stuart Hall points out that 27 “things don’t mean. We construct meaning, using representational systems-concepts and signs.’’ (Hall25)So based on this, there is no relation of reflection, imitation or one-to one correspondence between signifying practices and the real world. Nevertheless, signs are the things to symbolize, present or reference concrete objects such as people and events in the so called real world, and abstract concepts which have no material form such as emotions, imagined and abstract ideas(Hall28). Thus, based on the theory proposed by Stuart Hall, the name prawn given to the real creature is just a sign that helps people to better understand the world. After learning the set sign, people who are reminded of the word prawns will connect it with a real picture of this creature and also the characteristics associated with them.So people giving the nickname prawns to these aliens will naturally make people associate these inferior characteristics the real prawns have which are set by human through signs. In a word, the depiction of these aliens as prawns occurs not only because these two creatures are quite similar in appearances, but also because the connotations associated with the name, the inferior and discriminated status. By giving the setimpressions about prawns produced by human, these aliens are discriminated and stereotyped. 2.2.3 The Stereotypes of Aliens Stereotype, just as the author mentioned above, is actually the set opinions and impressions on a certain group due to the discrimination of one superior group. Thus, stereotypes are, according to Stangor and Lange, in modern psychological terms, mental representations which contain enough details on social groups and their members, making people to know what group members are like without ever meeting them. (4)So, that is to say, just like the mental representation people have on many things, such as plants, animals and so on, these representations contain attributes and traits which are often contributed to a certain group and members. So, in this film, there are many such representations called stereotypes, leading to the biased opinion 28 on these aliens and providing a reason to justify their discrimination on them, leading to the “cultural racism which occurs when those in positions of power define norms, values and standards in a particular culture.” (Augoustinosand Reynolds4) The first stereotype that people have on these aliens is that they are villains and killers who are brutal. Just as the script shows: (00:04:59,237-->00:05:33, 345The aliens, prawns,they take my wife away. The aliens made off with an undisclosedamount of cash. One bystander was hurt.They can take the sneakersyou are wearing off you.) They don’t know what is advocated and valued and what is prohibited and abandoned. (00:05:33,442 --> 00:05:36, 801 They take whatever you have on you.Your cell phone or anything.) They just behave like what they used to do in their planet. All these rules and the regulations to decide what is a crime and what is the behavior forbidden are set by human just for the convenience of living in a world that is under control. Since human live in a world in which rules and regulations have already been set, they have to obey these rules in other words, they have to adapt this system in order to survive.(00:09:27,804 --> 00:09:31,068 There are rules, we\'re all livingby rules in this world.)These rules and regulations such as the definition for crime and the punishment are partly created by ideological state apparatus which is promoted by French Marxist philosopher Louis Althusser in his important essay\"Lenin and Philosophy\". In his essay, he proposed that there are two kinds of state apparatus, one is the repressive state apparatus, such as the penal system, police and army, which is coercive in its cooperation through using these powers, the second one is the ideological state apparatus including religion, the legal system, education, family and so on, which is used to unify society through ideology and reproduce a regime through consent. The ideological state apparatus are functioning to ratify and legitimize the society. (Brooker 132).So, based on this theory, we can see that human presented in this film are suited in these legal system which enables them to distinguish what is right and what is wrong,(00:05:19,225 -->00:05:28,929 What for an alien might be seenas something recreational,setting 29 fire to a truck,derailing a train, is for us obviouslyan extremely destructive act.)and the reason that human cannot tolerate the behaviors of these aliens such as taking whatever they want without human’s consent lies on this state apparatus. Human are converted the legal system and the rules and regulation, knowing that stealing things are wrong. However, these aliens as are presented in this film have not actually adapted the customs and also the rules set by people on the earth.But, since these aliens live on earth with human, they have to obey the rules and regulations here. If they don’t, human just impose their moral justice and ideals on the judgments of aliens, creating the stereotypes of these aliens: committing crime, stealing so on. The second stereotype is that they are dangerous in that they will attack people anytime. And these stereotypes have become pervasive among human, which means that everyone holds the same opinion on these aliens. Therefore, people in Johannesburg who are interviewed in this film all expresses their consistent opinion in these aliens: they are villains and killers and always commit a crime, these aliens are dangerous, we need to get them out of here as soon as possible. So actually, this kind of stereotype that these aliens are dangerous is formed without much effort, since people just hear from others. There is a scene that is quite satiric happening in thisfilm. (A woman is interviewed about her opinion about these aliens) A woman is talking about how they feel about the prawns while at the back a prawn who looks quite shabby is searching for the food for eating in the rubbish at the back of the woman. So, from the perspective of the camera, we can see what is actually happening behind the woman.This prawn, instead of attacking the woman 30 just like the stereotype these people hold on them, is so busy in searching his food rather than seize the opportunity to attack human just as what is described by human on them. So, why this kind of stereotype so pervasive among human since not everyone experiences the bad moment of being killed by prawns?The answer is that in social-cognitive approach, stereotypes are seen as relatively mundane inhabitants of our mental world. “Stereotypes, like other mental representations are shortcuts the mind uses to simplify and understand the social world.” (Augoustinos and Reynolds4)So, stereotypes can serve as an instrument to facilitate the process of understanding the world around people. According to the experiment made by Macrae et al (Macrae, Milne, and Bodenhausen 37-47), stereotypes are devices that save capacity since it can free us from the need to consider each information we receive about someone. Thus, that is to say, stereotypes allow people to form an impression of an individual without a lot of mental effort. There are many advantages in this mental process, such as people can have more energy to devote to more important things that demand our attention. Although people can benefit from saving in the information processing time and mental effort, “the price of these information processing advantages is bias in the judgment of individual category members’ (Trope133-149). Thus, it can simplify the cognitive mechanisms for the social perceivers but with prejudice. According to Hamilton and Sherman(Katz 125-154), people learn stereotypes every early. It is not hard for anyone to list one or two stereotypes people have in their society. Since these stereotypes have functional characteristics, they are known to everybody and frequently accessed and consented. This result of long learning process, according toDevine(1989) is that everybody, irrespective of their personal beliefs, will automatically activate stereotypes when they encounter with other group members or the symbolic representation of the group, no matter whether they are religious or not. That is to say, everybody, despite they have different beliefs, activates stereotypes when judging outgroups or outgroup members.(5-18) The main point proposed by Devine is that all individuals will 31 experience the automatic stereotypical activation process of informationassociated with this group. So, in this film, facing with those aliens who look totally different from human, people will automatically stereotype these outgroup members. That is the first reason why so many people are consistent with the opinion that these aliens are extremely dangerous since they don’t bother to experience and make a self -contact with them rather than follow the trend to save their mental effort based on the cognitive approach. Another thing that attributes to the popularly accepted stereotypes that prawns are dangerous is the representation of the media about these aliens. It can be easily identified that there are many scenes where people are being interviewed, giving their bad opinions or stereotypes on the screen of TV. (A man interviewed to express his opinion about aliens) These opinions are actually the representations of the real thing, and due to the special characteristics of media, people’s opinion can be easily altered or changed by the things presented by the media. People will be greatly influenced by these representations. Just as Hall pointed out in his book that there is a decoding and encoding model existing in the circuit of meaning through media. In the encoding process, the producers or the encoders will decode the message based on the current cultural framework in the form of the media, So, the media professionals are involved to determine how to encode the raw social event in discourse. As Halls mentions: \"reality exists outside language, but it is constantly mediated by and through 32 language: and what we can know and say has to be produced in and through discourse. Discursive knowledge is the product not of the transparent representation of the real in language but of the articulation of language on real relations and conditions.” (131) So, in fact, through the representations, media is a kind of tool to implement discursive power, which means that it favors something. And the text will be constructed by the leading dominance in the way in which the text is desired to be understood. So, in this sense, the media will guide people to understand the meanings that they want people to, leading to the fact that media dominates people’s understandings of the world since it can provide a way for people to learn the world through its representation. The way how the media represents the raw social event contributes to the way people think about it. So, in this film, it is not difficult to draw the conclusion that people interviewed on the TV are expressing the stereotypes about these aliens, which, through the power of media, will finally persuade people to believe so, that is also what the dominant power want human to believe. So, in this way, these stereotypes are widespread and finally accepted by all. The third stereotype human hold on these aliens is that they are stupid as the prawns living on the earth. Just as film scripts mention(00:14:18,715 -->00:14:32, 989 What we have strandedon Earth in this colony,is basically the workers that areunable to think for themselves.They will take commands,they have no initiative.They\'ve lost all theapt of leadership through whatever cause.We presume illness.)People just connect them with the prawns which are actually lower intelligent animal compared with other animal. This part of discrimination the author has already discussed in the previous chapter. 33 Based on the analysis on the human and these aliens in this chapter, it is easy to draw the conclusion that people are always in the superior status while these aliens flying from outer space are in the inferior status. Human treat these aliens with discrimination and stereotypes, leading to these aliens living in a miserable condition and the bare survival on the earth. This film circles on the eviction movement which means to move these aliens who are living in the District 9 near Johannesburg which is a slam in reality to another place which is purported as a safe, comfortable place. So, due to the different status of human and these aliens, it is not difficult to suppose the result of this eviction plan to be successful. However, at the end of this film, the eviction plan failed and two aliens successfully start the spacecraft hanging over the Johannesburg since its arrival and they go home leaving human alone and surprised. What a satire for the human\'s failure. (The aircraft is starting to launch) In this film, there are many forces involved in this eviction plan, including the air force and so on. The government assigned this eviction mission to MNU. So, to enforce this mass eviction,the government turned to MNU which devote everything they have to finish this task in the purpose of seeking advanced weapons owned by these aliens.(00:06:01,537 -->00:06:14,833Today we start a very complexand delicate operation.This is the largest operationthat MNU has ever undertaken, and we believe that it is goingto be undertaken successfully.) They employed the professional and prestigious police officers who are bold and powerful, helicopters and other advanced vehicles to implement this mission. They even have some 2.3 A Satire: The Failure of Human 34 delicate divisions such as the population control office to ensure that this mission can be successfully implemented. They are quite confident that they will fulfill this task without no difficulty. When they have a problem, such as they have trouble in controlling these resistant aliens, a special troop will suddenly appear to intimidate them and to threaten them. Everything seems under control. However, though humans are in the superior status both in the mental aspect and the military aspect, the mission finally failed at the end of the film. They didn’t successfully evict these aliens to the place where people planned for them, instead, these aliens continue to live here with one human is transformed a prawn living with them together. Besides that, two aliens managed to escape from the chase of the MNU forces and successfully manipulate the spacecraft and go home. These all controversies lead to the satire to the arrogance of human and expresses the theme of anti-racism of the director. 35 Chapter Three The Transformation of Wikus An Alien The most basic element for a film is the storyline which can catch people\'s attention and also make people to indulge themselves this film through the coherence and consistence of the logic presented in the storyline. Thus, as a film, an intriguing storyline is indispensable for not only attracting the audience but also for the illustration of the theme embedded in the film. Thus, District 9, as a science fiction film, can\'t be an exception. This film, whose box office reached millions, which proves its\' popularity among audiences, is conducted through the main line of the extraordinary experience of the main actor Wikus. Wikus, who is previously envied by his colleagues and friends for he will marry his very beautiful fianceewho is born in a very wealthy family of power and influence. With the help of his future father-in-law, he successfully takes on the position of the leader for the action of expelling these aliens out of Johannesburg, which makes him the jealous target of the people around him. As a common people, he owns the two things that most people have desired for their whole lives: power and beautiful wife, which makes him a popular person in MNU which is the company that is in charge of the expel action of the aliens in District 9. Like all other human, he stands on the same position of resisting these aliens and treating them cruelly because of the sense of superiority brought by being a human. However, the main actor doesn\'t live a happy life like the ending in some fairytales. An accident that Wikus is exposed to the fluid found in one of the alien\'s house unexpectedly happens in the eviction mission, which makes him infected, leading to the transformation from human to the appearance of the aliens gradually. During the transformation process, he experiences the betrayal of his family and the cruel treatment of the MNU since this company hopes to conduct researches onhis transforming hand which can start the foreign weapons since he is the first person who survives in the exposure of the fluid and presents the transformation process. (00:44:54,530 -->00:45:01,443He was the only human who 36 had ever...successfully been combined with alien genetics and remained alive.)During this period, he is faced with many dangers posed by his family, his colleagues and to a larger extent the whole human. He is excluded by the human since he presents an appearance that is different from human but similar to these aliens. Being indulged in despair, he struggles to come back to the human side but in vain. With the despair, he escapes to the area district 9 which is occupied by these aliens to search for the chance for survival. In his struggle to become a human again, he learns that his variation can be cured from one of the aliens only if the aliens can come back to his own planet to get the fluid which can be used as a treatment for this transformation. At last, he successfully helps the alien and his son to launch the aircraft and is moved by the love and emotions between aliens. However, he is left behind by them with the promise that they will come back in three years to save him. Finally, with the transformation process going on, he becomes one of these aliens totally and lives in District 9 forever. So, judging from the experience of the main actor Wikus, we can separate this main storyline three stages. The first one is when he is still human who expresses the superior status over these aliens. So, in this stage, Wikus identifies himself with the human, and presents the same ideological ideas over other races and within others\' discourse, he justifies his action since what people think about him has an effect on the formation of his internal identity.In the second stage, he experiences a process of transformation by being contaminated by the fluid of the aliens. During this stage, he experiences the betrayal of human and struggles to the human world but in vain. With the change of the appearance of body, there is also an identity shift, both from the inner world of the main actor but also in the outer world in which people will possess a different opinion on him. He struggles to identify with the human with many efforts such as keeping in contact with his best friends and his family, helping the aliens to launch the aircraft to get the cure for his transformation. In the third stage, he becomes an alien totally living in the area where aliens reside in. 37 So, these three stages concern about the identity problem. Thus, in this chapter, the author will illustrate it in three different stages to reveal the cruel result of the racial prejudice over the aliens through the transformation of a human the alien and the reaction of the human on this transformation to reveal that the racism is not true when people are placed in the inferior position, leading to the uncovering of the theme of anti-racism of the director. 3.1 Being self: Human Superiority This part will focus on the explanation of the first stage of Wikus: being human. Being self in this part refers to the being human. Wikus, as a human, possesses many characteristics and also the ideologies of held by common people who live in the same period as Wikus, such as the racial prejudice and stereotypes and so on, which concerns about the identity. Thus, in this part, based on some identity theories concerning about how the identity is constructed and the relating factors that influence the formation of identity, the author will analyze the how the identity as a human of the main actor Wikus is constructed (including the identification with the human to fight against the aliens and also the personal characteristics he possesses) and draw the conclusion that Wikus as a member of human, expresses the racial prejudice over other aliens just like other people. Wikus, as one member of human, possesses the same ideological ideas like other human because in order to live in the world, he must identify himself to the human so that he can enter the symbolic order of the world based on the Lacan\'s theory. It was in 1570 when the first use of the word\"identity\" was recorded, appearing as \"identities\", which means\"the quality or condition of being the same in substance, composition, nature, properties, or in particular qualities under consideration; absolute or essential sameness; oneness\"(Oxford English Dictionary). In the early theory of identity, people consider identity as a self-fashioning, agentive, internal 38 project of self, However, in the postmodern period, people concern identity as fluid, fragmentary, contingent and crucially constituted in discourse. In the psychoanalysis theories, Lacan intended to consider that the illusion of coherent and bounded identity is produced by the fluid and chaotic unconsciousnessduring the early infancy. And Lacan call this process \"Mirror Phase\"(1-7) in which the infant identifies itself with the image reflected in the mirror repeatedly and misrecognizes itself aswhole, unified and autonomous but simultaneously \"othered\" or aliened. And according to Lacan, before the stage of mirror phase, infants haven\'t form the sense of distinct identity and it is the fragmented body which makes infant lack the sense of unity and self which is separated with the outer world that promote this previous development. Thus, in order to overcome the sense of fragmentation brought by the body, the infant tends to identify itself with the external mirror image due to the inability of distinguishing itself as a separate entity. This process of misrecognition becomes the basis for all future identifications by the subjects of itself as autonomous and sovereign, once it has entered the symbolic order of language.Thus, the mirror phase is regarded as the starting point of the identification process and also the beginning of the formation of identity.so, in this way, human forms a basic idea of their image and can make a distinction between the human and other aliens. But they can\'t make a judgment about these differences. Then, the infant enters symbolic order(the language) in which language is fundamental in theorizing subjectivity and identity. It is the subjects\' lack of fullness and inability to control meaning that motivates language.Besides that, according to Althusser, in this model of interpellation, he thinks that the linguistic category of the speaking subject \" I\' who identifies with and speaks and acts according to the ideology in question. (121-73.)Thus, the subject is split because the subject who says \" I think\" is not the same as the subject who really considers, making it impossible for the subject to acquire the unity and the knowledge and truth about itself since the language destroys the authenticity of subjectivity. In this sense, the identity 39 categories are regarded as attempts to compensate the gap between the subjects who speak and the subjects who are spoken. Once people can speak a language, they have entered the symbolic order.In Foucault\'s \"discursive production of the subjects\", he believes that it is the dominant discourses which are controlled by social arrangements and practices that produce identities. Then, the main ideologies form in the society. As Taylor (36) points out\"One cannot be a self on one\'s own.\" Identity derives from the identification with others. According to Stuart Hall, identification originated in the recognition of the same and common beliefs and characteristics that are shared with other person or groups. (2)So, in order to enter the symbolic order of the society, they have to identify themselves with the mainstream ideologies that are popular at that time.Individual subjects who are eager to enter the real world have to internalize particular meanings and values that are existing before their birth and express their consent to them, and accept the identity offered to them by the institution, for example, that of a mother, a worker or citizen of a particular state. Besides that, this identification happens on the condition of the basic body structures. As Chris Weedon points out in his book, individuals who present different forms of subjectivity and identity are constructed within different discourses produced through power relations exclusion and inclusion, and this differenceis often reflected on visual signifiers of difference which has acquired particular meanings in racist societies. (13) Thus, different identities partly rely on the visual difference in which body plays an important role. (humans, despite their racial or ethnical peculiarities, they all have the same basic body structureand all share some common bodily experiences and functions, which fundamentally define us as being human)(Yu19-34)In this way, Wikus identifies himself with the human since they have the same appearances.And the meanings discursively attributed to bodies are never static but dynamic in which the meanings can change due to the regimes of power that control the discursive fields which define and shape both the materiality and meaning of bodies. Thus, the body human have is defined as normal, while 40 others are not. Thus, through the body identification, people can distinguish the differences between himself and aliens. So, for the Wikus, who is also the product of that time, embraces the ideology of racial prejudice that is prevalent at his time in order to enter the symbolic order.And he tries to be identical with the people around him. He also presents the human superiority over these aliens. The most impressive one is the slaughter of the eggs of the aliens. It can be seen that he is quite enjoying the killing process presented by his tone of pleasure and his action of showing off the dead eggs. In this film, there is a plot that Wikus makes an amazing finding that there is a nest for nurturing the aliens\' offspring. After showing how the mechanism of the nutrition system works, he cruelly pumps out the pipes that provide the nutrition like he is dealing a machine and presents the face of satisfaction. ( Wikus is pulling the nutrition pipe for the eggs of aliens cruelly) Even so, he tries to share the pleasure of killing these eggs with his colleagues to show that he is capable of being the leader since he has made some big achievements. (00:16:12,744 -->00:16:36,025 can just show you a little bit how it works. Basically, a cow is hung from the ceiling, you can see here. Very little of it left, of course, because all these pipes supply the nutritionto the little prawn eggs.You can do one, I can show you, want to see? -No, I\'m fine.There we go. Okay,no more nutrition to the guy. Then finally we take air back. The little guy is gone to a nice little sleep 41 now.) Another one is that he uses his intelligence like other humans since they believe they are smarter creature that the aliens to lure the prawns to sign on the eviction document and threatens the prawns by taking away his child.(00:13:28,529 -->00:13:49, 388 It is cat food.I just distract them. No it\'s not my house.I don\'t live here. Well, that\'s a pity because, you know, this... This is a nice cat food, you know. But of course, it\'s not your house.) So, Wikus, living in the time, has shared the same opinions with other humans and expresses the racial prejudice through the construction of identity. And in order to enter the symbolic order, he identifies himself with the dominant ideologies. In a word, through the process of identification, the conclusion that Wikus also possesses the superior status over these aliens through the racial practices presented by Wikus can be drawn. Macro level Except the formation of racial prejudice against these aliens like other humans, Wikus also constructs himself as an individual, that is to say, he builds some certain characteristics in the micro-conversational level. Subjects are undoubtedlystuck in and between the competition in ideological codes produced in society and influenced by unconscious processes, but it is not only determined by them because individuals are active, cogitating, feeling, meaning-making. They are placed within social processes which include some dominant discursive practices, subject positions, on the condition that they exist and operate within inter-subjective contexts. As Taylor points out in his work, individuals are continuously formed through conversation or imagined conversation with others, for example, I can be a self only when I have a relation with others, and a self exists only within what he calls webs of interlocution.(45)And this opinion is echoed by Williams who summarized Hegel\'s contribution as that human selves and their identities are constituted within the relationships, not the substances which exist prior to persons\' relationships with one another. (21)So, the individual is formed through the communication with others. 42 And the discourse from others can exert a great influence on people\'s formation of characteristics. In the narrative analysis and positioning theory, these theorists argue that we live in a \"story-telling society\"(Denzin Forword) through which we make sense of our lives and the events that happen in it. That is to say, people construct their selves through narrative telling since selves are made coherent and meaningful by the way of narrative or biographical work that they do or other people do to them. And selves and identities are therefore constituted in talk and in narratives. Just as Georgakopouloustates in his work\"Through storytelling, narrators can produce edited descriptions and evaluations of themselves and others, making identity aspects more salient at certain points in story than others.\"(413-32) Thus, selves are constructed through communication and interactions with the people around us. And due to the very nature of communicative act, people have the ability to reflect back upon their conditions of subjection, enabling them to present real and active interventions in social life. Thus, through communication with others, people can make a sense of what he is doing and can make an understanding of their own conditions of existence through communication. Besides, people can acquire the meaning of what other people think of us. Being identified by others as responsible or capable has consequences for the way one thinks about oneself, the goals set for oneself and the expectations one has. One\'s external identification thus affects and helps to construct an internal identity. In turn, the goals and expectations that individuals can exert corresponding feedbacks the designations. In thin film, Wikus, who is just a common stuff working in the MNU, is assigned to the important mission to evict 180 million of aliens out of the district 9. Basically speaking, he is not qualified to be the leader of this mission since he is incapable of dealing with the problem. He is weak, timid, and has no aspirations or ambitions for his career who is just like the majority of the people.(00:07:06,103 --> 00:07:09, 559Everybody always said that Wikus was not a very smart boy.) It is this common people who takes the burden to conduct the eviction task. There is many doubt about 43 this assignment. But Wikus gains the confidence and makes sense of this eviction task through the communication with others and the discourse of others. Many people claim that he is extraordinary in some aspects, such as his wife who praises that he is romantic and his mother praises he is obedient and his father-in-law claims that it is his ability not his special status that makes him to make this decision to promote him. (00:07:09,656 --> 00:07:28, 372 but he was a wonderful son. That was my Wikus, just... Wikus was always making me things.He said that way they just mean so much more. I had to put aside the fact that my daughter was married to Wikus. That didn\'t affect my decisionto promote him.)Through these opinions expressed by people who are most intimate to him, he can strengthen his confidence and in return it will affect his self-recognition since \"identity emerge out of a process in which individuals have to decide and assert who they are in negotiation with other identity0assigning agents such as their families and so on.\"(Rattansi 116)Besides that, many people express the message that taking this mission is quite proud for him and everybody around him are preparing for the eviction task and are under control, which makes him believe and persuades him that his action is worthy and he has the ability to handle this which is quite opposite to his ordinary characteristics, which is presented at the beginning of the film when Wikus makes a brief introduction of the eviction mission just like he is introducing some grand project with a proud and smile face, which shows that he is quite proud and excited to take on this job. (Wikus is making an introduction for his mission proudly and happily) (00:07:16,185 --> 00:07:19,833 Feels like life on the big stage. Thank you Piet... Mr 44 Smith. 00:07:28,756 --> 00:07:33,046 It\'s almost as big as my wedding day. You know... not as big.) And in order to prove that he is qualified to this job and meet the expectation of others on him,Wikus makes every effort to deal with this job devotedly by presenting his organizational skill and also showing off his achievements made through the mission. When the finding of a house full of weapons is made, he is to impatient to show off his findings to others to prove that he is the right person to take on the job and to meet the previous expectations of others: finishing the job successfully.All this illustrates that Wikus is largely affected by the discourse of others through the conversational act. 3.2 Being Self and Other: Identity Struggle In the second stage, Wikus experiences a transformation in his body after he is exposed to the foreign fluid accidentally when he tries to find out something valuable in one alien\'s house. Then, he finds a container with fluid which is exactly the substance that one of the elite alien tries to obtain to launch the spacecraft again which is hovering over the Johannesburg to return to his planet. With curiosity, he opens it and splits it accidentally on his face.Then, the transformation process begins.First he experiences the vomit behavior, then the dizzy feeling, the nose bleeding with black substances. More seriously, he begins to lose teeth and nails, then an alien hand appears and scales protrude from his skin, all of which illustrates that he is becoming an alien. The transformation of his body from being a human being an alien causes the changes both in self-recognition of Wikus and the opinion of others on him since there is a close relationship between the body and the identity. Body is central to the identity formation since people who is controlled by discourse and power relations are more likely to categorize people different group according to the body differences. So, this part, based on body and identity theories, will reveal the deep meaning of the transformation of body: the identity 45 shift, besides that, based on the identity shift, the author will explore the reactions of both the outer world and the inner world of Wikus, such as the cruel treatment of his colleagues, the betrayal of his family, and the struggles that Wikus make to come back to the human world. Due to the identity shift, things experience a different trend. Based on the cruel treatment from human, the author will draw the conclusion that human is greedy and cruel only if Wikus presents a different identity. For Wikus, being abandoned by human, he has no choice but to live like a prawn in District 9. Having experienced the cruelty of human, he still tries to identify himself with human by curing his transformation. In search for the cure for his transformation, he cooperates with the prawn and identifies himself with the alien partly through which he experiences the true emotion and love of the prawn to him and his sons. So, this causes a contradiction of his previous thought. These two reactions both from the outer world and the inner world illustrate that aliens are stereotyped and it is a satire to the racism possessed by human. 3.2.1 Identity: Body and Mind Being contaminated by the foreign fluid, Wikus experiences a transformation of body to the alien appearance, which makes the change in identity. Identity concerns about the process of identification which usually imply and rely on the recognition of difference. (Rattansi115)For example, being black, female and young are possible on the basis that others are categorized as white, male and old. Therefore, identities are defined in a relation of the difference of what it is not, meaning that all identities have their others making them realize the difference between them. And thecharacteristic that identity is formed based on the identification of what is not or what is different from them means that any identity is potentially open to be threatened and destabilized by identities that are being denied. Thus, identities are constructed within differences. Identities, are not completely fixed in time and space since individual identities are relatively provisional and open to transformation. This opinion is further explained by Stuart Hall. According to him, identities are never 46 unified, instead, they are increasingly fragmented and fractured; they are never singular but multiply through different discourses, practices and positions. They are constantly in the process of change and transformation.(Hall4)That is to say, identity is often under the threat of being changed. Because identities are about questions of becoming rather than being: not \"who we are\" or \" where we come from\" but what we might become, how we have been represented and how we might represent ourselves remain questionable. Just as Hall claims in his work\"We should consider identity as a production, which is never complete, always in process, and always constituted within, not outside representation.\" (Weedon 5)So, the identity which is under threat of change is determined by the representation. And, according to Foucault, identity is constructed through discourse which controls the representation and he regards the \"discourse of identity as part of specific discursive fields that are structured in relation to a range of cultural and other institutions.\" (Weedon 18) Thus, the identity is constructed within discourse and within the relations of power. In the construction of identity, body is central because basically, identities are constructed through the marking of difference, and the most notable difference occurs on the body. Just as Johnson points out in his book that body plays an important role in the creation of meaning and its understanding and our embodiment in and with the physical and cultural worlds and itdecides what is meaningful to us and determines the way of our understanding.Body is concrete, however, the power of relations or the discourse can endow the concrete body with abstract ideologies and the discourse of body determines the meaning of the body. Some specific perspectives are set up bycultural model from which \"certain parts of the body and certain aspects of bodily experience are viewed as especially salient and meaningful in the understanding of those abstract concepts.\"(Gibbs145-166) Thus, the discourse or the power of relations in Foucault\'s account determines the meaning of body. The competition in meanings from different regimes seek to give different meanings to bodies according to gender, sexuality, skin color, age and 47 physical ability. And the body is central to the construction of identity since people are more likely to categorize people according to their body difference. In this film, Wikus, the main actor who is originally a human, and receive the identification of the human beings and also presents some characteristics of this group, such as the superior status over aliens and construct the racism ideas which are endowed through the ideologies perverting in the human group implemented by the power relations. In this sense, the human body is defined as superior while others are not. Then, Wikus is under the process of transformation aliens. The body change others makes the process of identification fail which leads to the identity shift aliens, which makes the whole human fight against him and through the discourse of others,Wikus\'s self-recognition begins to change. 3.2.2 The Reaction of the Identity Shift: Human’s Greed and Cruelty Human, purporting them as the superior over other aliens, have constructed the racism ideology on these aliens. Based on what is stated in some theories, the discourse and the power relations of human constructed specific meanings on the body which is originally concrete and human makes this concrete body abstract meanings by using the penetration of ideologies. \"Body is constructed by, shaped and reshaped by the intersection of a series of disciplinary discursive practices. \"(Hall11) It is the body with signifying systems which is constructed by human produces meaning and identity. Just as Peter Stallybrass and Allon White point out that the body is connected with the social formation, since the meaning of body is decided by them. The body is not a purely natural given thing, it is a way for people to decode the meaning in other areas. (49) So, the body is regarded as a site upon which meaning is both constructed and contested. As human, they endow the alien body the inferior meaning: being brutal, non-organizational and many other bad connotations. Just as Grosz points out in her work that the surface of the body binding individuals to systems of significance in which they become the signs to be read by others and themselves and bodies can mean something because they are coded with and as 48 signs.Thus, when then main actor Wikus presented the alien body, human naturally possesses the rival position over him since body is the main identification for identity. They take many brutal actions to fight him since Wikus has presented the alien identity, which illustrates that human are greedy and brutal. The first one is the pursuit of his profitable body since he is the first one who survives in the contamination of the foreign fluid and presents the transformation process. When Wikus is sent to hospital and diagnosed as being under the process of transformation, he is forcibly taken away to an experiment room where the aliens are dissected by researchers to find out the secret of launching the foreign weapons. ( An experimental room full of dissected aliens for experiment purposes) Then, the researchers force the Wikus to fight on the aliens who are used as a target in purpose of testing his foreign hand to use the foreign weapon. After knowing that his hand can initialize the foreign weapons which can be valued millions of dollars, the minister decides to dissect him in order to get the technology of using foreign weapons. (00:40:46,358 -->00:41:03,558There are people out there, governments, corporations, who\'d kill for this chance. Will he survive the procedure? -No, of course not. We need everything. Tissue, bone marrow, blood. The procedure is gonna basically strip him down to nothing.) Treating him as an alien cruelly since he presents the alien body, human just want to make full use of him regardless of his begging. The researchers called him a specimen instead of a human with cold-bloodness. (00:41:42,275 49 -->00:41:50,917We\'re starting to harvest material from the specimen. We\'ll start with the soft tissue first. Cut through the chest cavern. We need to get the heart outas quickly as possible.)In order to catch Wikus after his success escape from the experiment room, human do everything they can to get him both from the physical arm force and the ideological force. In the physical arm force, they send out all troops to find him. ((00:42:25,468 --> 00:42:56,056Control, this is Bird Dog 7, we have set up at all major exits to the city.) In the ideological force, human purport him as an extremely dangerous man in public, and claims some rumors about him in the purpose of controlling the people\'s mind and using them to fight against Wikus through the media. (00:43:18,468 --> 00:43:50,056Wikus Van De Merwe, white Male, Mid30s, is considered extremely dangerous 00:45:18,746 --> 00:45:39,394We interrupt this program to bring you breaking news.Apatient has escaped from the isolation ward and is loose in the city. Wikus Van De Merwe was recently apprehendedafter prolonged sexual activity with aliens in District 9. is causing bodily disfigurement.) According to media theories which are mentioned previously, media is just a tool for the controlling class to infuse certain ideologies to the public through representations. By making full use of the publicity and popularity of media, the controlling group can easily spread some misrepresented information to the public so that they can guide the public opinion to achieve the specific aim.(00:46:57,624 -->00:47:08,544The entire world was watching him. He was on every radio station, every image on television, anything you could find had his face on it.)Thus, in this film, the controlling group spread some misrepresented information about Wikus to make the whole human stay away from him and establishes a rival emotion on him so that they can get Wikus more easily since the public want the horrible specimen under control in the purpose of getting the most valuable thing in the world: his 50 transformation body.(00:45:42,481 -->00:45:55,803It\'s highly contagious and the police warns people, to stay at least 20 meters away from this man.If you have any informationregarding the whereabouts of Mr Van De Merwe, contact us immediately on 0800-stop-wikus.)Besides that, a faction who is undergoing the business of selling cat food to the aliens in the District 9 is also in the pursuit of Wikus transformation body because they believe that by eating his body, they can also be endowed with the magic to use foreign weapons. They try to cut down his hand and eat it. In a word, judging from the behaviors that human presents after knowing that his hand is capable of using the foreign weapons, such as conducting the dissection experiments on him, using the power of media to make the public believe that Wikus is dangerous for the society and so on, the conclusion that human is greedy and cruel in the treatment of the one who is not identical with them, presenting the racism ideas. The second one is the betrayal of his most intimate friends and family. The transformation of the human body alien body presents the identity change for human which means that human are no longer identifying Wikus as one of their members. When Wikus escapes from the experiment room, he tries to keep in contact with his friends. Unfortunately, no one is willing to help him because they regard Wikus as a horrible alien and the only thing that they want to do is to stay away from him.(00:44:23,429 -->00:44:32,289 He tried calling me. Anton, it\'s me! It\'s me! Accept the call! I\'ve been friends with you for fokkin\' 13 years, man!)More importantly, his family, including his father-in-law who had previously promoted him as the leader for the eviction mission and shows a great deal of trust on him and his wife who he loves most betray him. Contrary to the previous trust on Wikus, when his father-in-law finds out that his transformation body is the most valuable business on this planet since his body can innovate the technology to use the aliens\' weapons, he treats him like a product and agrees the researchers to conduct dissection operation on him on matter how hard Wikus tries to beg him.(00:41:05,961 --> 00:41:08,649 Please help me. Don\'t let them do it.) Besides that, he even hide the 51 truth about Wikus and lies to his daughter that Wikus has sexual activity with the aliens which is the reason that he is sick. And his wife, who have learned that he has become one of the aliens refuses to keep in contact with him, which makes the desperate Wikus more heart broken.(00:03:19,220 -->00:03:42,534They say that you\'re becoming one of them. I can\'t do this... I don\'t want you to hold me again.)All this illustrates that the transformation of body makes people have a different opinion and different attitude on him. These friends and his beloved family stands away and betray him. All this cruelty and the greed shown by human during the transformation process of Wikus from human alien are contrast to their behaviors when Wikus is still human. Once the identity change which is caused by body in human\'s eyes, human would treat him as another inferior and still valuable specimen even though they know that Wikus still remains as a human in his minds except the body changes. 3.2.3 The Inner Struggle of Being Human Wikus, who has undergone the process of transformation after being exposed to the foreign fluid, experiences a different treatment from human since human categorize him as aliens based on his similar appearances with aliens. Based on the theories posed previously, identification is a vital process for the identity construction. So, for Wikus, even though he is undergoing some changes on his body, he still makes every effort to seek identification with human since he is endowed with the social identity with human through the ideologies. But first, in the slow transformation process, he is experiencing some specific changes in his body which will partly change his self-recognition about himself and also destroy the identification with human. According to Kristeva\'s abjection theory, she claims abjection as \"the ambivalent process of subject formation in which elements that the self cannot assimilate are expelled, disavowed and designated repugnant.\"(Roberts4)In her masterpiece In Power of Horror, she describes that the subject separates the self from what it is not by expulsing the materials that are not fit 52 in this self. And this process of expulsion laid the foundation for the definition of subject/object both on individual and group identity and for the theory that the subject is shaped through its fraught and complex relationship with its own corporeality.(Kristeva 16) So, in order to maintain its integrity, the body will exclude the things such as body waste through the responses of revulsion and disgust to escape the threat of destroying the illusion of a unified, autonomous subjectivity.As Kristeva points out in her book that this expulsion occurs not for the lack of cleanliness or health that causes abjection but what disturbs identity, system, order. (4) So, the things disavowed and expelled are the things that are not suitable for the identity. And based on Kriteva\'s theory, from Harris account, he further claims that the construction of cultural or group identities is constructed by the logic of abjection which is activated by the incompatible elements with the identity which must be deposited so that they can separate itself from other. (Roberts 9)So, in this film, the changes happening on Wikus body such as the nose-bleeding, the falling fingers and the protruding scales are all the indicators for the identity shift since based on the theories above, the body will abject all elements what are not suitable for the identity. So, possessing the human identity, Wikus has the fingers, the teeth, the hobby for hamburgers, and many fast food. However, undergoing the process of transformation, he presents many abnormal changes for human, such as the sharp fingers, the protruding scales, the falling nails and so on, all of which can be regarded as the abjections for the original identity according to the abjection theories since the human appearance can\'t suit the different identity. Thus, these all body changes signify the opportunity of identity shift. However, even though he presents some of body differences and changes, he still seek to identify with human and try to cure his transformation body. The first action that he takes is to contact with his friends and family to prove that he is still one of them and seek identification with them by claiming that nothing different is happening on him. Knowing that the transformed hand that makes him different from 53 others and makes others fail to identify with him, Wikus even tries to cut his hand so in hope that he can come back to the human world and live a normal life as before. (Wikus is trying to cut his hand with a axe) Even though he shows the sign of transformation aliens, he still possesses racism ideologies like human which presents that his mind is still human at first, which is shown when he finds out that the elite prawns try to launch the spacecraft and get away. (00:08:07,881 -->00:08:19,279 What is he saying about the fuel? Are you trying to start this thing. Are you little fuckers trying to start this and get away? 80 Never mind. Yeah, you sneaky fokkin\' prawns.Yeah, you sneaky fokkin\' prawns.00:07:43,761--> 00:07:55,417For 20 years you\'ve... had this fokking\' thing in here? Jesus, this is very illegal. I mean, this is a find, you know. I wish they catch you with this.)However, with the media representation, no one are inclined to believe him. After being abandoned and betrayed by his friends and family which illustrates that he still makes every effort to get identification with others, Wikus decides to save him by himself after hearing that the elite alien and his son can cure him accidentally on condition that they can come back to their planet when he is begging for the prawns the help him in the district 9 since he has nowhere to escape. (00:06:09,397 -->00:06:14,519Sir... please sir, you have to help me. I\'m losing blood, they\'re trying to kill me. 00:08:34,592 -->00:08:43,452 turn this prawn hand a human hand? You can make me human again? We have medical machines on themother ship that can fix you. Yes.) 54 This begging has illustrated the satire that the previous rival has become the saver and also presents that Wikus will have a change in his mind. And the son of the elite alien tries to identify with him since he has the same hand as he does which resembles that this alien appearance with the Wikus has acquired the identification of prawns and is regarded as one of their members. ( 00:09:29,174 -->00:09:35,156 Why does he keep looking at me like that? -He likes you. We are the same).In order to get his hand back to human hand, Wikus decides to assist the elite aliens to regain the fluid that is confiscated by MNU. Even with the different intention, this is the first time that he stands by the prawn instead of the rival position and tries to cooperate with him to fight against the human.It is in this moment that he begins to consider prawns in a different opinion since he breaks the embedded ideologies that human should regard prawn as rivals and inferior species and give them many stereotypes. And through the cooperation with the prawns to get the fluid to fight with the human, he finally realizes the status of prawn in the human\'s eyes and begins to help the prawns to go back to their planet. And in the danger of losing life with the fight with humans, it is the alien robot which identifies the transformed hand of Wikus and saves his life. Moved by the true emotion of the father and son, he escorts the elite aliens the aircraft even at the risk of his life and makes his every effort to protect the aliens the aircraft since. So, in the cooperation with the prawns to get the fuel for the aircraft, he truly realizes that the racial ideologies about the aliens such as brutal, violent and so on is untrue, which causes the contradiction of what he previous held for the aliens. And at the final stage when he is in danger of death, it is the stereotyped aliens that help him when he is in danger, which is a satire for the human behaviors to the Wikus: making full use of his valuable body and abandoning him. 55 Finally, after the leave from earth of the two aliens driving the aircraft, Wikus who is heavily injured by helping the two aliens to launch the aircraft is pursued and attacked by the soldier who shows deep hatred to the aliens in the location of District 9. Without weapons, he can\'t fight with him but to wage a deathbed struggle. At this moment, the aliens who are wondering around them with no destination (according to the description of human) save Wikus by tearing the soldier pieces after recognizing his transformed arm and other characteristics of aliens on him. This is where the satire resides in. Since the appearance of alien characteristics of Wikus, he is treated cruelly by human who only wants the interests even at the expense of his life and he is expelled from the human group. However, at the moment of life and death, it is these aliens who save him instead of human, which serves as satire that these aliens are not the same as human described. They can accept the one who transforms from a human an alien and save his life while the human group can\'t spare a man who is accidentally infected by aliens\' fluid. Instead of helping Wikus deal with the infection, human treated him as an experimental object in pursuit of gaining the advanced technology of using the aliens\' weapons. Throughout the whole film, aliens are discriminated by human since they believe aliens are cruel, lack of discipline, but at the end of film, it is these aliens stereotyped by human express the most true emotion that one should show to his same kind. This satire expresses the theme of anti-racism in this film. Even though the effort Wikus makes to struggle for being a human again, hestill can\'t resist the transformation process and becomes a prawn at last after experiencing the situation that these aliens are confronted. Being a prawn in the appearance makes him no place to hide himself except District 9 where these aliens areliving. Without the same characteristics of human body, he is abandoned by his family and friends even the whole human kind. 3.3 Being other: the Shift of Identity 56 (The appearance of Wikus after the transformation) However, he stillpresents the human emotions to his wife by making her plastic flowers even though he has totally become an alien in appearances. (00:52:45,757 -->00:53:04,285 I found this at my front door. As if somebody had just left it there. My friends say that I should throw it away, cause it\'s just a piece of rubbish. That it couldn\'t possibly come from him. I know it\'s true.) All this illustrates that even though he has the different body from human, he still possesses the human emotions in his heart, which clearly overturn the ideology that people hold that people categorize others in body difference and endow them inferior and set meanings through the discourse and power relations to present the superiority of human. It is regarded as a satire for the racism held by human whichalso presents the theme of the whole film of anti-racism. 57 Conclusion In this essay, the author tries to reveal the anti- racism theme of the film through the analysis of three aspects from different levels in District 9. Concerning about the background setting, the similarities between the Apartheid in South Africa and this film can contribute to the conclusion that they are closely related and there is an intention of the director to make such a choice. After analyzing the film, the author reveals the implication for this delicate arrangement: to express the theme of anti-racism. From the perspective of the main two sides appearing in this film: the human and aliens, the author further proves her statement of anti-racism theme of this film by analyzing the conflicted relations between them and exploring the reasons that lead to this situation on the basis of some racism and stereotyped theories. By contrasting the superior human and the stereotyped aliens, it is easily seen that human are possessing the higher status. However, in this film, the human\'s failure of preventing the escape of the aliens even though they claim they are superior leads to the satire of the racism ideologies for the human, contributing to the formation of the theme of anti-racism. Finally, the author analyzes the main actor Wikus to prove her theory. By analyzing the reactions concerning about the transformation of body of Wikus from other human and himself based on some identity theories, there is a controversy in him that the previously superior human who conduct many cruel activities on these aliens is saved and moved by the aliens at the end of the film. This also contributes to the anti-racism theme of the film. In a word, through analyzing the film in three aspects, we can easily draw the conclusion that the director tries to express the idea of anti-racism through the film. The reveal of the theme of anti-racism in this film is significant for modern society. The previous researching materials about this film from both home and abroad mainly focus on the human nature and identity issues. However, this paper tries to analyze the film through a racism aspect and reveals the theme of this film is 58 anti-racism, which provides a different and novel aspect for the audience to ponder on this film. Besides, the exploration of the anti-racism film can perform as a warning function for modern people for that it can be a reminder for people to avoid racism in current society, and learn a lesson from the history and provide them an opportunity to consider about the racial problems in modern society. 59 Works Cited Adam, Heribert, and Kogila Moodley. South Africa without Apartheid: Dismantling Racial Domination. Berkeley: U of California P. 1986. Althusser, Louis.\"On Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses (Notes towards Investigation).\" Lenin and Philosophy. Trans. Ben Brewster. London: New Left Books, 1971. 121-73. Anthony, Moran BA(Hons). Modernity, Racism and Subjectivity. Diss. U Melbourne, 1995. Ann Arbor: UMI, 2006. Ashmore, Richard D., and Lee Jussim, eds. Self and Identity: Fundamental Issues. New York: Oxford U P, 1997. Atkin, Albert. The philosophy of Race. England: Acumen Publishing Limited, 2012. Augoustinos, Martha, and Katherine J. Reynolds, eds. Understanding Prejudice, Racism, and Social Conflict. London: Sage Publications Ltd, 2001. Baldwin-Ragaven, Laurel, London Lesley, and du Gruchy Jeanelle. An Ambulance of the Wrong Color: Health Professionals, Human Rights and Ethics in South Africa. Cape Town: U of Cape Town P, 1999. Bhabha, Homi K.. The Other Question: the Stereotype and Colonial Discourse. London: Sage Publications, 1999. British Parliamentary Human Rights Group. South Africa and Human Rights. By Brian Wrobel. London: House of Commons, 1989. 68. Brooker, Peter. A Glossary of Cultural Theory. London: Oxford U P Inc, 2003. Carlo, Comanducci. “Metaphor and Ideology in Film.” Diss. U of Birminghan, 2010. Chike, Jeffers. “The Cultural Theory of Race: Yet Another Look as Du Bois’s ‘the Conservation of Races’.” Ethics 123.3 (2013): 403-426. Cohen, Anthony P.. Self Consciousness: An Alternative Anthropology of Identity. London: Routledge, 1994. 60 Cyrus, Virginia. Experiencing Race, Class, and Gender in the United States. California: Mayfield Publishing Company, 1993. Denzin, N.K.. Foreword. Lines of Narrative: Psychosocial Perspectives. Ed. Molly Andrews, Shelly Day Sclater, Corinne Squire and Amal Treacher. London: Routledge, 2000. Devine, Patricia G. \"Stereotypes and Prejudice: Their Automatic and Controlled Components.\"Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 56.2(1989):5-18. Dyer, Richard. The Matter of Images: Essays on Representations. London: Routledge, 1993. District 9. Dir. Neill Blomkamp. Perf. Sharlto Copley, Jason Cope, and David James. TriStar Pictures, 2009. Film. Fiamingo, G. “The Conflict of Races, Classes, and Societies.” The Monist 7.3 (1897): 380-414. Foucault, Michel. Power/knowledge: ed Interviews and Other Writings 1972-1977. Ed. ColinGordan. Trans. Gordan et al. Brighton: Harvester, 1980a. ---. The Archaeology of Knowledge. London: Tavistock Publications, 1972. Frank, Roslyn M., Rene Dirven, and Tom Ziemke, eds. Body, Language and Mind Volume 2: Socio-cultural Situatedness. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter GmbH& Co. KG, 2008. Frederick, Johnston.\"White prosperity and white supremacy in South Africa today.\" South Africa : Sociological Analyses. eds. A. Paul Hare etal.. Cape Town: Oxford U P, 1979. 358. Frosh, Stephan. Identity Crisis: Modernity, Psychoanalysis, and the Self. London: Macmillan Education, 1991. Georgakopoulou, A. \"Plotting the Right Place and the Right Time: Place and Time as Interactional Resources in Narrative.\"Narrative Inquiry 13.2 (2003): 413-32. Gibbs, Raymond W.. \"Taking Metaphor Out of Our Heads and Putting It Into the 61 Cultural World.\"Metaphor in Cognitive Linguistics. eds. Gibbs and Gerard J. Steen. Amsterdam: John Bejamins, 1999. 145-166. Giliomee, Hermann, and Lawrence Schlemmer. From Apartheid to Nation-Building. London: Oxford U P, 1989. Goldberg, David Theo. Racist Culture: Philosophy and the Politics of Meaning. Massachusetts: Cambridge P, 1993. Grosz, E. \"Bodies and Knowledge: Feminism and the Crisis of Reason.\" Feminist Epistemologies. eds. L. Alcoff, and E. Potter. London: Routledge, 1993. 187-195. Hall, Stuart. \"Culture, the Media and the Ideological Effect.\" Mass Communications and Society. Ed.J. Currean, M. Gurevitch and J. Wollacott.London: Edward Arnold, 1977. 258. ---. Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices. London: Sage/Milton Keynes: Open U, 1997b. 25-28. ---. \"Encoding and Decoding\" Culture, Media, Language. Ed. Hall, D. Hobson, A. Lowe and P. Willis. London: Hutchinson, 1981. 131. Hall, Stuart and Paul Du Gay. Questions of Cultural identity. London: Sage Publication Ltd, 1996. Hallam, Elizabeth, and Brian V. Street, eds. Cultural Encounter: Representing “ Otherness”. London: Routledge, 2000. Hamilton, D.L.and Sherman, J.W. \"Stereotypes.\"Handbook of Social Cognition. 2nd ed. Ed. R.S. Wyer and T. K. Srull. Hillside, NJ: Erlbaum, 1994.1-68. \"Identity.\" Oxford English Dictionary. 2nd ed. 2002. Johnson, Mark. The Body in Mind: the Bodily Basis of Meaning, Imagination and Reason. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1987. Jones, Matthew. \"District 9 (Review).\"Film & History: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Film and Television Studies 40.1 (2010): 120-122(review). 62 Davis, Jude, and Carol R. Smith. Gender, Ethnicity and Sexuality in Contemporary American Film. Edinburgh: Keele U P, 1997. Kapatein, Helen. \"The Hysterics of District 9.\" English Studies in Canada 40.1 ( 2014): 155-175. Karen, Bowdre M.. “Passing Films and the Illusion of Racial Equality.” Black Camera 5.2 (2014): 21-43. Katz, P. A. \" The Acquisition of Racial Attitudes in Children.\"Towards the Elimination of Prejudice. Ed. Katz. New York: Pergamon P, 1976. 125-154. Kristeva, Julia. Power of Horror: An Essay on Abjection. Trans. Leon S. Roudiez. New York: Colombia U P, 1984. 4, 16. Lothe, Jakob. Narrative in Fiction and Film: An Introduction. NY: Oxford U P, 2000. Lacan, Jacques. \"The Mirror Phase As Formative of the Function of the Eye.\" Trans. A. Sheridan. Erits: A Selection. Ed. Lacan. London: Tavidtock, 1977. 1-7. Macrae, C. Neil, Alan B. Milne, and Galen V. Bodenhausen. \"Stereotypes As Energy Saving Devices: A Peek Inside the Cognitive Toolbox.\"Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 66.1 (1994): 37-47. Marger, Martin N.. Race and Ethnic Relations: American and Global Perspectives. The United States: Wadsworth Publishing, 2000. Meredith, Martin. Mandela:A Biography. New York: Simon and Schuster, 2010. 95. Milazzo, Marzia. “Reconciling Racial Relations in Post-Apartheid South African Literature.” Research in African Literature 47.1 ( 2016): 128-148. Miles, Robert. Racism. London: Routledge, 1989. Mulvey, Laura. Visual and Other Pleasures. Bloomington: Indiana U P, 1989. Phillips, Michael. \"\'District 9\' stars Sharlto Copley, Jason Cope, David James.\" Chicago Tribune. 14 August, 2009. Web. 12 Dec 2016. Pirie, G.H. \"Travelling under Apartheid.\"The Apartheid City and Beyond: 63 Urbanization and Social Change in South Africa. Ed. D M Smith. London: Routledge, 1992. 172–81. Rattansi, Ali. Racism: A very Short Introduction. London: Oxford U P, 2007. Rieder, John. \"Race and Revenge Fantasies in Avatar, District 9 and Inglourious Basterds \"Science Fiction film and Television 4.1 (2011): 41-56. Roberts, Harris Garrod. Embodying Identity: Representations of the Body in Welsh Literature. Cardiff: Uof Wales P, 2009. Saks, Lucia. Cinema in the Democratic South Africa: the Race for Representation. Bloomington: Indiana U P, 2010. Schilhab, Theresa, Malou Juelskjar, and Thomas Moser, eds. Learning Bodies. Denmark: Danish School of Education P, 2008. Smith, Mark M.. How Race is Made: Slavery, Segregation, and the Senses. Chapel Hill: The U of North Carolina P, 2006. South Africa History Online. \"From the Western Areas to Sweto: Forced Removals.\"Sweto. South Africa History Online. 16Mar 2011. Web. 15 Feb 2017.
试阅到此结束,如需查看全部内容请购买正版文献。如因学习需要阅览全文,请联系站长。